SUNDAY LAWS FOR MINORS

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 12, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 19.

Read the full edition

SUNDAY LAWS FOR MINORS.

THE State of Alabama has no Sunday law, except for minors. Any person over twenty-one years of age is at liberty to do any kind of labor on Sunday except gaming, racing, and a few other acts which are prohibited. The Sunday law for minors was intended to protect them from being forced to labor on Sunday against their will by those having them under their employ. This law also applies to servants who are employed by persons not restricted by Sunday laws themselves, to prevent them from working servants on Sunday against their will. But on April 30, in the case of Brother W. J. Hasty, of Columbia, Ala., this law was interpreted by the decision of the jury differently from its original intent.
Brother Hasty was arrested on the charge of compelling his son to perform labor on Sunday which was not the customary domestic duties of daily necessity or comfort. The State had three witnesses, who did not pretend to testify further than that the work was done by the boy, knowing nothing at all of his being forced to do it. The State then called the boy as witness in the case, and he testified that his father never asked him to do the work, but, on the contrary, that on the day in question he, himself, proposed to his father that they plow on that day. He testified that in the work on the farm he had much to do with the planning of the work, he being eighteen years old; that he was a member of the Seventh-day Adventist Church, having joined on his personal conviction on the question of the Sabbath, which he now observed, and worked on Sunday as a part of his religious faith.
The State’s attorney argued the case, in face of this testimony, to the effect that the law presumed that when a minor and the parent did an act jointly, it was done under the direction or authority of the parent, and that under the persuasive influence of the parent, the minor was forced to do the work. He said it was unlike an Alabama boy to work of his own free will. This was quite enough for the jury to convict the defendant, even in the face of the following charge of the judge:—
“It is not whether the boy of the defendant worked on Sunday, but whether the defendant compelled him to do so; that is, did he force him to do such work? Before the jury can reach a conviction of the defendant in the case, they must believe from the evidence, beyond all reasonable doubt, and to a moral certainty, that the defendant compelled his son to work on the first Sunday in June, 1895; and unless this has been proved by evidence to the exclusion of every reasonable doubt, the jury should acquit the defendant. If the jury should believe, from the evidence, that the minor son of the defendant worked at the time, as said by the State, of his own volition, and was not compelled to do so by the father, then the defendant could not be guilty, and it would be the duty of the jury to acquit the defendant.”
The jury was out only a short time before reaching a verdict of “guilty,” with an imposed fine of $20, the limit of the law, with $31.70 costs, all of which is to be paid in the mines at hard labor for thirty cents a day.
Brother Hasty has a large family, and being now in the midst of his farm work, this unlawful enforcement of a law that was originally intended to protect the rights of a certain class of people, but is now enforced to deprive others of their rights, works an extreme hardship upon him. Old veterans who went through the war with Brother Hasty shed tears freely as he was shut up in the jail, and many of the younger men present, who had broad conceptions of justice, declared that it was an outrage upon the community; but none of them could understand why he refused to give bond for the payment of fine and cost, rather than face the disgrace of the jail, and bear all its hardships. This is a hard point for the people to comprehend.
D. W. REAVIS.