Did Christ Take Sinful Flesh? Examining the Question

50%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 5, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 18.

Read the full edition

Did Christ Take Sinful Flesh? Examining the Question

The question as to whether Christ partook of sinful flesh in his earthly experience, is one that is being discussed with some interest. It is by no means a new-comer on the field of theological discussion, having been, in various forms, debated, resolved, anathematized and blessed, approved and rejected, for ages. With us its solution must depend upon the understanding we have of the meaning of the term. First, the Bible does not say unequivocally that Christ had sinful flesh; but that he was “made in the likeness of sinful flesh.” And there may be a wide difference. If it be contended that sin exists only in the concrete, and that “sinful” means, literally, sin-full, then it cannot be said that Christ was sinful, or that he had sinful flesh, for that would be the same thing. If, on the other hand, we say that “sinful” is only a relative term, referring to the tendencies or liabilities, then it is true that he had sinful flesh, for he was “in all points tempted like as we are,” which could not be true of the divine nature. The power of temptation consists in the tendencies of the tempted one to yield. Temptations could have no power with a being who possessed only a divine nature. It is upon the human nature that temptation exerts its force. Christ’s “likeness” to sinful flesh made him subject to temptation; but it met in him a superior force, and he was, though tempted, “yet without sin.” Upon this point there can be no controversy between Christians; so the question resolves itself into that of how we use the term “sinful.”