AdventAI

QUERY

By J. G. Lamson

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 18., May 5, 1896

BY J. G. LAMSON.

(Bay City, Mich.)

WHY was Cain’s offering not acceptable to God?

The idea that Cain’s sin was in the quantity rather than in the quality of his offering, is warranted by the Septuagint translation of Gen. 4: 7: “If thou hast offered aright, but hast not divided aright, hast thou not sinned?” and by Paul’s allusion to the same (Heb. 11: 4), when he calls Abel’s offering “a larger,” literally, in the Greek, “a fuller sacrifice.”

The above question and answer appeared in the Canadian Baptist recently. The only reason for noticing it is the evident endeavor of the editor to take away from the offering required by the Lord, the only real merit there was in it. The idea of the one who answered the above question seems to be that Cain did not bring a large enough offering,—that is, that in making division of the fruits of the ground, he did not give the Lord his full share,—and God was displeased thereby. Also by italicizing the word “aright,” the idea is advancedp. 277 that Cain offered the right kind, but not the right amount.

In the account of this offering we read that Cain was angry because Abel’s offering was accepted, and his own was not. This anger was allowed to smolder till it found vent in the death-blow dealt to Abel while they were alone. John says, in regard to the killing, that it was done because Cain’s works were evil and his brother’s righteous. 1 John 3:12. It necessarily follows that the offering of Cain was not “aright,” for it was the wrong, or evil, in that offering that brought on the whole trouble. What, then, was there wrong in Cain’s offering? Paul to the Hebrews (chapter 11, verse 4) says: “By faith Abel offered unto God a more excellent sacrifice than Cain, by which he obtained witness that he was righteous, God testifying of his gifts: and by it he being dead yet speaketh.” Then the difference between the two offerings was the essential element of faith.

“Without faith it is impossible to please him.” Verse 6. Abel had the faith and obtained the witness of God’s pleasure, while Cain did not receive the approbation of God, because he lacked the faith. The trouble with Cain’s offering was that it did not show faith in the promised Saviour. “Without shedding of blood is no remission.” Heb. 9:22. And in Cain’s offering there was no shedding of blood. Had Cain shown faith in the Messiah (notice Gen. 4:7: “If thou doest well”), he would have been accepted; but if there was no faith shown, “sin lieth at the door.” If the offering was unmixed with faith, and the shedding of blood was God’s appointed way of showing that faith, there was no remission, and the sin was not removed.

The reason, then, why Cain’s offering was not acceptable to God, was not in quantity, but in quality.