It is customary with those who desire to evade the to them disagreeable fact, stated in prophecy and confirmed in history, that the papacy changed the Sabbath, to resort to various expedients for this purpose. A not unusual course is to assert that Sunday observance may be distinctly traced to a period of time prior to the establishment of the Roman Catholic Church, hence it cannot be true that the papacy changed the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week. A recent paper states the matter thus: “Now everybody who knows anything at all about history, knows that the first day of the week was observed by the primitive Christians long before the Roman Catholic Church had an existence. Justin Martyr and Tertullian make repeated mention of the first day of the week, or Sunday, in the second and third centuries.”
If this assertion is worth all that its authors claim for it, if the papal church had no hand in the change that some one has made in the observance of the Sabbath since God spoke the fourth commandment, then it follows that, (1) Seventh-day Adventists are entirely mistaken, to say the best that can be said of them; (2) the prophecy of Dan. 7:25, that the papacy should “think to change times and the law” (R. V.), has failed to receive a fulfilment; and, (3) the claim of the Catholic Church that it has changed the Sabbath is a false confession.
Before we adopt such a sweeping conclusion, let us see how well founded is this assertion. It consists of two propositions: The papacy, or the Roman Catholic Church, did not change the Sabbath, because it was changed before that church had an existence. The proof of this is the evidence that appears in various writings of the second and third centuries that Sunday was observed by the Christians of that time.
The alleged allusions to Sunday observance made by Justin and other Fathers have often been noticed in these columns, and their doubtful, indecisive nature or their spurious origin has been clearly shown. But let us allow all that can be proven for them. Let us acknowledge that in A. D. 140 Justin Martyr wrote that “on the day called Sunday, is an assembly of all who live either in the cities or rural districts, and the memoirs of the apostles and the writings of the prophets are read.” This is the earliest mention of Sunday in connection with regular religious observance which has a shadow of reliability, and it contains no mention of Sabbatic honors. But that point we will not now discuss. Let it stand for all that is claimed for it, and how does it affect the question at issue? It shows that by that time religious respect was being shown to the first day of the week. Beyond that point all credible trace of such observance disappears. There is nothing of it in the New Testament, and between the latest writing of the sacred volume and this time there is an impossible gulf of fifty years. But no doctrine has a sufficient basis that cannot trace its origin to the life and teachings of our Saviour. Paul says, “Be ye followers of me, even as I also am of Christ.” He also says, “Though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.”
It matters not one whit how close to the divine source we may trace a practise or doctrine, if it comes short of reaching back to that source, the sentence of the apostle is, Let it be accursed. We may trace the territory of a dominion to the very border line, but another step carries us into alien territory. So with authentic Bible doctrine; we may trace it all in clear and distinct terms through prophets and apostles to the very lips of Christ. We may read it in his life and character. But there the line is drawn. Whatever is of human origin is spurious. Yea, even though it proceed from a Father of the church, from an apostle, or from an angel—if it be not from Christ, let it be avoided; it is not good.
Evolutionists have not sought more agonizingly for the “missing link” to prove man’s ascent from lower animals, than have the friends of Sunday observance sought for those links of testimony which would connect their custom with apostolic practise, and then with the example and precepts of Jesus. They are missing indeed. And the moment that Sunday observance is cut adrift from all connection with sacred authority, it becomes an audacious interloper, a presumptuous usurper, bearing the stamp of Antichrist. Justin Martyr is no better authority for a religious practise, than is a man who lived ten centuries later.
Now when was the change in the observance of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day brought about? and when was the papacy brought into existence? The answer to these questions is in each case nearly identical with the other. No definite point within several hundred years can be indicated as the exact time when the papacy was developed and established; and the same is true of Sunday observance. They both grew out of the amalgamation of the church of Christ with the heathen world. In the matter of priority the establishment of the papacy has the precedence. The apostle Paul stated that “the mystery of iniquity doth already work.” 2 Thess. 2:7. This statement is made directly in connection with his prediction of the rise and development of the papacy, “the man of sin,” so that by an inspired writer we have the commencement of the papacy located in Paul’s day. No credible proof can be given that Sunday observance appeared in the church for three fourths of a century after that. But year by year the apostasy deepened in its darkness; the church strayed farther and farther from the Lord and his word; and as it did so, it nourished and cherished the false sabbath. At last the church obtained civil power. She was flattered and courted by emperors and princes. With the power thus obtained, she nourished her favorite offspring, the sign of her Heaven-defying power.
As the see of Rome became the center of the church, and the bishop of Rome become its recognized head; as the decrees of potentates and the force of arms gave power to the dicta of the church, the Romish Church stepped forth full-fledgedp. 217 in its arrogant assumption of heavenly prerogatives. Life and power were then imparted to Sunday observance, obloquy and reproach were heaped upon the true Sabbath, and a curse was placed upon its observers. Then “the very act of changing the Sabbath into Sunday” was flaunted before the world as an evidence of the power of the church of Rome over even the law of the Most High.
The above brief statement of the case we thoroughly believe to be true beyond successful controversy. We leave the reader to judge of the correctness or otherwise of the prophetic declaration that the papacy would change the law, of the claim of Roman Catholics that that church has changed the Sabbath, and of the statements that they have done so as made by Seventh-day Adventists. G. C. T.