TO CORRESPONDENTS

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 17, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 11.

Read the full edition

TO CORRESPONDENTS.

44.—In 1 Thess. 4: 16, 17 Paul speaks of the coming of the Lord, of the resurrection “of the dead in Christ,” and of the taking up of the living; but what becomes of the living wicked? C. R. B.
45.—If God is not the God of the dead, but of the living only (Matt. 22: 32), and as Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob died many years ago, does it not follow that they have an existence in another state? J. R. W.
No; we think not. By reading the preceding verses it will be seen that the resurrection of the dead was the subject in question; and Jesus was proving out of the Pentateuch, in which the Sadducees believed, though they rejected most of the Old Testament, the resurrection, which they denied. If God is still the God of Abraham, it shows that Abraham will have a resurrection. This was the argument, otherwise it would seem to have no force.
46.—(1) How long was Noah building the ark? (2) What would have been the result had Esau instead of Jacob received the blessing from Isaac? S. S. L.
I am not aware of any definite information. Noah preached for one hundred and twenty years. See Gen. 6: 3, and “Patriarchs and Prophets,” p. 96. Peter writes that Noah preached “while the ark was a preparing.” 1 Peter 3: 19, 20. It would seem appropriate that while the invitations of mercy were being held out, the means of salvation should also be preparing. (2) All through those patriarchal days we are struck by the value that was attached to the father’s blessing. This blessing was conferred by the laying on of the hands. Gen. 48: 13–19. This custom was transmitted to the gospel church. By the apostles the Holy Spirit was conferred by the laying on of the hands. By this means they were capable of transferring the blessing which they had received and enjoyed. It is probable that this was the case in patriarchal days. It rested with the father, as the priest of his own house, to place upon the son of his choice the special blessings that God had vouchsafed him. That the value of this blessing was not an imaginary thing, the bitter tears and lamentations of Esau abundantly testify. But in the case under question, I suppose that had Rebecca and Jacob trusted the matter to God, he would have seen that the blessing was placed where it belonged, on Jacob, and the long years of separation and servitude need not have been endured, and Esau would have suffered no wrong. It is thus, by taking the work out of God’s hands, that some of our most grievous mistakes are made. The case presented in the question is not supposable; or if it be so, we cannot tell how things would have been if they were not as they are.
47.—Where did the twelve tribes originate? how did they preserve their tribal relations? and how long did they continue? E. P.
The best answer to these questions is to be found in a study of the historical books of the Old Testament. Briefly, the tribes originated with the sons of Jacob. Genesis 46. The land of Canaan was parceled out to the tribes, and their boundaries clearly defined. See the book of Joshua. These distinctions seem to have been well preserved until the division of the kingdom in the time of Rehoboam. 1 Kings 12. After that the principal distinction was between Judah and Israel. The first embraced the tribes of Judah and Benjamin, and the second the other ten tribes. The Jews are the descendants of the former, while the latter became extinct as a separate people during wars and captivities with Assyria.
48.—(1) Does the expression, “And there was no more sea” (Rev. 21: 1) mean that there will not be any bodies of water called seas in the new earth? (2) To whom does the Lord refer in Job 38: 2, “Who is this that darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge?” to himself, Job, or Elihu? F. S.
(1) It is not unreasonable to suppose that the meaning of the expression is that the vast wastes of water which now cover three fourths of the earth will be no more. There will be rivers and streams there (Rev. 22: 1; Isa. 35: 6), and we may believe there will be pleasant lakes, but no oceans. It is probable that these were produced at the time of the flood. (2) To Job, undoubtedly. The Lord was answering Job’s arguments; but he had no reproof for Elihu.
49.—(1) Please explain Rev. 9: 15 through the REVIEW, as several are interested. It appears to me that this is a prophecy of time. (2) Please explain Prov. 26: 4, 5.
(1) You are right. The prophecy relates to the time of the supremacy of the Ottoman empire, and is one of great interest and value. But in this place we could hardly give space for its exposition, with the attendant facts. See “Thoughts on Daniel and the Revelation,” page 480 and onward. (2) It is difficult to know how to treat people who act foolishly, for if you answer them according to their folly, you make a fool of yourself; and if you answer them in wisdom, they cannot comprehend your meaning, and therefore consider their arguments unanswerable. Either way, there is difficulty. These are maxims, rather than commands. Solomon was not in favor of answering a fool, but of putting a rod on his back. Verse 3.
50.—Please explain Num. 28: 18. “In the first day shall be an holy convocation; ye shall do no manner of servile work therein.” A. M. H.
Reference is made to the first day of the feast, not the first day of the week. See verses 24 and 25. These were annual sabbaths. Lev. 23: 24–39.
51.—Please harmonize Matt. 1: 16 with Luke 3: 23. An infidel here says it cannot be done. He wants an answer.
A comparison of the two genealogies of Christ will show that they separate after David. Matthew gives David, Solomon, Rehoboam, etc.; and Luke gives David, Nathan, Mattatha, etc. They have no further agreement until they reach Joseph, the “supposed” father of Christ. Matthew follows the line of Joseph, and Luke follows that of Mary, both together showing that Christ was of the seed of David by a double line of descent. Joseph’s name is inserted in the place of Mary’s by Luke because the Hebrews never permitted women to enter their genealogical reckonings. When a family ended with a daughter, her husband’s name was inserted instead of hers.
52.—G. H. C. wishes the REVIEW to notice some marked paragraphs of a report of one of Ingersoll’s lectures, for the benefit of several inquirers. They are in substance as follows: (1) “The Bible says, After the flood some seventy people went into Egypt, and in fifteen years they had increased to 4,000,000. It says that there were 600,000 men of war. (2) We read that David built a temple forty-five feet high, with a porch one hundred and eighty feet high. Probably the architect was inspired. (3) Matthew says that Christ was born when Herod was king, and Luke says that it was when Cyrenius was governor; but according to Greek history and the annals of Rome, Cyrenius was not made governor until ten years after Herod was dead.”
Following up Robert Ingersoll, or any other railer against the truth, is not a profitable business. It is like following a crane, who tempts you into a swamp. He is at home in the muck and mud, while you will soon get stuck. However, these so-called criticisms are sometimes thrown into our faces in a way that it is difficult not to notice them. To criticize is one of the easiest things in the world. While the Lord has provided abundant grounds for faith, he has left sufficient room for doubt to those who choose it.
(1) This is one of Ingersoll’s mistakes. The children of Israel were in Egypt at least two hundred and fifteen years. The Bible does not give their number at the exode. The length of life was greater then than now. It is true that the result shows an unusual increase, and the Bible claims that it was so. Ex. 1: 7. But reckoning their number at 3,000,000, the ratio of increase would be by no means impossible, even if there were no miraculous intervention. (2) What of it? The portico, or façade, of the temple rose high above the main part of the building—a mode of architecture not uncommon then, nor unknown now. All the representations of the temple show it that way. (3) Various methods of explaining this apparent difficulty have been employed by commentators. One of these, which does not seem improbable, is that instead of the Greek word πρῶτη, translated “first,” we should have the two words πρὸ τῆς, in which case it would read: “This taxing was made before that when Cyrenius was governor of Syria.” But to my mind it is wholly unnecessary to twist the record to accommodate our imperfect understanding of the secular history of those days. It is not at all improbable that Cyrenius did occupy some place of authority before he was formally appointed governor. One thing is certain; we cannot afford to throw away the great weight of evidence we have in favor of the inspiration of the Bible because such men as Ingersoll can throw dust on some obscure points like the above.