AdventAI

INFALLIBILITY

By J. O. Johnston

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 7., February 18, 1896

BY J. O. JOHNSTON.

(Greenville, S. C.)

No doctrine of the Catholic Church is made more prominent than the dogma of her infallibility; and that there is a deep reason for this will be plainly seen upon a careful study of the subject.

Protestants hold that the papacy is the great antichrist, which the apostle Paul declared would arise as the result of the falling away of the true church of God; and in this professed church, Satan was to show forth the fulness of his power. 2 Thess. 2:3–10.

It has always been Satan’s ambition to be like God. “I will be like the Most High,” is his declaration concerning himself; and when he sought to instil this principle into the human family, it was with the same thought, “Ye shall be as gods.” It has ever been the ambition and purpose of Satan and his followers to exalt themselves to the place of Deity.

When Christ established his church on earth, Satan, true to his policy, also began the work of forming a church. This church he endeavored to make as near like the true as it was possible for him to do; and as Satan claims all the prerogatives of God, so his church claims all the power and authority of the true. But as Satan has absolutely nothing in harmony with God, so his church has nothing whatever in harmony with the true. Yet he has persuaded many to believe that he is God, and to worship him, and he has also led many to believe that his is the true church, and many thousands believe it at this day.

This, then, is Satan’s counterfeit of Christ’s church; and who will say that his Satanic Majesty is not the prince of counterfeiters? The danger in a counterfeit lies in its likeness to the genuine. A pewter dollar is not very dangerous; but the counterfeit which can only be detected by a thorough analysis of the metal composing it, is dangerous indeed. In order that this may be clearly understood, I quote from a standard Catholic work the following:—

“That the church was infallible in the apostolic age is denied by no Christian. We never question the truth of the apostles’ declarations.”—“Faith of Our Fathers, page 85.”

Let us study these two statements. The second sentence is certainly true, and cannot be questioned by any one who believes the Bible to be the inspired word of God. But this truth is only to deceive us into believing that the first statement is also true. This sentence we must carefully examine.

If the apostolic church was infallible, then it must be that that church never made a mistake. But that this is not the case, is evident from the fact that the apostles were all the time being called upon to set to rights things that were going wrong in the church. Take, for instance, the churches of Galatia. Paul said they were “removed . . . unto another gospel,” and had become “foolish” and “bewitched” and did not “obey the truth.” Surely no one would claim that this church was infallible—never erred. But were not the apostles the head of the church, and were not they infallible?—No, they were neither the one nor the other. Christ is the only head of the church (Eph. 5:23), and the church is his body. We nowhere read that the body of Christ has two heads.

Again: we find that the apostles were but fallible men. Peter, the boasted father of infallibility in the Catholic Church, was but a fallible man. We read that at one time, according to Paul, he “dissembled,” that he “walked not uprightly,” and “was to be blamed.” Gal. 2:11–14. Thus we find that neither the early church nor Peter himself was infallible, but they were both liable to mistakes.

The question then arises: Did not Peter write part of the New Testament? and is not this word infallible?—Yes, all that is written in the Bible is surely infallible. But did Peter really write any part of the Bible? Peter himself said that the Scriptures did not come by the will of man, but “holy men of God spake as they were moved [caused to write] by the Holy Ghost.” 2 Peter 1:21. And again, he tells us that it was the Spirit of Christ which was in them (the prophets) “that testified.” 1 Peter 1:11. Thus in the Bible we do not have the testimony of certain men, but the testimony, or words, of Christ himself and the testimony of the Holy Spirit. This is infallibility—in the church, but not of the church.

The doctrine of infallibility, then, is Scriptural; and the early church did have an infallible guide; but the church was not the guide. It was the thing guided. This guide was thep. 100 word of Christ, manifested in the church through the prophets, and by the direct operation of the Holy Spirit, and in no other way. And therefore a church can lay no claim to infallibility.