AdventAI

IS SUNDAY THE SABBATH?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 4., January 28, 1896

The Dayton (Ohio) Evening Herald of a late date contained the following communication from Elder W. L. Iles, to which the editor appended comments as seen below:—

“The church was founded by Jesus Christ, and he has all authority in it. The gospel commission only authorizes the church to teach whatsoever things Christ has commanded. As there is no command in the Bible for the observance of Sunday, it is contrary to the gospel commission to teach its sacredness. The apostolic church had the doctrines of Christ, but before the death of Paul men arose in the church preaching ‘perverse things,’ and the mystery of iniquity was already working in his day. Only a few years after the apostolic age the Christian church had accepted pagan rites and customs. The pagans had certain ‘mysteries,’ and the Christians, to be like them, turned the Lord’s Supper and baptism into ‘mysteries.’ Sunday was the high day of the pagan religion, and as the pagans were professedly converted to Christianity, they still held to Sunday, and thus it became the Christian’s ‘festival “Lord’s” day,’ as well as the pagan’s ‘festival sun’s day.’ The observance of Sunday as the Christian’s festival day began at or soon after the falling away of the Christian church, but did not take the place of Sabbath until after Constantine’s famous Sunday law in honor of the venerable day of the sun. By the councils of Nice and Laodicea it was decided to have ‘nothing in common with the Jews,’ and that ‘Christians should not Judaize and be idle on the Sabbath, but work on that day.’”

“The transference of Sabbath works to Sunday was done by the bishops of the Catholic Church between the years 321 and 386; but long before this time the Christians, not liking to call Sunday by its pagan name, had, professedly in honor of the resurrection, named it the Lord’s day. In the early centuries the Christians had no thoughts that Sunday was a sacred day, but worked on that day as on other working days. The ‘church’ received Sunday from the pagans, and Protestantism came out of Catholicism, bringing the idea of Sunday sacredness with them. If it has any sacredness, it was not given by God, but by the Catholic Church. The Protestant rule is ‘the Bible, and the Bible alone; and unless Sunday sacredness can be found in the Bible, Sunday should be considered a common working day.’”

The editor of the Herald remarks:—

“That one day was set apart as a day of rest and for devotional exercises, was wisely done. Its antiquity as such renders it venerable, and worthy of highest respect. Its necessity cannot be disputed, and its sanctity commands our highest admiration. In these days of agnosticism it is well, from an educational standpoint, to know the historical facts; but their dissemination in this instance cannot but commend the wisdom of setting apart such a day.”