THE TRIALS IN ONTARIO

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 17, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 51.

Read the full edition

THE TRIALS IN ONTARIO.

While you and I, dear reader, are enjoying the blessings of liberty, three of our brethren, all ministers, are under sentence of fine, or imprisonment ranging from forty to sixty days in the Chatham (Ontario) jail, having been convicted of working at worldly labor of the usual occupations on Sunday, Nov. 3, 1895.
Brethren A. O. Burrill, P. M. Howe, William Simpson, and Thomas Griffith were summoned to appear before Mr. George A. Watson, justice of the peace in and for the county of Kent, the first three mentioned to answer for laboring at “carpenter and mason” work, and the last for chopping wood, Nov. 10.
Darrell, where the work was done, is situated on the Erie and Huron Railway, four miles north of Chatham. The “informers” went to Justice Forham, of the latter place, but the justice refused to issue a summons, and when pressure was brought to bear, declared that he would resign first. Attorney Douglass, queen’s counsel, was visited first, and he advised the informers to wait, saying that the law in the case was not clear; and then further to show his idea that the prosecutions should not be begun, he sent a letter to the “settlement” in and about Darrell, advising them to the same purpose, but telling them to go on if they thought fit.
But there was a magistrate over at Ridgetown, twenty-two miles away, who has a reputation for his severity with the “hated sect,” and over to Ridgetown the prosecutor, Harvey Kennedy, went. Here his ardor met another dampener, for the prosecutors of brother John Matthews have allowed the justice who assisted them in sending Matthews to jail, to go without his pay all this time, and Magistrate Watson did not care to do business for nothing.
A second trip was made to Ridgetown, and on Nov. 27, twenty-four days after the alleged work on the building was done, summonses were issued, returnable Dec. 5. At that time a large hall was well filled to hear the Adventists tried, and at every point made by the prosecution, and every adverse decision made by the court, the crowd showed their approval by laughter, clapping of hands, and stamping of feet. These demonstrations were held quite well in check by the officer a part of the time, but in his absence and at the final verdicts the noise of the crowd was beyond the court’s control.
During the cross-examination of the first two witnesses, it became very evident to any unbiased mind that one of two things must be true,—either Attorney Watson had assurances that the decision would be for his side, and that he needed not to work very hard to get it, or else Attorney Watson was a very incompetent attorney, so far as the laws of evidence are concerned. Two witnesses were examined before dinner, one being the youth Kennedy, who laid the information, and the other a young friend of his by the name of French. Kennedy testified to having seen Elder Burrill mixing mortar on Nov. 3. This was in the morning, and the news spread so that at Sunday-school twelve or fifteen came down past the church lot, as they testified, for the purpose of “witnessing.”
Others testified that they had seen Mr. Burrill using a boring machine on a stick of timber, and one other, that Mr. Burrill got some sills ready for laying that day. The only testimony against brother Howe was that he stirred some mortar with a hoe; but this he positively denies, and on the witness-stand swore that the only work done that day by him was to carry a pail of water, and pour it in a barrel.
In order to make the Lord’s-day Act reach the ministers, the information was amended so as to allege that the brethren had two callings, that of minister and carpenter. Witness French swore that Mr. Burrill made a business of going round building churches and preaching in them.
In spite of the fact that Mr. Howe conducted tent-meetings in Darrell all last summer, the witnesses swore that they did not know that he was a preacher; and some of them were quite willing to swear that Burrill and Howe were laborers, and that they must be carpenters, or they would not be working at the carpenter’s trade.
At the conclusion of the taking of testimony, Mr. Watson opened for the prosecution, and was quite mild in his argument, maintaining that it was against public policy for sects of such diverse creeds to live together; that Sunday-keepers were vastly in the majority, and that it was not a good thing for the children of Sunday-keepers to be brought up where they could see so much work on Sunday; and so a stop should be put to Sunday work; and much more to the same effect.
Mr. Mills, for the defense, maintained that the statute was not applicable to preachers; that it was proved beyond a doubt that the defendant was a minister of the gospel, and that he had not performed work of his ordinary calling on the day in question. Mr. Mills had several typewritten pages of notes relative to the origin of Sunday laws, but they were all ruled out, and he was not allowed to read what he had so carefully prepared. He denominated the matter “religious persecution because of bigotry,” and challenged any one to gainsay that the Adventists were right as to the keeping of God’s law.
Mr. Smith closed for the prosecution, asking that a sufficient fine be imposed to make it improbable that Mr. Burrill would work on Sundays any more, maintaining that the law should be enforced as long as it remained on the statute-books, and that the magistrate had no other alternative. He said that if the Adventists did not like the law, the proper thing for them was “to agitate, agitate, go to jail, go to jail, every day and every day, till the legislature should say, ‘Here, we have a bad law, let us repeal it.’” More was said to the same purpose.
Mr. Burrill then asked permission to make some statements to the court, but the privilege was denied him.
The justice then pronounced Mr. Burrill guilty, holding as follows:—
“1. It matters not if Mr. Burrill is a minister; he did carpenter work on the Lord’s day.
“2. If Mr. Burrill both preaches and works at the carpenter’s trade, he is both a preacher and a carpenter, and both are his ordinary callings.
“3. I find him guilty of following his ordinary calling on the Lord’s day, Nov. 3, and sentence him to pay a fine of $20, which, if not paid in five days,—sixty days in jail.”
This was less than the usual time allowed for appeal, and when this was mentioned by Mr. Mills, the justice said, “I could make him pay it now if I wanted to, and five days is enough.”
In consequence of the adjournment of two of the cases till the 12th, the five days was later extended to the 16th.
In his argument to the court, Mr. Howe maintained that he had been guiltless of breaking the Lord’s-day Act, and that the statute did not define what the Lord’s day is.
When he touched upon the religious phase of the question, the prosecuting attorneys objected, and the court sustained them, so that Mr. Howe could not go into the matter to any very great extent. In the course of his remarks, he said, “Just let me speak for a few moments, and that is all I ask. I know there is no hope for me before this court, so there is no need of your worrying about the result. I just want to state why I am not guilty of this charge.”
The prosecuting attorney asked that the smallest fine ($1) be imposed, but the court was bitterly against the Adventists who stood before him, and imposed a fine of $10 or forty days.
For a moment even the enemy was stunned, and then came a boisterous approval from a bench full of young men sitting behind the prosecutors. While the majority seemed glad that Mr. Howe was convicted, and others wished the fine higher, there were some who thought it pure spite work on the part of the court; and a few of those who had been against Mr. Howe in the beginning, said that the judgment was shameful. It was now nearly eleven o’clock, and the cases of brethren Simpson and Griffith were put over for one week.
In accordance with the adjournment, last Thursday, the 12th, the court was again convened, and brother Simpson arraigned. He pleaded “not guilty,” and appeared without attorneys; but he had progressed only a little way when Mr. Mills and Mr. Coats both volunteered their services to assist in the trial, and this we heartily believe came from their appreciation of the true animus of the prosecutions, and their desire to aid the right side.
The trials were conducted along the same lines as those preceding, save only that the cross-examination was milder; yet, at the same time, some good points were made. But a conviction was inevitable, and the magistrate sentenced brother Simpson to $10 or forty days in jail, the same as brother Howe. The case of brother Griffith was then called, and the evidence showed that he was chopping wood in the bush on his father’s farm; and on the witness stand he swore that he had leased the farm, and hence under the statute of Ontario, being a farmer, he would be exempt from the Lord’s-day Act. This matter presented itself very forcibly to the justice, and he could not bring himself to decide against the defendant, so reserved his decision for one week. This will be next Thursday. We believe that if it is possible for the justice to do so, he will find the defendant “not guilty,” although it is hard to tell how courts and juries will decide, unless they have previously placed themselves on record, as was the case at Ridgetown. So closed the trials.
The bitterest feeling was manifest. A few months ago, brother Griffith would have resented any insult or slur against himself, without stopping to think about it; but the Lord has been working with his heart, and on the witness stand, in the face of insult and hard words, the power of God manifested itself in him, and he was as calm and careful as though he were in his own home. It was a vindication of the power of God to calm a tempestuous heart, and although the attorney threw at him such expressions as, “The Adventists must be proud of you,” “You are a pretty specimen,” etc., these expressions were met by the defendant with a smile, and his face and countenance never wavered. The Lord be praised for the victories he has given his people in Ontario! It is drawing them closer together, and they feel that their dependence is upon God; and may the angels of heaven now move upon the hearts of the judges of the high court, to which these cases have been appealed, so that our people may be given a little longer to do the work necessary to be done in Ontario. Let our prayers constantly ascend to the throne of grace, that the Captain of the Lord’s hosts will send his army to the protection of his believing children on the earth.
J. G. LAMSON.