A CONFESSION AND AN ACKNOWLEDGMENT

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 10, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 50.

Read the full edition

A CONFESSION AND AN ACKNOWLEDGMENT.

BY ELDER M. E. KELLOGG.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
THE Voice, of New York City, organ of the Prohibition party, excusing and sustaining the various schemes of so-called reform to which Miss Francis Willard would commit the society of which she is the president, says: “The truth is, most of the criticisms of the W. C. T. U., both now and heretofore, proceed on the assumption that the Union has but one object, namely, prohibition. The W. C. T. U. holds no less firmly to that object than it did at the start; but it has broader aims to-day than it had at first. It has been growing and developing, lo, these many years; and to-day its purpose, whatever may have been the case at the first, is not included in the one word ‘prohibition.’ The purpose now, as we view it, may be broadly stated as the application of the laws of God to political affairs; to carry the standards of morality and religion into national life; to bring about, not a union of Church and State, but a harmony between them; and to make the acts of the citizen conform to his acts as a Christian.”
The above attempted justification of the change which has come o’er the spirit of the dream of the W. C. T. U. is both a confession and an acknowledgment,—a confession of so great a change of its original purpose that it ought to change its name, and an acknowledgment of purposes, which, though veiled in honeyed phrases, betrays a scheme, the success of which would be dangerous to liberty and the best welfare of the whole country. The plan is to apply the laws of God to the political life of this nation. This is the object for which the W. C. T. U. is now in the field, and to attain this object it asks the help of all citizens.
But is there any general agreement as to what constitutes the laws of God, and where such laws are to be found, sufficient to form a basis for such remarkable legislation as that proposed?—There is not. Some people find their laws of God in nature, others, in revelation. Many people do not recognize such laws as existing anywhere, denying or doubting the existence of Deity. If the Bible is to be used as the revelation upon which this proposed legislation is to be based, it should be remembered that its laws are twofold, enforcing duties to God and to man. Then if a majority of the people of this nation should make laws upon this basis, duties to God would be enforced upon thousands of people who do not believe in God! We leave the reader to judge whether such enforced service would be pleasing to God or beneficial to men.
Moreover, those who accept the Bible as a revelation of God’s laws, do not agree in their understanding of it. Hundreds of religious sects, all pretending to draw their ideas of duty to God and man from the Bible, hold as many positions as there are sects. Now shall all the opinions of all these sects be enforced as the laws of God? Of course the opinion of the weakest sect as to what constitutes the laws of God, is worth as much as the opinion of the greatest; indeed, the history of the world shows that the minority have oftener been right than the majority. But it is certain that if an attempt should be made in this country to apply God’s laws to political affairs, it would be done, as it has been done in the past, by one church getting its ideas of what constitutes God’s laws enforced by the laws of the country, or by several joining and controlling all others. The W. C. T. U. is evidently attempting to do the latter. But whether one church succeeds in getting its ideas of the laws of God enforced upon all the people by law, or whether several churches, uniting upon what they can all agree, do the same, it will make no difference in the practical working of this plan upon those who are outside of it. It is a union of the Church and the State. And the Voice well knows that the authors and abettors of such a movement lay themselves open to the charge of seeking to unite the State with the Church, and so it hastens to deny it in advance. It is as a man contemplating a theft in a store, and seeing some one observing his movements, hastens to say, “I am not going to steal.”
Take the last statement quoted from the Voice. The object of the W. C. T. U. is here said to be to create “harmony” between the Church and the State by making “the acts of the citizen conform to his acts as a Christian.” This is precisely what the various unions between the Church and the State were for in past ages, and the enforcing of the laws of God, according to the ideas of the majority, caused the persecutions of which we read in history.
Again: if a citizen is a Christian, his acts as a citizen will conform to his acts as a Christian; if a citizen is not a Christian, the law will not make him a Christian, and outward conformity to distinctively Christian duties, while the heart secretly rebels, is nothing but hypocrisy. Such legislation would therefore result in dividing the people into three classes: Conformists, or those who belong to and sustain the State church thus established; non-conformists, who dissent from the interpretation of the laws of God enforced by civil law as held by the church party, and who would in consequence be persecuted for their non-conformity; and lastly, hypocrites, who outwardly conform for the sake of honors, money, and freedom from persecution. Such is the condition of things, which, according to the Voice, the W. C. T. U. is now in the field to secure. It is a confession and an acknowledgment that this society has entered the arena of politics; that it hopes to enforce its notion of what the laws of God are upon all the people, that Christianity and the State may be in harmony, and that general conformity to the ideas of God’s laws as held by the W. C. T. U. may be secured! Against the passage of any such act of uniformity, I protest, and would place myself on record in advance as an incorrigible non-conformist.