1. We promised last week to show that trine immersion is three baptisms, which is contrary to the scripture which says that there is only one baptism. This will appear upon a brief examination of the subject.
Trine immersionists never sprinkle, because they hold that the Greek word “baptize” means only to immerse. On this point, then, we stand upon common ground, that baptism and immersion are synonymous terms; that only immersion, or being buried in the water, is baptism. But we turn to Eph. 4: 5, and there we read that there is “one Lord, one faith, one baptism.” Inserting the equivalent term “immersion,” it would read as follows: “One Lord, one faith, one immersion.” But trine immersion means three immersions, whereas the apostle admits only one.
It may be urged that inasmuch as the Greek Church practices trine immersion, we ought to follow them in the interpretation of their own language. There would be more force in this claim if they were consistent with themselves; but while they are evidently true to the language when they immerse, because the commandment is to be baptized, they just as clearly depart from it by adopting three immersions, when Paul says there is but one; for trine immersion, as already noticed, is in reality nothing but three baptisms. To say that it is only one baptism with three immersions, is a contradiction of language, if baptism means immersion as they admit. It is equivalent to saying, There is one baptism with three baptisms, which would be absurd. To decide otherwise would be to admit that baptism is not identical with immersion; but that would be to throw the whole subject of the mode into doubt, and leave that question yet to be settled.
It further appears that their practice is not consistent with their theory; for they say that baptism is three immersions; and hence they could carry out the commission of Christ only as follows: “Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them [thrice immersing them] in the name of the Father, and baptizing them [thrice immersing them] in the name of the Son, and baptizing them [thrice immersing them] in the name of the Holy Ghost.” And thus nine immersions, instead of only three, would be necessary to fulfill the commission. Trine immersionists cannot possibly avoid this conclusion, unless they admit that they truly and properly baptize in each name by one immersion. But to say that one baptism is truly administered by one immersion, is fatal to their theory.
In favor of a plurality of baptisms, Heb. 6: 2 is sometimes quoted (“the doctrine of baptisms”). This certainly refers to a plurality of baptisms. Then why do they deny that they practice three baptisms? Where is the necessity for them to twist language into such a contradictory form as to say, “One baptism with three immersions”? Paul is correct in speaking of baptisms (plural), for there is more than one. There is the baptism of the Spirit, baptism of water, and baptism of suffering. To say there are three of any one kind, is to contradict the plain statement of Paul. There is only one baptism of the different baptisms spoken of.
Tertullian mentions three baptisms, by which it appears that the practice of trine immersion was beginning to be introduced as early as his day. The matter, however, is put in its true light, if Professor Stewart correctly quotes him as saying, “Thence we thrice immerse, answering (that is, fulfilling) somewhat more than the Lord has decreed in the gospel.”—De Corona Militis, § 3. Here he gives the whole practice away, by admitting that it is more than the Lord decreed; and the language of the gospels plainly shows that the Lord never decreed three baptisms, but only one. And when Paul emphatically says there is only one, to introduce more is to go beyond the word of the Lord.
2. We have said also that the practice of trine immersion is entirely out of harmony with the form of baptism set forth by Paul in Romans 6. There the apostle says that we are “buried with him [Christ] by baptism into death;” and again, verse 5, “Planted together in the likeness of his death.” Christ died for our sins, was buried, and rose again. 1 Cor. 15: 3, 4. Then death, burial, and resurrection, is the order brought to view, and which baptism is meant to represent; for, as being buried in the water is the likeness of Christ’s burial, the coming up out of the water is “the likeness of his resurrection.” That Paul has reference to this order in Romans 6 is evident, for he speaks first of our being dead to sin (verse 2), then being buried into Christ’s death by being buried with him by baptism (verse 4), then coming up from the water in the likeness of his resurrection. Verse 5. And we might ask right here with reference to the foregoing proposition, Did Christ die three times? was he buried three times? was he raised from the dead three times? And in the likeness thereof must the sinner backslide and die to sin three times? and be baptized three times? and be raised up out of the water three times?—Yes, according to the view of the trine immersionists, but not according to the Scriptures.
But trine immersionists plunge the candidate three times, face forward, into the water. Is that a likeness of Christ’s death and burial? The practice of the Jews must govern our ideas in this matter of form, and they laid their dead decently on the back in the tomb, not face downward. It would be repugnant to all our ideas of propriety, to bury our dead face downward. Christ was not so buried, hence that is not the form of baptism to be followed according to Romans 6.
To justify the forward action, it is sometimes said that Christ bowed his head upon the cross and gave up the ghost, and that makes the forward movement in baptism appropriate. If this be so, then the candidate should go into water of sufficient depth, so that simply bowing the head would cause the immersion of the whole body; but this is hardly possible. On the other hand, in trine immersion, we understand (for we have never witnessed the ceremony) that the candidate kneels down in the water, and then the whole forward portion of the body is plunged forward three times under the water. The Saviour did nothing of this kind on the cross, hence there is not here the least likeness of Christ’s death. Thus, from every point of view, our proposition is established, that trine immersion is contrary to the form of baptism set forth by Paul in Romans 6, and in all the Scriptures.
3. In trine immersion the significance of the ordinance is entirely lost. If the foregoing propositions have been proved, as we confidently submit that they have been, the one now before us follows as a matter of course. The significance of baptism lies in the showing forth of our faith in the death, burial, and resurrection of Christ; and the form of baptism must be such as to resemble, as nearly as may be, those great facts. If we go through a ceremony which has no resemblance to the burial and resurrection of Christ, the significance of our act as indicating that faith, is lost. The forward action and the three plunges, having nothing in common with the burial of Christ, cannot be the form to be followed.
It is sometimes said that baptism is the “door into the church.” If this be so, it is against the forward plunging; for in that case the candidate is raised up backward, and goes into the church in that manner. But one does not usually, when he goes to the house of a friend, and the door is opened, turn around and back into the house. We must have the backward movement in the burial in baptism, to have the forward movement in being raised up out of the water.
As to the $500 prize for proof of a single use of the backward action in baptism for several hundred years after Christ’s time, as noted in the question of our correspondent last week, we canp. 794 just as safely offer a prize of $5000 for proof of a single instance of the forward plunge during New Testament and apostolic times, which is the only safe and reliable period in the history of the Christian church. As we have already said, we care not how nearly an error can be traced to apostolic times, if it does not actually reach them, it has no ground for a claim of truthfulness. We care no more for the practice of the Greek Church on this point, than we care for the practice of the Roman Catholic Church in sprinkling, purgatory, Mariolatry, saint worship, Sunday-keeping, and a hundred other superstitions, which can be traced back to the very early days of apostasy in the Christian Church. A man may accept, and begin to advocate, the most monstrous errors in half a day’s time, if he will give himself up to his own vain imagination, and to the suggestions which the evil one is ever ready to instill into minds which are ready to receive them.
When we come to history on this subject, it deals only with these apostate times. Much is made of history by trine immersionists, for, as in the case of all traditions, their proof for their position is found only there. But history, even, does not sustain them, but in reality disproves their claims. To those who wish to examine this subject further, we commend the excellent work on Baptism, by the late Elder J. H. Waggoner, published at this Office, which thoroughly deals with the subject from both the Scriptural and historical point of view.
U. S.