A CORRESPONDENT writes us as follows upon this subject:— “I notice the Greek Church, the ‘Brethren,’ and perhaps some others use trine immersion. I also note that there is a $500 prize offered for proof of a single use of backward action baptism for several hundred years after Christ’s time. I also noticed recently that T. De Witt Talmage answered as to trine immersion, that ‘there was no doubt but it was the original form of baptism.’ I also note that some very excellent Greek scholars decide that the formula, as given in Matthew, cannot be fulfilled without three immersions. Is it possible that your church is not following Christ’s teaching in this particular, as the other churches are not doing as regards the fourth commandment? Please answer fully in the REVIEW AND HERALD, and oblige.”
It is certainly our sincere desire to follow fully the teachings of Christ in all things. But in the points noted above we fail to find any proof that Christ ever taught any such form of baptism. The “Greek Church,” the “Brethren,” the “$500 prize,” and “T. De Witt Talmage,” are of no account whatever with us, on a question which must depend on the direct testimony of the Scriptures themselves. We care not how near to apostolic times a doctrine can be traced, if it does not really touch their times, and cannot be found in the record they have given us, it is like a broken electric wire—the “current” of truth is not in it.
The only allusion to the teaching of Christ is in reference to the formula of Matt. 28 : 19 : “Baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost.” The whole question turns on the word “baptizing;” does it denote one action or three? It is said that that is a verb of repetition, and therefore denotes more than one action. Then we inquire, Why limit it to three? Why may it not mean more than three? Provided it is a verb denoting repeated action, is there any proof that the repeated action pertains to the same individual? Of course the act is repeated indefinitely, as the ministers of Christ baptize some in “all nations.”
But, it is urged, there are three names in the commission, and therefore the act must be performed three times. But it does not read, “in the names,” but “in the name,” showing that all are included in one name. The Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, therefore, constitute, with reference to the work of conversion, the name, so to speak, of a firm, all the members of which are equally concerned in the work. To perform a baptism in the name of each one separately destroys this unity. It is not so done in the ordinary transactions among men, and we should avoid giving to language in the Bible a different meaning from that which it has in ordinary use, unless there is some proof in the context to show that it is used in a tropical sense. Firms consisting of three parties are numerous in the commercial world; and anything done by their agent for them in the firm name, is done only once for them all. If a firm composed of J. Field, E. Jacobs, and P. Sampson, should send an agent to deposit a thousand dollars in a bank, and the banker should ask him, In whose name do you deposit this money? he would reply, In the name of J. Field, E. Jacobs, and P. Sampson; or, in the shorter and more common form, In the name of Field, Jacobs, and Sampson. This would not signify that he deposited a thousand dollars for each name, making three thousand dollars in all; but only a thousand dollars in the name of all combined, because all are equally concerned in it. But the union existing between the members of any commercial firm comes infinitely short of that existing between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit; and a baptism is not required for each one, as though they were independent parties, but one baptism shows the relation of the sinner alike to all three, and that is all that is required.
It is said, further, that the language is elliptical, and that the ellipsis can be supplied only by reading it thus: “Baptizing them in the name of the Father, and [baptizing them in the name] of the Son, and [baptizing them in the name] of the Holy Ghost.” But this is not true. The facts of the Scriptures, as well as the analogies of language, are against it. Try it in reference to the second coming of Christ. The Scriptures plainly teach that Christ will come in the glory of the Father, and in his own glory, and in that of the holy angels. According to the trine immersionist’s argument, we should have to come to this conclusion: Christ will come (once) in the glory of the Father (Mark 8 : 38); and he will come (another time) in his own glory (Matt. 25 : 31); and he will come (a third time) in the glory of the angels. 2 Thess. 1 : 7, 8. According to the analogy of language this would be an exact parallel to their claim on Matt. 28 : 19. But it is not true. The second coming of Christ is but one coming, enveloped in a threefold glory.
Try the argument again on Ex. 3 : 15 : “And God said moreover unto Moses, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, The Lord God of your fathers, the God of Abraham [one God],p. 777 the God of Isaac [a second God], and the God of Jacob [a third God], hath sent me unto you,” etc. We can claim three different Gods from Ex. 3 : 15, on the same ground and with just as much evidence, as three baptisms can be claimed from the wording of Matt. 28 : 19.
In another paper we will show that trine immersion is “three baptisms,” which contradicts the declaration of Paul that there is only one baptism (Eph. 4 : 5); that it is entirely out of harmony with the form of baptism set forth by Paul in Romans 6; and that in the ceremony of trine immersion, the significance of the ordinance is entirely lost. U. S.