SUNDAY CLOSING IN CHICAGO

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 26, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 48.

Read the full edition

SUNDAY CLOSING IN CHICAGO.

Last July there went into effect in Illinois a law compelling the closing of barber-shops on Sunday. In Chicago there has been war on the subject since. A Barbers’ Protective Association was formed to prosecute all offenders. Ministers, churches, and leagues have upheld the law, while a few have bidden it defiance. The manager of the Great Northern Hotel has been in the lead in this matter. A case was appealed to the District Court, where on the 16th inst. a decision was rendered by Judge Gibbons, that the law was unconstitutional, and consequently invalid. This decision has created no little stir. The Barbers’ Association will carry the matter to the Supreme Court. Immediately after it was rendered, several arrests were made in defiance of the decision.
The action of the higher court will be awaited with interest. The present decision is contrary to that of the Michigan Supreme Court, where a similar law was sustained. The principal basis of Judge Gibbons’s decision was that the law was partial. It was “class legislation.” It selected a class of tradesmen of honorable and useful employment, and made them the subjects of restrictive law. The judge stated that a Sunday law that was impartial in its application would be upheld. He had considerable to say in favor of such a law.
This matter, though but a side issue to the real crisis toward which the country is rapidly drifting, is of serious significance, because it deeply stirs the elements, arousing the energies of those who are destined soon to act an important part in this great controversy. It shows the strong trend of the public mind in the direction indicated by the prophecy. The way is thus being prepared for the speedy fulfillment of the remaining particulars of this earthly story.
Extracts from the Above Decision.—To show the tenor of Judge Gibbons’s decision, we present the following passages taken from the published reports:—
“The courts cannot take cognizance of the moral aspect of the case, even though a seventh day of rest seems to be established by divine decree or natural necessity. Whether we accept the account of creation so graphically given in Genesis, as literally true, or We adopt the theories of scientists, that the creation was the result of successive evolutions, extending through numberless cycles, long antedating the Mosaic period, we cannot but recognize that the economy of all creation proclaims the wisdom and necessity of rest.”
“Reading aright the so-called religious history of the past, we cannot but the more keenly appreciate and approve the wisdom that inspired the fathers of the republic in incorporating into its natal polity the absolute and unalterable separation of Church and State.”
“I should gladly uphold impartial legislation, ordaining one day of rest in every seven, and if that day of rest should fall on Sunday, it would meet with hearty approval from the great majority of the American people; but I could never willingly assent to a law which would single out one class of citizens and visit it with penalties and punishments for actions which are innocent in themselves, from which all others are exempted. Nor should I willingly assent to legislation which would place the ban of outlawry upon persons who believe in innocent and lawful recreation combined with rest on the sabbath day, or which shall deprive persons pursuing a particular profession or vocation of their property, unless there was something in the nature of the property aimed at, or in the vocation pursued, hurtful to society.”
“With all due respect to that court [Michigan], we cannot subscribe to any pronouncement, from whatever source uttered, which would exalt the police power of the State above and beyond all constitutional restraints, and which would endow a State legislature with an omnipotence greater than that ever arrogated by the British Parliament. I repeat here the significant commentary of one of the ablest and purest jurists of the Michigan court, Mr. Justice Cooley, in his dissenting opinion in the State tax-law cases, 54 Michigan, 330: ‘Personally,’ he says, ‘I have little care how this case shall be decided. But it seems to me that in constitutional questions the court is drifting to this position: That those statutes are constitutional which suit us, and those are void which do not.’”
“If the legislature of Michigan had passed an act prohibiting barbers from conducting their business on Wednesdays or any other week-day, would the courts of that State hesitate to declare it a flagrant abuse of legislative power? Why, then, have they upheld the law in question? Was not the court unconsciously influenced by its desire to promote Sunday observance? ‘It is hard entirely to throw off human nature.’”
“It must be apparent to every one that if the law under consideration is to be upheld, the action of the court can be justified upon no other theory than that the law promotes Sunday observance. Based upon such a theory, it finds no warrant in the constitution, State or federal. It is not within the province of the legislature to enforce an observance of religious duty on the sabbath.”
“The first article of amendment of the Federal Constitution and the third section of article 2 of our own constitution, guarantee the exercise of religious worship to all, and prohibit any preference from being given by law to any denomination or mode of worship. In this respect the line of demarkation between Church and State is clearly drawn, and the perfect equality of all persons before the law so clearly recognized, that it is only necessary for us to walk in the path marked out by the founders of the republic to enjoy the fruitage of the best and wisest government ever devised by man.”
“The law in question is class legislation, and deprives barbers of their property without due process of law. This must be so unless it is proved that the business, or vocation, of a barber, is hurtful to the community, tends to promote pauperism and crime, or to provoke a breach of the peace. Muscle and its labor are property. The faculties of the mind and their productions are property, and are as securely protected under the law as any other species of property.”
“The late Justice Miller says: ‘It must be conceded that there are rights in every free government beyond the control of the State. A government which acknowledges no such rights, which holds the lives, liberty, and property of its citizens subject at all times to the absolute control of even the most democratic depository of power, is, after all, but a despotism. It is true it is a despotism of the many, of the majority, if you choose to call it so, but it is none the less a despotism. It may well be doubted if a man is to hold all that he is accustomed to call his own, all on which he has placed his happiness and the security of which is essential to that happiness, under the unlimited dominion of others, whether it is not wiser that this power should be exercised by one man than by many.’”
“When the legislature of this State shall, in its wisdom, enact a law based upon a wise public policy to promote rest from labor on Sunday, a law applicable alike to all classes of citizens, and operating upon all businesses and vocations, then shall it be upheld; otherwise it must receive the seal of judicial disapproval as partial and arbitrary in its nature and an unwarrantable exercise of legislative power.”
“The Court of Appeals of New York said: ‘The term “liberty,” as used by the Constitution, is deemed to embrace the right of every man to be free in the enjoyment of the faculties with which he has been endowed by his Creator, subject only to such restraints as are necessary for the common welfare.’”