THE TRIAL OF OUR BRETHREN IN ILLINOIS

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 26, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 48.

Read the full edition

THE TRIAL OF OUR BRETHREN IN ILLINOIS.

DURING the past few days four of our brethren have been tried for Sunday labor. J. F. Rothrock has been running a grocery at West Salem since early last spring. In the month of May the village adopted a code of ordinances, one of which contained a clause forbidding Sunday labor, although the State law permits labor on the part of those who observe some other day than Sunday. The ordinances went into effect, May 18. On the 19th, which was Sunday, brother Rothrock sold goods as he had done on previous Sundays. The next day he was arrested. He was tried before a justice, and fined $10 and costs. The case was appealed to the circuit court, and was tried the 11th of this month. This court sustained the decision of the lower court. The case was pleaded by Judge Hannah, who made an able defense; but as the town ordinance was very plain, a decision in brother Rothrock’s favor would simply mean the setting aside of the town ordinance. All could see, except those who were prosecutors, that there was a religious bearing to the question. The judge of the court saw it, and reversed the decision of the jury, and the case is to be tried again at the spring term. There was a minister on the jury, and we learn from good authority that he used his influence to have the fine imposed. Brother Rothrock was tried at Albion, the county-seat of Edwards county.
Last August, in Richland county, adjoining Edwards, five of our brethren were arrested for Sunday work,—three for work on the farm, and two for running a country store. These cases were tried before a justice, and the brethren were fined. An appeal was taken to the circuit court. Three of these cases were tried at Olney, in Richland Co., Nov. 13. It was agreed that one case should be tried, and the decision of that one case should apply to all. The judge decided that that might be done in the case of the farmers, but that it would be better to have a distinct trial made in case of the merchants.
The cases were tried before Judge Landes, and the case for our brethren was conducted by Lawyers Mc Cauley and Hoff. There were twenty-four regular jurors present. When the case was called, the court-room was crowded full. Twelve jurors took their seats. They were questioned very closely by the lawyers if they had discussed the merits of the case, and passed opinions on it, and as fast as they admitted they had, they were dismissed. Sixteen were dismissed. The lawyer that opposed us asked each one if he had attended our camp-meeting, which we held in the city last September. If they had, and several had, they were asked if they were influenced either for or against the subject. They generally stated that they were. One man said, “I sometimes think the Adventists are right on the subject, and then again I do not know.” He was dismissed as he said he did not think he could give an unbiased decision. Another gentleman said that he had heard the Adventists preach on the subject, and he would confess that he was “tangled.” At last a Catholic was seated, and when asked if he knew anything about the Sabbath question, he answered, “No; but I heard of this trial, and came here to hear about the question.” It took three hours and a half to select a jury. When it was selected, it was made up of nine church-members, and four that had made no profession. The nine church-members represented six different denominations.
When the jury was seated, brother Ross Foll, who is twenty-two years of age, was tried for the crime of plowing on Sunday. The first young man placed on the stand to witness against brother Foll, testified that he was disturbed in his mind by seeing the work done. It was proved that the Sunday before, he had aided in hiving a stray swarm of bees. The next witness testified that he and his family were disturbed by seeing the work done. The next one that testified was an old lady seventy two years old; she testified that she was disturbed by the plowing. When asked why she was disturbed, she replied that she was so disturbed by seeing a good boy plow on a day that she had been brought up to keep, that she could not sleep nights. She said that the Adventists were a nice class of citizens, until the “cranky” Adventists came and got them to work on the “Sabbath.” Another lady testified that she was disturbed by the noise made in plowing. When these had testified, the prosecution rested the case.
The State’s attorney then argued the case. He claimed that the Adventists had a perfect right to keep the Sabbath on Saturday if they chose, but that the law said that all must keep Sunday, and that Adventists, even though they are good citizens, shall keep Sunday.
He was followed by Judge Hoff, who very ably set forth many facts in regard to the rights of conscience that the Constitution of the United States and the State of Illinois grants to every citizen. That the State of Illinois granted to every citizen the privilege of working the first day of the week, if he observed another day as a rest day. He gave in an able manner many facts in relation to the Sunday rest day; gave its heathen origin, how it was named after the sun, and the facts in relation to Constantine’s Sunday law; presented the rights of every man to worship irrespective of earthly governments.
He was followed by Judge Mc Cauley, who, with law book and Bible, set forth the rights of our people to worship according to the dictates of conscience. He made an able address. As the case passed into the hands of the jury, nearly every one thought our brethren would be acquitted. The jury were out nearly six hours. Some were for fining to the extent of the law,—$25 and costs; others, for making the fine light, while others were for acquitting. It was finally decided to fine $1 and costs. The verdict was so rendered.
Judge Hoff is an able lawyer, who not only practices law, but publishes the Flora, Ill., Democrat. He has read the Sentinel for some time, and is much interested in the subject of religious liberty. Hearing of the cases to be tried, he attended the trial, and volunteered his services free of charge, and did all that he could to aid in the trial. He is anxious that an appeal to a higher court be taken to test the question of whether our people have rights in this State.
The court-room was crowded, and as quiet while the case was being tried as at any other case during last week. The court is still in session. At the close of last week the case of the two brethren who are under arrest for running a store on Sunday, had not been tried, and it was thought that their cases would not come up before the spring term. The judge seemed disposed to deal with the case fairly. In his charge to the jury he stated that in this State Sunday labor is not punishable, and that they could only fine unless a disturbance had been proved.
The case has claimed a wide-spread interest in the Sabbath question in the county, and has called attention to it, that could not have been as quickly in any other way; this being true, only good can come to the truth. The costs had not been determined when the writer left. The brethren are cheerful and firm in the truth, knowing that it will in the end triumph gloriously. S. H. LANE.