CIVIL POWER IN THE RELIGIOUS REALM.
By G. O. T.
The distinction between civil and religious duties is a very obvious one; and it is also evident to every thoughtful person that to the State pertains the work of enforcing one, and to the church pertains the work of inculcating the other. It is also a fundamental principle in good government that neither can with safety infringe upon the work or jurisdiction of the other. The reason why they may not interchange offices and trespass on each other's ground is not an arbitrary one. It is not simply because there is a distinction, and it would be an unfriendly act for either to infringe upon the other. The truth is that the barrier between the two realms is an impassable one. They cannot pass from one to the other and retain their original character. The question is asked, Why may not the State require men to pray, to be baptized, and to keep the Sabbath? and we say, Because those are religious duties, and the State may not tamper with them. They are matters of conscience between man and God, and no earthly power should interfere between a man and his Master, to whom alone he is accountable in such matters. Those reasons are all good and pertinent, perhaps, but they are secondary. The ultimate and all-sufficient reason why the State should not do such things is that it cannot. We may say that the government has no right to forgive sins. True; but a more far-reaching and conclusive fact is that it cannot forgive sins. Its attempt to do so would be but a hollow pretense, fatal to all who trusted in it. So in moral or religious matters, human authority can by no possible means control men's consciences or regulate their morals. Were it possible to do so, we could not question the right of it. If I undertake to save a person from a burning building, I am justified in removing him, willing or unwilling. If necessary, I may drag him out by the hair, or pitch him out of a window. It is my duty to save him,— by persuasion if I can, by force if need be. And on the same grounds, if it were possible for me to compel men to do right, and thus be eternally saved, instead of permitting them to do wrong, and thus be eternally lost, why should I not exercise that power? Most assuredly I should. On that hypothesis the Inquisition was and is defended. It is better for a man to lose his eye or his hand and enter into life, than that his whole body should be destroyed in hell. It is better that a man should go to heaven from the stake, than die in his bed and be lost. But the fiendishness of that whole scheme lies in the utter falsity of the hypothesis. Righteousness is the result of voluntary action alone, and is never a creature of physical force. God himself recognizes that great truth in his merciful dealings with men. Because men do not perceive it, many become involved in doubt and unbelief of God's goodness, and complain of his wisdom or criticise his government; while many others undertake to do what God has never done, evidently to make up for his remissness, by making laws which are to control men's morals and enforcing them by physical or human force. We all acknowledge that the fear of eternal punishment will not of itself produce a desirable effect on moral character, how much less, then, the fear of man. To keep the Sabbath in response to human force, to be baptized because the law said so, or to pray because compelled to do so, would be but empty mockery. Instead of being Christian acts, they would be antichristian. Instead of being meritorious, they would be hypocritical, and in the highest degree distasteful to God. They would be equally delusive and dangerous to any who might be led to trust in them for merit. So that the moment the State takes up the work that pertains to the church, that State becomes antichrist; that work glorifies Satan, and dishonors God. In the mandatory power of courts and policemen the gospel of Christ loses at once its essential character, loses its power to save from sin, and becomes bitter and devilish. What a gigantic mistake is thus being committed! It is passing strange that with the history of the past before it, the civil power will again in these last days seek to lay its iron hand upon the consciences of men, and infuse its bitter human spirit into the peaceful elements of the gospel. It reminds us of an attempt to sweeten apple sauce with salt instead of sugar—it cannot be done. The least particle is out of place; and the more there is of it, the worse the mixture becomes. Two things civil law can make with religious laws as instruments — hypocrites and martyrs. Hundreds of millions of these have been made; but never a single Christian! Equally impossible is it for the church to preserve its character and carry its work into the realms of civil power. But of that next week.