AdventAI

Melchisedec Again.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 45., November 5, 1895

The answer to Question 539, in the Question Chair, in the REVIEW of Oct. 15, has called out a communication from a correspondent, E. G. F., who cannot see the correctness of the position there set forth. He asks where in the writings of sister White it is said that Melchisedec was not Christ, and how this can be harmonized with what is stated in “Spirit of Prophecy,” Vol. II., page 396, where it is stated that as Christ descended the Mount of Olives, the rulers repeated the question, Who is this? “The disciples, filled with a spirit of inspiration, are heard . . . repeating in eloquent strains the prophecies which answered this question: Adam will tell you it is the seed of the woman that shall bruise the serpent’s head. Ask Abraham, he will tell you, It is Melchisedec, King of Salem; King of Peace.”

To this we answer that the words our correspondent inquires for are found in the REVIEW of Feb. 18, 1890, first page, third column, and read as follows: “It was Christ that spoke through Melchisedec, the priest of the Most High God. Melchisedec was not Christ, but he was the voice of God in the world, the representative of the Father. And all through the generations of the past, Christ has spoken; Christ has led his people, and has been the light of the world.”

And this is not in conflict with what is said in “Spirit of Prophecy,” Vol. II., page 396. There he is spoken of as he had been represented to the world, in prophecy, type, and figure. Because he had taken upon himself our nature, he was called “the seed of the woman;” because he was the antitype of Melchisedec, he was called “Melchisedec.” And the disciples might have added, This is our “Isaac,” this is our “Moses;” because they were both types of Christ. Or they might have said, This is the “true vine,” this is the true “door” into the fold; because by these figures he is set forth in the Scriptures. That is, by the figure of metonymy the name of the type, or object, by which he was represented, could be applied to him.

A word more may be added to show that Melchisedec was not Christ. (1) The last verse of Hebrews 6 shows that they were two distinct persons, thus: “Whither the forerunner is for us entered, even Jesus, made an high-priest forever after the order of Melchisedec.” To say that Jesus was made an high-priest forever, after the order of Jesus, or after his own order, would hardly be consistent language to use, and would be no comparison, such as the apostle evidently intends to draw. Christ is here compared with some other being, and that is Melchisedec. (2) In the record in Genesis, Melchisedec is spoken of as a literal, visible, tangible person, on the earth, as much as the king of Sodom, brought to view in connection with him (Gen. 14:17, 18), exercising political, kingly power, and performing the office of a priest. But Christ never reigned thus visibly and literally on this earth. Our correspondent on this point asks if Christ was not king of a theocracy, and if he was not therefore king on this earth; to which it may be replied that even during the theocracy, Christ himself did not occupy a visible throne here upon the earth, upon which he sat as a personal king, as it appears that Melchisedec did. But further, there was no theocracy, until Israel came out of Egypt in numbers sufficient to constitute a nation and a kingdom. But Melchisedec appeared back in the days of Abraham when a theocracy did not exist. (3) Melchisedec was a priest; but Paul says that Christ could not be a priest on the earth; all his priesthood is performed in heaven. Heb. 8:4. Melchisedec could not therefore have been Christ.

Melchisedec is called “King of Righteousness” and “King of Peace,” and it is asked how this could apply to any mortal man. Let it be understood that all, or nearly all, of the ancient localities, cities, and provinces, had names which had meanings. Primarily, a king over these places was simply a king of the place, or city, which went by the name, abstractly considered, without reference to the definition which the word bore. Melchisedec was king of Salem, which is supposed to have been the ancient name of Jerusalem; and it will be noticed that it is only when Paul makes the application to Christ, that he gives the definition of the word, and takes pains to say that it is “by interpretation;” because that definition so well applies to Christ.

In answer to the question in the REVIEW of Oct. 15, the point was made that Melchisedec could not be the Son of God, because he was made like unto the Son of God. Our correspondent thinks that argument cannot stand in view of such expressions as we find in Dan. 7:13 and Rev. 14:14, “one like unto the Son of man.” But the expressions are not alike. The texts referred to speak of “one like the Son of man;” that is, one in his own nature, like the Son of man, without any external influence or circumstances to make him such. But of Melchisedec it is said that he was “made like unto the Son of God;” that is, he was not like him in his own nature and organization, but he was made like unto him; namely, in the position in which God had placed him, the circumstances that surrounded him, and the manner in which he is introduced into the record. These circumstances fitted him to be most conspicuously a representative of the Son of God, as priest-king.

Lastly, let it further be borne in mind that the expressions, which are to many so perplexing, are written from the standpoint of the record we have of Melchisedec, which give us no particulars on these points. These expressions are: “without father,” “without mother,” “having neither beginning of days, nor end of life,” “of whom it is witnessed, that he liveth.” The record tells us nothing about his pedigree, his birth, or death. So far as the record goes, no beginning nor end of life is given; and it was the custom, therefore, among the Jews, to speak of such as having no genealogy, no mother, no father, no beginning of days, nor end of life. And considering that all these expressions are used simply from the standpoint of the record, there is no difficulty. Melchisedec suddenly appears upon the scene of action, an eminent servant of God, combining, in his own person, the double office of king and priest. All before him is blank; all following him is blank. Neither birth nor death appearing in the scene, he becomes a fitting prototype of Christ in his position of priest-king in this dispensation. So we call the priesthood of Christ the priesthood of Melchisedec; although that performed by Melchisedec was, according to Heb. 7:15, only “a similitude” of that enacted by Christ.

U. S.