WHO SUBSTITUTED SUNDAY FOR THE SABBATH?
By F. Peabody
EARLY in the third century, evidence was not wanting that the church was absorbing the world. The high standard set up by Christ and maintained by the apostles was being lowered. The church gained in numbers but lost in power. The heathen, bringing in customs and laws of long standing, knocked at her doors, and she made room for their practices by substituting them for those of heavenly origin. The Sunday had become hoary with age. In 321 Constantine denominated it “the venerable day of the sun.” Long ages before Christ came, it was born and reared in the lap of heathenism. Its parentage can be traced, but the time of its birth is lost in the dim past. At first the church adopted it rather as a silent member of the family, but soon, dazzled by its adaptability to the new conditions it had assumed, it took it as a child of its own. Notwithstanding its age, the church soon found it needed nourishment she was unable to give. It was proposed to substitute it in the place of the Sabbath of the Lord, the seventh day. This was done after the church was weakened by the incoming flood of half-converted heathen, with their venerable pet, asking that that place be given it. Two rest days in one place was one too many. One must step down and out, the other step up and in. The Sunday took the preference in the now worldly church. Who substituted Sunday for the Sabbath this time? When the church had thus adopted this pagan pet, it was not ready to adopt all the customs in which it had been reared. After substituting it for the Sabbath, it desired that the substitute should be treated as the original. The pagans were not prepared to do it. Then the civil power was invoked to legalize the substitution and compel its recognition. Up to this time, we again ask, who substituted Sunday for the Sabbath? — The professed Christian church did it this time, and there is no room for dispute. Since then the church has claimed Sunday as a genuine offspring of its own. It lived and thrived better in darkness than in the light. Through all the dark ages of papal supremacy, but few thought to question its parentage. When Luther and others gave their life-work to dispel papal errors, this adopted child was retained, without questioning its parentage, and thus it became a prominent member in the Protestant family. Its hoary age commanded659 respect. No one then thought to examine its birth record; no one dared whisper doubt concerning its legitimacy. This, with many other resemblances, shows that Protestantism has not moved as far from her mother home as she has claimed. They do not agree as to birth of the foster-child. The mother church and Protestants do not quite agree as to its age, the latter making it older than the mother, the former claiming it a genuine offspring of its own. How the dispute will be settled remains to be seen, though it now appears quite evident that the foster-mother’s claim will be granted by the latter. If they could, they would rather find a record of the birth of the precious foster-child about A. D. 31. Times without number has it been tried to find such record, but always with the same result. No record of the birth of this institution can be found at or near that time. In 1893 Rome sent this word to the world: “The Christian Sabbath, the genuine offspring of the union of the Holy Spirit, and the Catholic Church, his spouse.” When they say the Christian Sabbath, the first day of the week, or Sunday, is meant. This claim is either true or false. Protestants, who have the precious child, must receive it as genuine or illegitimate. The choice is before them. It is a very prominent member in their family. Its hoary age commands respect, they say. They must admit that it is not an offspring of their own. They have adopted it. Then it is becoming Protestants to ask the Catholic Church of the birth and parentage of this common member in both families. They have asked, and the answer has come in no uncertain terms: “It is a genuine offspring, the fruit of the union of the Holy Spirit and the Catholic Church.” Mind, they do not call it the Roman Catholic, but Catholic (universal) Church. Then the claim is that the church, somewhere this side of Christ, substituted Sunday for the Sabbath. We will not inquire at what time, but it was done by the church. Protestants, failing to find anything in the life and teachings of Christ to indicate that he made the substitution, are really compelled to voice the same thing. It was the church some time this side of Christ that did the wicked thing. That it was not done in the first century, all must admit who read the history of the early church, and not for a long time after, all ought to admit. When it was done, the church was in good condition for it. Sunday did not come into the new family alone. When the church opened the door, in rushed a large brood of pagan pets. Yes, the church did substitute Sunday for the Sabbath; but it was not the first time it had been done. The pagans had really done it long before. Now, what are the Protestants, who hold the same day for the same purpose, doing? — Only following in the same line, repeating the same thing. It is substitution from beginning to the end. If the Protestant church had carried the reformation on in the same spirit that actuated Luther and others, instead of being satisfied by turning out a few pagan ideas, Sunday would, in time, have been asked to step down and out. Even at that time, when one wished to question its legitimacy, he was treated as an innovator, so strongly had it become rooted in its substituted place. After the church had adopted, substituted, and nursed this ancient institution, it invoked the aid of civil strength and might to hold it in its position; so the Protestant church, when they see its parentage and birth questioned, are now invoking civil authority to hold this member where it was placed by the church. And when they gain it, will it not be truly an image? Mr. A. or B., pagan, Catholic, or Protestant, who, knowingly, takes Sunday in the place of the seventh day, the Sabbath of the Lord, is to-day as guilty as individuals living at any time in the past, who have done the same thing. Further, any government upholding and enforcing its observance must be as guilty before God as those who have done so in the past. The image and the original look alike, act alike, and are alike guilty. If one was to “think to change times and laws,” the other, if it is an image, will think to keep that change in force. Once more God has set his hand to bring his people up where they will know that he is God. The Sabbath, unchanged stands as a sign between God and his people. The character of the substitute is being examined; the search-light of prophetic truth is revealing the character and work of governments and individuals that are upholding the claims of this venerable substitute. Each is wheeling into line, and fulfilling the prophetic predictions without a thought that Heaven had marked out their course beforehand. The church, with its hand upon the lever, is making every effort to increase the speed that will soon end in everlasting ruin. When God has accomplished his purpose in restoring the earth to its Eden state, the first day will take its place as God at first ordained, and the Sabbath will stand in its lot with God’s blessing upon it, world without end.