AdventAI

NARROW VS. BROAD AND LIBERAL.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 42., October 15, 1895

It may be pertinent to consider whether we are in our belief too narrow or as broad and liberal as we should be; inasmuch as a writer in the Catholic Mirror comes out and says that he is no friend to the Seventh-day Adventists, for they are the most narrow and bigoted people he knows of in the world.

Such a declaration, coming from a Roman Catholic, challenges a moment’s comparison of our respective views. Man must be the object in reference to which the comparison must be made, as he is the most important object on earth, and the one most concerned in the question whether the views entertained by his fellows will be narrow or broad and liberal; and the standard by which the matter must be tested is the amount of freedom that will be granted to the members of the human family, mentally, morally, and physically.

1. We hold that man is endowed by his Creator with certain unalienable rights, for the use of which he is responsible to God alone.

2. That man’s conscience is as free as the air of heaven, that is, that it should no more be controlled by man than the air he breathes; that he is responsible to God alone for its exercise and conclusions, and that man must not interfere with it in the least degree.

3. That man’s mind is as free as a bird on the wing, that is, that it has a right to search through every avenue of knowledge, and explore every inch of the vast realm which God has set before him for his learning, and that no man can interfere with the conclusions at which he may arrive; that in thought, religious belief, religious practices, and physical action in the pursuit of happiness, he is responsible to God alone, and responsible to man only so far as not to trespass upon any of the rights of others.

This is what the Romanist must call narrowness. Now let us look at his creed. He does not believe man has any rights to be controlled by himself, but that he must surrender himself, soul, body, and spirit, and all his rights, into the hands of a self-constituted representative of God on earth; that he must have no conscience of his own, but believe as another may tell him; that he must not think for himself, but think only as another may direct him; that he has no liberty of speech, only within limits which others may have prescribed; that he must pursue no course of action which is not in accordance with rules laid down by others; that he must torture himself for his sins, depend on his own works for heaven, pour out into the ears of a fellow-man the inmost secrets of his life, and look to a mortal as weak and imperfect as himself for the forgiveness of his sins. Thus at every turn, from the cradle to the grave, he is restricted and imprisoned in mind and body, and made to grovel in the very dust. And this, we suppose, is what the Romanist calls broadness and liberality. As between our narrowness and their broadness, we are willing to leave any intelligent and candid person to judge.

But there is another side in which we shall not pretend to compete with the Roman Catholic in liberality. We believe that when God speaks and gives us a command in plain language which cannot be misunderstood, it is every man’s duty to take that command just as it reads, and render obedience in just the manner in which it is prescribed. This the Romanist calls narrow. But what does he do? This question does not apply to the average member of the Romish communion, the rank and file of that church; for they can believe only that which the priests tell them. But the responsible parties, the Roman hierarchy, have set themselves above the Bible and above God. They presume to change the law of God, to set aside practices which he has enjoined, and to introduce others in their places which conflict with them, and which God has never commanded. They presume to multiply forms, rites, ceremonies, and vain formalities without number, and prescribe a whole round of duties in the religious life independent of God, and of that word which God has given to instruct men in righteousness and to make them perfect, thoroughly furnished unto every good work. 2 Tim. 3:17. This we suppose is what they call broad and liberal, and it is broad and liberal with a vengeance! It is a liberality which we do not crave, a freedom for which we do not care to be responsible. And here, again, as between our narrowness and Catholic liberality, we are willing to leave any candid and intelligent person to judge.

U. S.