PROTESTANT FREEDOM IN SOUTH AMERICA

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 1, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 40.

Read the full edition

PROTESTANT FREEDOM IN SOUTH AMERICA.

It is presumable that the readers of the REVIEW have been interested in the efforts of the Methodist Ministers’ Meeting of Chicago to gain for their co-religionists in South America, and for all Protestants, that religious freedom which Catholics possess in this country.
In response to the urgent requests of these Chicago ministers, Cardinal Gibbons laid the matter before the pope, and finally the papal secretary addressed a letter to Rev. John Lee, in which he declared these disabilities related solely to the civil laws of those countries, and carried the idea that the Catholic Church was not to blame, and had nothing to do with the matter.
This position was hardly satisfactory to the Protestants of this country, who know how great an influence the Catholic Church has in those countries, and that the laws generally are made by devout adherents of that church. The feeling of American Protestants was well expressed by the Chicago Tribune, which in its issue of July 31, said:—
“As to the matter of the reply, there can hardly be any doubt if an official investigation is made, that the contention of the cardinal secretary of the Holy See to the effect that the condition of things in the South American States is dependent upon the civil laws, will be shown to be a technicality, since in the States named the civil laws are inspired by the Roman Catholic Church. The control of the church over law in those republics is all powerful. Hence it has the power to obtain for Protestants there the same degree of liberty which Roman Catholics have here.”
Many others of the leading periodicals of this country have referred to this matter, and all have urged that it should be pressed until the papacy shall be compelled to show its hand; but up to the present time the pope has made no effort to ameliorate the condition of the Protestants in those countries, nor is it likely that he will do so.
The Methodist Ministers’ Meeting, however, is determined to keep the matter before the people, and to this end letters have been addressed to many distinguished men, asking them for their views upon the question. These replies are published in the papers, and thus the attention of the public is being drawn more and more to the matter.
Three letters received by Mr. Lee are so interesting that they are herewith inserted. The first is from Justin M’Carthy, leader of the Home-rule party in the British Parliament, a Catholic, but evidently a believer in religious liberty:—
“No. 73 Easton Terrace, London, Southwest, Eng., Aug. 9, 1895.
“DEAR SIR: I have read your letter just received with great interest. I feel no doubt whatever that the influence of the pope will be exercised in securing for Protestants in the South American republics the same liberty of conscience that is enjoyed by Roman Catholic citizens of your country. I need hardly say that your purpose has my fullest and most cordial sympathy. I thank you much for your kindly words with regard to myself and my writings.
“Very truly yours,
“JUSTIN M’CARTHY.
“Rev. John M. Lee, M. A.”
Mr. M’Carthy’s hopes are not shared by the celebrated English historian, Lecky, who responds as follows:—
“Vosbergen, Guilderland, Aug. 17, 1895.
“DEAR SIR: I wish you all success in your efforts to obtain a repeal of the grossly intolerant laws about Protestant marriages which exist in some of the South American States, but I shall be much surprised if you obtain any real help from the Vatican. Such laws were once general in Roman Catholic countries. They were always inspired or suggested by the priests, and they were only abolished when the political power of the church was restricted or overthrown.
“Yours faithfully,
“W. E. H. LECKY.
“Rev. John Lee, Chicago.”
But if these two letters are interesting, a letter from the English poet, Swinburne, is especially so, since he not only tells what the papacy has been, what it is, and what it will be, but expresses the belief that this effort of the Methodist ministers of Chicago is but an idle waste of time. Thus he writes:—
“The Pines, Putney Hill, London, Southwest, Eng., Aug. 12, 1895.
“DEAR SIR: I am no less honored than gratified by your expressed wish for my opinion on so practically grave a question as that on which you ask for it. I can only say that it seems to me a somewhat wanton waste of time to apply directly or indirectly to cardinal or to pope for any relaxation or modification of the most monstrous claim ever put forward by the church. Force, and force alone, could obtain even a show of justice, decency, or fair play from the ministers and agents of a religion which has never yielded one jot of its atrocious pretensions except under sheer compulsion of absolute necessity.
“Yours most sincerely,
“ALGERNON CHARLES SWINBURNE.
“Rev. John Lee.”
Whether the replies are gratifying to the Chicago Methodist Meeting or not, is a question. If the writer were allowed to express an opinion upon the matter, it would be something like this: If the Chicago ministers had devoted their efforts to the relaxing or repeal of laws in this country, which were as certainly enacted through a churchly influence as are the South American laws against which complaint is made, they would have shown more wisdom than they have done. Before this thing is over, they may be invited by the cardinal secretary to pull the beam out of their own eyes, before they give themselves such great anxiety about the mote in the eye of the Catholic priesthood of South America. M. E. Kellogg.