PAYING PENANCE

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 24, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 39.

Read the full edition

PAYING PENANCE.

BY ELDER R. M. KILGORE.
(Graysville, Tenn.)
The shocking account detailed recently of a Miss Thomas, in a Cincinnati convent, inflicting sore punishments upon herself, discloses a horrible chapter on convent life. The legitimate fruits of precept and example set before its inmates, which she had so freely imbibed, are manifest in this case, much to the chagrin of those in charge. They profess great surprise at the unexplainable mystery, as it is “without a parallel in the history of the Catholic Church.” She was suffering from swollen legs and feet, and was transferred to the city hospital. On examination “it was found that the limbs and feet were imbedded with pins and needles.” “Fifty-one needles were extracted from her body.” The following day “ten more were extracted, and it is thought others will be found.”
The following account is clipped from the Chattanooga Times:—
“The girl protested till after the operations that she could not tell how her feet and limbs became imbedded with these needles, but finally she said she had been at the convent of the Good Shepherd for several years. She was an orphan, and alone in the world. During her stay there, she had done wrong. Not once alone, but persistently. She had done that which she knew was not right, and for every sin she had committed she had done penance by thrusting a needle into one of her legs. She explained that each operation had caused her agonizing pain, and that at times the operations were almost unbearable, but she felt she must bear the pain as a recompense for the sin committed. This mode of doing penance, she said, had covered a period of more than two years. Her wrong-doings had been of frequent occurrence, and she was unable to estimate the number of needles she had placed in her limbs.
“A peculiar feature of the case is the fact that the patient is perfectly rational, and talks of the matter since divulging the secret as though it was a very commonplace matter. She was at no time excited, but remained perfectly cool and collected, and there is not the slightest ground upon which to establish the belief that the girl is not perfectly sane. Her mind is to all appearances bright and clear, and her story was told in a plain, simple manner. Miss Thomas is an orphan about twenty-one years of age and of very prepossessing appearance.”
Why should they or any one express great surprise at this occurrence? “Penance, by which the sins that we commit after baptism are forgiven,” is one of the seven sacraments, which Roman Catholics teach are “necessary for the salvation of mankind,” and “the direct means instituted by Christ himself for applying his infinite merits to the souls of men.” Penance is doing on the part of the penitent, and is wrought out in “contrition, confession, and satisfaction.” “Contrition is an interior grief, horror, and detestation of sin committed, with the firm resolve never more to relapse into our evil habits.” Could there be any more effectual method of producing “grief, horror, and detestation,” or a more potent agency by which a “firm resolve” might be kept, than by filling one’s body with needles and pins? “Confession is an express, contrite, but secret self-accusation, to a duly authorized priest, of all grievous sins committed after baptism.”
Did not Miss Thomas, by filling her body with pins and needles, express loudly enough the “contrition” which she felt within, and show sufficient “self-accusation” for the sins committed, which so shocked the modesty of the priest in the confessional? “Satisfaction means doing the penance enjoined by the priest in confession.”
The priest “must determine what instruction, admonition, advice, or penance,” are to be given. Doubtless more “contrition and self-accusation” were imposed on Miss Thomas, who, with the “interior grief,” caused by the goading needles and pins, already lacerating her body, secretly administered another instalment of pins and needles, in order to satisfy the priest, and procure remission of sins. This is logical. How could it be otherwise, when, by the catechism, she was taught that besides the penance enjoined by the priest she “may also add more, for her own sins, by her voluntary prayers, fasting, or other good works, or sufferings.” Again, in another, because “it is to be feared that the penance enjoined is seldom sufficient to take off all the punishment due to God’s justice on account of his sins; and it is certain that the more a penitent is touched with a hearty sorrow for his offenses against God, the more he will be desirous of making satisfaction, and revenging upon himself by penitential severities the injury done to God by his sins.” And now we are informed that, to Sister Superior, Mary Malone, this was “a startling revelation,” and that she “was surprised and shocked beyond measure.” Why so? The sin of Miss Thomas, the lessons taught her, and the penalty she inflicted upon herself, have the same paternity, and all flourish together under the same roof.