THE CASE OF BRETHREN KECK AND MC CUTCHEN.
By W. A. McCutchen
On Sunday, Nov. 19, 1893, brother E. C. Keck and I were working on some seats inside our church at Gainesville, Ga., when we were arrested by the police of that place. When asked what they wanted us for, they said, “For Sabbath-breaking.” We gave bond for appearance before the mayor’s court next morning. In the meantime we examined the city code and found there was no city ordinance against “Sabbath-breaking.” There was no city statute whatever on the subject of Sunday or Sabbath work. On appearance at court for trial, the charge of “disorderly conduct and disturbing the peace” was read to us. The mayor being reminded that we had given bond the day before for appearance at his court to answer to the charge of Sabbath-breaking, and that now we were arraigned on another charge, and being requested to state upon which charge, and for which offense we were to be tried, simply remarked that it all amounted to the same. In our defense we still insisted on this, and contended that if held on the first charge, there was no city statute against it, and demanded its production if any (which was not done); and if on the second, we had committed no act that came, in a single instance, within the meaning of “disorderly conduct” or “disturbing the peace,” according to the definition given these by the code itself. These ordinances were defined in plain, unambiguous language by the code, so that their meaning could not be mistaken. The witnesses summoned for the city swore that in what we had done, there was nothing “disorderly” or “disturbing” in the act itself, but simply in the fact of its being done on the day that it was; so that it was not the character of the act, but the day upon which it was done. Some of these witnesses lived nearly half a mile away, and were “disturbed” in their minds when they heard of the Sunday work, notwithstanding we were inside our own church, with the doors closed on our own premises, making no noisy demonstrations, and the nearest neighbors, immediately across the street from the church, swore they were not disturbed. But for all this, the mayor arbitrarily fined us $50 and costs each, or ninety days in the chain gang, and we were thrust into jail half a day, until through an attorney we got the papers fixed up for an appeal of the case, when we were let out. We then appealed the case to the superior (circuit) court, asking that the mayor’s judgment be set aside on the ground of his having no jurisdiction in the case. There was a State Sunday law, and the case, whatever there was to it, properly belonged to the State, and not to the city at all. Nor was the State long in taking hold of it. The grand jury soon convened, and this same mayor was on it as foreman. Accordingly, a bill was found against us, notwithstanding this foreman of the jury had, as mayor, already fined us excessively for the same offense. After an unsuccessful attempt to convict us in the county court, the judge of that court dismissed the case from his court. Thus the State’s case was disposed of. But the city’s case, which we had appealed to the superior court, was still pending against us. The best lawyers of the place, including the ex-judge of the superior court, said it could not fail to be set aside when brought to the test; that it was only a question of getting it before the judge of that court, and he would have to reverse the mayor’s decision; he could not do otherwise; there was nothing else left for him to do; the law was too plain, etc., etc. It was seen to be a clear case of petty persecution, and some of these lawyers tried to get the mayor to dismiss it from his court in the first place, telling him that all he could properly do, would be to bind us over to the State for its action. This he refused to do, however, notwithstanding he had no jurisdiction over the case, and had himself, the very Sunday we were arrested, a man at work at his tannery a short distance away, which was no uncommon thing with him. It is nearly two years ago that this appeal was taken, and the case has been pending in court ever since. And although everybody was so confident of a reversal of the mayor’s decision when the case should be reached, they were destined to be taken by surprise. A new judge afterward came to the bench, who is a Baptist minister. In his very first charge to the jury he enjoined upon them particularly to look after “Sabbath-breakers” (meaning Sunday-breakers of course); and publicly warned and threatened Seventh-day Adventists, calling them by name, from the bench. And now on reaching our case he has held, in a decision rendered Aug. 17, that we were properly convicted in the mayor’s court, and are held subject to the judgment then rendered against us. The effect of this decision will be ninety days each for us in the chain gang unless carried on to the supreme court; for we cannot conscientiously pay the fines, having done nothing to pay a fine for. If carried up to the supreme court, it is thought by others that this decision will be reversed, and I cannot myself see how it can fail to be set aside; for it has absolutely no law for its basis. Our lawyer writes that he thinks he can get the city to remit the fines, and if not, he is ready to take it on to the supreme court, if we wish it. If the fines are not remitted, it is my sincere wish that it be carried to the higher court. We have twenty days after the rendering of the decision in which to file the bill of exceptions for appeal. I have instructed our attorney to appeal at once in case the city does not remit the fines. I shall expect to hear from him soon as to what has been done. In the meantime I shall await with much interest the outcome. Whatever is God’s will in the matter, I know he will give grace for it.