AdventAI

SOMETHING FOR TEA-DRINKERS.

By W. H. Wakeham

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 36., September 3, 1895

BY ELDER W. H. WAKEHAM.

(College View, Neb.)

A prominent medical writer has said, “After the establishment of any wide-spread custom or dogma, there is never a lack of sophists to demonstrate its scientific propriety.”

Never has the truth of this been more clearly evidenced than by the various apologies that have been offered by physiologists in behalf of the toxic beverages—tea, coffee, etc.—since their use has become common.

When tea was first introduced into England, it was almost universally condemned, medical men, especially, warning the people against the evils resulting from its use. As early as 1678, Henry Savile, speaking of the practice of tea-drinking, wrote: “The truth is, all nations are growing so wicked as to have some of these filthy customs.”

A medical writer in 1722 speaks of tea as follows:—

“Among other novelties, there is one which seems to be particularly the cause of the hypochondriac disorders, and is generally known by the name of ‘thea’ or ‘tea.’ It is a drug which of late years has very much insinuated itself, as well into our diet as in regales and entertainments, though its occupation is not less destructive to the animal economy than opium, or some other drugs which we have at present learned to avoid.”—Encyclopedia Britannica.

And the celebrated Dr. Lettsom showed the people how the use of tea creates an appetite for stronger stimulants. He says:—

“The first rise of this pernicious custom [that of drinking alcoholic liquors to excess] is often owing to the weakness and debility of the system brought on by the daily habit of drinking tea; the trembling hand seeks a temporary relief in some cordial, in order to refresh and excite again the enfeebled system, whereby such persons almost necessarily fall into a habit of intemperance.”

Coffee also ran through a similar gauntlet of adverse criticism and denunciation before it obtained its present hold on the minds and bodies of civilized mankind. The early Mohammedan priests held it to be an intoxicating beverage, and the Koran prohibits its use under severe penalties. Chemists early discovered that the active principle of tea (which is identical with that of coffee), is an alkaloid poison, and that it is closely related, in its physiological effects, to that powerful narcotic, cocaine; and surgeons have used it for anesthetic purposes. A writer in the “Encyclopedia Britannica” classes tea and coffee with alcohol, tobacco, opium, and other powerful poisons, and shows that their effects differ only in degree. He says:—

“Tea sots are well known to be affected with palpitation of the heart, as well as with more or less sleeplessness, mental irritability, and muscular tremors, which in some cases culminate in paralysis; while positive intoxication has been known to be the result of excessive use of strong tea.”

“Coffee belongs to the medicinal or auxiliary class of food substances, being solely valuable for its stimulant effect upon the nervous and vascular system. It produces a feeling of buoyancy and exhilaration, comparable to a certain stage of alcoholic intoxication.”

Dr. Isaac Jennings says:—

“I venture the assertion, and without any fear, too, that future investigations and revelations will reverse the verdict,—that tea and coffee do more to alienate the natural and moral affections, pervert judgment, weaken the moral sense or force of moral obligations, and to disturb the peace and harmony of families, than alcohol does. I do not, of course, mean that in individual cases alcohol may not transcend tea and coffee in its mischievous effects, but in the aggregate of malign influences, exerted directly and indirectly, tea and coffee will not yield the palm to alcohol.”

Yet, in spite of all these and many other similar warnings, the use of tea or coffee has become in this country almost universal as a daily beverage. And now we find physiologists attempting to defend the use of these narcotic poisons on scientific grounds. The same battle which has been fought with reference to the use of alcoholic liquors as a beverage, is being fought over again with reference to tea and coffee. Certain ones claimed that alcohol was a food. Scientists have demonstrated that it is in no sense a food.

Baron Liebig reasons that alcohol must be a food because it is “derived from such nutritive substances as grain, sugar, and fruits”—“so is mildew.”

Dr. Oswald replies:—

“Would that circumstance warrant the inference that the fungi derived from the putrid residuum of an apple pie, should be valued as an article of concentrated nutritiveness?”

It was claimed that alcohol warmed the body; but scientific research, as well as experience, has proved that the bodily temperature of men under the influence of ardent spirits is lower than otherwise, and that a man freezes to death more quickly.

And so to-day there is no “lack of sophists to demonstrate the scientific propriety” of adopting and maintaining the daily use of tea and coffee. And for the sake of illustration, I will cite a few statements from Steel’s popular school text-book on physiology. Of coffee it is said, “No other substance so soon relieves the sense of fatigue.” O yes; a dose of opium or cocaine will, or a “knock down” blow on the back of the head is equally efficacious, and the last expedient might produce the less permanent injurious effects. We are also informed that coffee “tranquillizes the nerves, and usually leaves no unpleasant reaction.” This last statement is contradicted by the experience of almost every one who has ever become addicted to the use of coffee. Let the devotee of the “soothing” beverage be deprived of his usual potion for one day, and not only he, but all others in his immediate vicinity will become painfully conscious of a very “unpleasant reaction.”

Our author continues: “It serves also as a kind of negative food, since it retards the process of waste.” This is given as an argument in favor of the use of coffee. The inconsistency of the writer will be clearly seen by comparing the part which I have italicized with the following from the same writer:—

“The tendency of alcohol is to cause a formation of an unstable substance resembling fat, and so the use of liquor for even a short time will increase the weight; but a more marked influence is to check the ordinary waste of the system. [This is given as an argument against alcohol, and it is a good one, too.] . . . The life process is one of incessant change. Its rapidity is essential to vigor and strength. When the functions are in full play, each organ is being constantly torn down, and as constantly rebuilt with the materials furnished with our food. Anything that checks this oxidation of the tissues, or hinders the deposition of new matter, disturbs the vital functions. Both these results are the inevitable effects of alcohol. . . . The person using liquor consequently needs less bread and beef, and so alcohol seems to him a food—a radical error, as we have shown.” (Italics mine.)

This is how apologists for popular errors stultify themselves. Alcohol checks the natural wastes of the body, and is therefore very pernicious. Coffee does the same thing, and is therefore very good! Coffee is “a kind of negative food,” since the user does not seem to need so much bread and meat. But the same argument applied to alcohol is rightly termed “a radical error.” To all users of any of these narcotic beverages we would say, “Things are not [always] what they seem.” And herein lies the strength of the delusion. One drinks a glass of wine, and soon feels better, or, more properly speaking, he does not feel so badly (for the alcohol destroys his sense of feeling), and so he thinks he is better. Another imbibes an infusion of tea or coffee, and has the same experience, and falls into the same deception, each one trusting to a feeling that is only artificial and so misleading. As the Lord declared of wine, so may it be said of each of these narcotic drinks, that it is a “mocker,” “and whosoever is deceived thereby is not wise.”