SADLY MIXED

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 30, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 31.

Read the full edition

SADLY MIXED.

(Concluded.)
C. “THEREFORE, if a man is sick, or in trouble, or hungry, or naked, the Sabbath must yield to the necessity of the man, since it was ordained for the benefit of man. . . . This does not at all justify persons in disregarding the requirements of nature for a day of rest, but it does operate to prevent the making of this law a yoke of bondage.”
We make no apology for dissenting, in toto, from such a view of the Sabbath. It does not yield at all. It is no encroachment upon the Sabbath law at all to attend to a man’s necessities upon that day. “It is lawful,” said Christ, that is, according to law, “to do well on the Sabbath day.” There is no yielding of the law in any respect when we do only what is in accordance with both its spirit and its requirements. But according to the foregoing statements, the law of nature contains no such merciful provisions; and that, then, must be indeed a yoke of bondage.
We come now to the great effort to establish the first day of the week in the Christian church as the day of rest and worship; and this is the extraordinary line of argument on which it rests:—
1. The first day of the week became to the apostles a day of worship and finally a day of rest.
2. Paul tarried a whole week at Troas, and passed over the seventh day of the week entirely, holding no meeting, but met the disciples on the first day of the week.
3. Paul wrote fourteen epistles and never mentioned the Sabbath at all, showing “how widely he differed from those who make the keeping of the Sabbath the burden of their message.”
4. Paul says that “one man esteemeth one day above another, and another esteemeth every day alike; therefore, no man should judge you in reference to the Sabbath.”
5. The Jewish commonwealth is subverted, and no nation is now under the Mosaic law: “Many legislatures have adopted many of its provisions and acted quite in its spirit in reserving a weekly day of rest for the common benefit of mankind.” Such a day should be observed as a day of rest in obedience to the law of the land.
6. No man is to judge you as to what day you are to keep.
This is a further illustration of the embarrassing predicament people find themselves in on the Sabbath question when they depart from the straight line of argument presented in the Scriptures. They want a Sabbath, but they want a different day from that which the Lord has designated, and in appealing to the Scriptures to sustain them in this innovation, all the testimony they can find, if it applies to the Sabbath at all, proves that there is no Sabbath in this dispensation.
A strange claim is set up on Acts 20:7, and that is that Paul did not hold a single meeting during his seven days’ tarry at Troas, except on the first day, because no other meeting is mentioned except on that day. The more probable conclusion would be that he held a meeting every day, and the reason of the mention of the meeting on the first day of the week, just before his departure, was simply for the purpose of bringing in the miracle of the healing of Eutychus. But on account of this silence the Christian asserts, positively, that Paul did not hold any meeting on the seventh day, but did on the first day, showing that he had transferred his day of worship from the seventh day to the first. But let us see how this argument will work in verses 2 and 3 of the same chapter. The record states that Paul came into Greece “and there abode three months.” Nothing at all is said about any meeting during all this time; and we may, on as good authority, assert that Paul did not hold a meeting on the first day of the week, or on any other day, for three months, because it is not here mentioned, as the Christian can assert that no meeting was held on the seventh day at Troas, because it is not mentioned.
But his meeting on that first day of verse 7 amounts to nothing in behalf of any sacredness to be attached to the day; for there is nothing to show that it was a regular custom, the word being simply a participle, “The disciples having come together,” etc. And the meeting was in the evening, just as the day began, and while Paul was preaching, the other disciples, his companions, were sailing the ship around the promontory to Assos. Paul preached until daylight, and then went off on foot, during the daytime of Sunday, about twenty miles, to Assos, traveling all the daylight of that same Sunday.
It will be noticed that they carefully waited until the Sabbath was past, and then Paul’s companions hastened to take the ship around the promontory to Assos, while he could remain behind and hold one more meeting with the disciples, and overtake them at Assos, by going afoot the next day across the base of the peninsula, which he did on that pleasant Syrian Sunday, and thus forever demolished any claim it could present to being the Sabbath day.
But what about Paul’s writing fourteen epistles, and not mentioning the Sabbath? Why, pray, should he mention it? There was no controversy on the Sabbath question in his day. There was a controversy over the ceremonial system of the Jews, and on that the apostle spoke in Colossians 2, Ephesians 2, and Romans 14, which the Christian unaccountably mixes up with the entirely distinct system of moral laws, as contained in the decalogue. But while Paul does not specify the weekly Sabbath by name, he does something better. He, in the most explicit and emphatic manner, defends and upholds the law as a whole; and it is a principle of logic which every one understands, that whatever is affirmed of anything as a whole is equally affirmed of every part of which that whole is composed. And hence, when Paul affirms that the law is not made void by faith in Christ, but is established thereby (Rom. 3:31), he equally affirms that the Sabbath is not made void by faith in Christ, but is established thereby. That is enough. Paul does not “differ from those who make the Sabbath the burden of their message,” but quite the contrary. Nor do we differ with him. We accept “Pauline Theology” on the Sabbath question as fully as we do on the question of life only in Christ.
C. “The Jewish commonwealth is subverted. There is no city or country to-day under the Mosaic law. The legislatures of many countries have adopted many provisions of that law, and have acted quite in the spirit of that law in reserving a weekly day of rest for the common benefit of mankind.” Here, then, is the authority we have for a day of rest: Legislatures have reserved it from the Mosaic law “for the benefit of mankind.” But has God left mankind destitute of this observance, which would be for their benefit in his service? Having once given man the Sabbath, which is held up as so beneficial, why did he abandon it? If he has anywhere enjoined this rest day, which human legislatures have so wisely reserved, where has he done so? and where is his law for it? But if he has not given us a day of rest, where is his care for his people?
But the Christian says we should keep the law of the land, and yet should let no man judge us with reference to what day we should keep. And all this, remember, in an exposition of the fourth commandment of the decalogue!
So much for this effort to stretch and curtail, trim and twist, the testimony of the Scriptures to fit a custom founded on apostasy and error. But it is all of no avail, and all the arguments by which it is attempted are like the iron and the clay composing the feet and the toes of the great image of Daniel 2; they will not cleave one to the other. Better conform a wrong custom to the plain testimony of the Scriptures, and so be prepared for the verdict, “Well done,” at the last.
U. S.