AdventAI

PERSONALITY OF THE DEVIL.

By John Norton Loughborough

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 29., July 16, 1895

[The following articles are a review of a lecture by Robert Roberts, of Birmingham, England, by Elder J. N. Loughborough, while in England, and were written in a series of letters to a friend in Somerset, England, and published by request in the Signs of the Times, in March, 1881. As Elder Loughborough finds the same error prevalent where he is now laboring, he offers them to the REVIEW for the purpose of helping those who are hindered from the truth by the doctrine that there is no personal Devil.—EDS. REVIEW.]

LETTER FIRST.

My Dear Friend J.: In compliance with your request, I have carefully and prayerfully read the fifth of Mr. Roberts’s series of twelve printed lectures, and will now give you some of my thoughts on the subject. I understand him to take the position that the Devil is not a personal being, but only sin as it exists in the hearts of men.

It seems to me he tries too hard to confound the common view of the Devil with that held by pagans, without presenting proof of the same. He says:—

“In most systems of theology, the Devil is placed in juxtaposition with God. As the one is presented for worship, as the source and embodiment of all good, so the other is held up for detestation and dread, as the instigator and promoter of all evil. The one is regarded in the light of the good God, and the other as the bad God. It is the polytheism of paganism reduced to the smallest dimensions compatible with its existence.”

What pagans have taught and what Protestant Christians teach on this subject, I do not consider the same, and why should we assume that the one is the same as the other? We who believe in the existence of a personal Devil do not claim that he is a deity in any sense, but that he is a fallen being of a higher order than man, who uses his faculties and powers to war against truth and right. Neither do we claim that all evil deeds performed at the present time are directly and immediately from the Devil. There are presented in the Scriptures three sources from which temptations to evil arise; from the lusts of the human heart, from the world without, and from the Devil.

Mr. Roberts proceeds to state:—

“Satan is looked upon as the great bad agent, as God is looked upon as the great good agent, and the moral universe is the battle-field on which they measure strength in what would appear to be a somewhat unequal encounter.”

What believer in the Protestant idea of the Devil ever taught, either in print or otherwise, that God is “measuring strength” with the Devil? The Scriptures clearly set forth, as in the case of Job, that the Devil can go no further than permitted, and that finally he is to be completely overthrown; for Christ is to “destroy him that had the power of death, that is the Devil.” Heb. 2:14.

Again he says:—

“Common belief assigns something like omniscience to the evil being thus described; he is regarded as universally at work, alike active in England and America, and all other parts of the globe at the same time, and exerting his seductiveness in millions of hearts at once.”

Contrary to the above view, we believe the Bible statement that the Devil “walkethp. 452 about,” as a roaring lion, “seeking whom he may devour.” If he were omniscient, all things would be open before him, as in the case of God, and his “seeking,” which implies a lack of knowledge, and a dependence upon his researches for a knowledge, of those he could lead astray, would be unnecessary. Of the omniscient God we read, “All things are naked and opened unto the eyes of him with whom we have to do.” As to how Satan is working in various parts of the world at the same time, we read of “the Devil and his angels.” He may have his legions of angels in various parts of the world at the same time carrying out his purposes, equally called the work of the Devil. In special cases they may have their councils with the “Devil,” “the father” of lies.

After stating very positively that there is no personal Devil, Mr. Roberts says:—

“We are not unaware that apparent countenance is given to the doctrine in the Scriptures. . . . The apparent sanction accorded by the Scriptures to the idea of a personal, supernatural Devil, is no sanction at all, but arises from a misconstruction under educational bias of certain allusions to other agencies altogether.”

Having thus denied the existence of a personal Devil, although admitting that the Scriptures seem to speak of such a being, he passes on to show us what this Devil is. We quote:—

“The wages of sin is death.” Rom. 6:23. “Sin entered into the world, and death by sin.” Chapter 5:12. This is an eternal principle; death and sin are inseparable. “God only hath immortality” (1 Tim. 6:17); and he bestows it on the principle of obedience. Disobedience, which is sin, he will not tolerate; in every case he visits it with death. Therefore the angels which kept not their first estate, were cast down to hell (the grave) and reserved under chains of darkness (the bonds of death) (Jude 6; 2 Peter 2:4); therefore Adam was sentenced to return to the ground (Gen. 3:19); therefore Moses was prohibited from entering the promised land, and condemned to die (Deut. 32:48, 52); and therefore Uzzah was slain for harmlessly (humanly speaking) saving the ark from a fall (2 Sam. 6:6, 7). . . . With God is the fountain of life. Ps. 36:9. No one can steal a march upon him, so as to retain life and power in rebellion. ‘In his hand is the life of every living thing’ (Job 12:10), and he cuts away the life that would be lifted audaciously in antagonism to Heaven; he consigns to death all disobedience and sin.”—Page 153.

I have quoted the above in which he claims that the angels that sinned were cast into “the grave.” It is of considerable importance to know where these sinning angels were cast. The Bible testimony is not that they are dead, but that they are “reserved unto judgment,” intimating surely that they are not yet judged.

He says that the angels are “cast down to hell (the grave)” as though it were a foregone conclusion that the word “hell” in this text meant the grave. The word rendered “hell” in the New Testament, meaning the grave, is hades. The word rendered “hell,” referring to the place of the future punishment of the wicked, is “gehenna.” The word rendered “hell” in 2 Peter 2:4 is neither “hades” nor “gehenna,” but tartarus. The word occurs here only in its verbal form, tartaro-o, which means “to cast down to tartarus.” Is it so certain that tartarus means the grave, that Mr. Roberts can assert it without fear of criticism? Let us see. The word “tartaro-o” used by St. Peter is a verb signifying “to thrust down to tartarus.” As this case in Peter’s epistle is the only instance of the use of the word in the Scriptures, and as this does not clearly define the place, we will inquire for the meaning of the term “tartarus” when used as a noun. The Greek Lexicon of Liddell and Scott says: “Tartaro-o, to hurl or to cast into tartarus, N. T. Tartarus, a dark abyss, as deep below hades as earth below heaven. Later, tartarus was either the nether-world, generally, like hades, or the regions of the damned as opposed to the Elysian Fields.” Parkhurst, in his Lexicon, says: “In order to know what was the precise intention of the apostle by this expression, we must inquire what is the accurate import of the term ‘tartarus.’ Now it appears from a passage of Lucian that by tartarus was meant in a physical sense the verge, or bounds, of this material system, for he says: ‘Thou formedst the universe from its confused and chaotic state, and after separating and dispersing the circumfused chaos, in which, as in one common sepulcher, the whole world lay buried, thou drovest it to the confines of outer tartarus.’ Tartarus, then, in its proper physical sense, is the condensed, solid, and immovable darkness which surrounds the material universe. And thus tartarosas will import that God cast the apostate angels out of his presence into that blackness of darkness where they will be forever excluded from the light of his countenance.”

Lange, Dr. Bloomfield, Dr. Gill, and Dr. Whitby, all unite in the same testimony. It is not intimated in one of these writers that the tartarus of St. Peter is the grave, but it seems to me after carefully examining all the various writers on this subject, that tartarus is the name used by the Spirit of God for the great abyss of space into which Satan and his angels were cast after their rebellion, before the creation of man. The chains of darkness must signify a condition of hopeless despair, for literal chains cannot be made out of darkness.

His next statement I am not prepared to indorse without modification. He says: “No one can retain life and power in rebellion.” Some men have lived to a great age in sin and rebellion against God; the wise man, Solomon, says: “Because sentence against an evil work is not executed speedily, therefore the heart of the sons of men is fully set in them to do evil.” Eccl. 8:11. Job inquires: “Wherefore do the wicked live, become old, yea, are mighty in power? Their seed is established in their sight with them, and their offspring before their eyes. Their houses are safe from fear, neither is the rod of God upon them.” Job 21:7–9. If this is true of man, why may not the Devil,—a fallen angel, of a higher grade of being than man (though not immortal), endowed with a greater life force, perhaps sufficient to save him from decay for thousands of years,—why may he not live until destroyed at last in the lake of fire?

Man sinned and was cast out of Eden. Death was not executed upon him at once. Adam “lived nine hundred and thirty years, and he died.” In consequence of his sin the race is subjected to all the effects of mortality, and finally die; but when our cases come to judgment, we must receive, for our personal sins, “the second death.” So Satan and his angels that sinned were cast down, degraded from the joy and light of heaven to the darkness of tartarus, not yet finally judged because their sinful state is not yet completed. They are to be judged at last and consigned to the lake of fire. As these fallen angels now tempt mankind to sin, when their judgment comes, the saints of God who have overcome their temptations will have a part with Christ in judging them. 1 Cor. 6:3.

We are not of the class that, as Mr. Roberts intimates, claim that the Devil was created a Devil, and was “never nothing but a Devil.” We claim that he and other angels were placed on probation, not as immortal beings, but to decide their title to a second estate, and this they would secure by keeping “their first estate.” Jude 6. Instead of so doing, and becoming “as the angels of God in heaven,” to “die no more” (Luke 20:36), they left that estate (“sinned,” 2 Peter 2:4), and “fell from heaven.” Luke 10:18; Rev. 12:9. Of the Devil, Christ said: “He abode not in the truth.” John 8:44. It could not be said that he abode not in the truth if he never was in it. By a comparison of the above texts with other equally explicit statements of Scripture, we learn that he who is now called the “Devil” was once “in heaven,” “in the truth,” was “cast out,” and “his angels with him,” and thus he “fell from heaven,” and is now “going to and fro in the earth,” “like a roaring lion, seeking whom he may devour.” He is an outside foe who is to be resisted by steadfastness in the faith, and whom successfully to resist, it is needful to submit to God, and be clothed with his “whole armor.” James says, “Submit yourselves therefore to God. Resist the Devil, and he will flee from you.” James 4:7.

As to his question why it was necessary that the Devil should be “defeated through death,” I answer, Death is the penalty for sin. The Devil introduced death into our world by introducing sin. So Christ obtains power to destroy sin, death, and the Devil, by obtaining the victory over death, thereby demonstrating to all that he is more than a match for the full result of Satan’s deception. Having passed through death, he will destroy “him that had the power of death, that is, the Devil.” Heb. 2:14. Coming forth from the grave a victor would be a demonstration of his power to rescue all from death. So Christ says, “I am he that liveth and was dead, and am alive forevermore, and have the keys of hell and of death.”

On page 154 of the lectures we read:—

“The first general fact that strikes the attention is the entire absence from the Scriptures of a formal Devil theory. The word occurs often enough, but there is no affirmation of the doctrine popularly attached to the word. This is remarkable; for if the doctrine be true, why do we not find it explicitly detailed like other points of truth? The doctrine of God’s existence; of his creative powers; of his relation to his universe, is not only implied in the appellations he appropriates to himself, but formally propounded, ‘I am God, and there is none else.’ Isa. 46:9. ‘To whom then will ye liken me, or shall I be equal? saith the Holy One. Lift up your eyes on high, and behold who hath created these things.’ Chapter 40:25, 26. ‘Thou knowest my downsitting and mine uprising; thou understandest my thought afar off. Thou compassest my path and my lying down, and art acquainted with all my ways, For there is not a word in my tongue, but, lo, O Lord, thou knowest it altogether. Thou hast beset me behind and before, and laid thine hand upon me. Such knowledge is too wonderful for me; it is high, I cannot attain unto it. Whither shall I go from thy Spirit? or whither shall I flee from thy presence?’ Ps. 139:2–7. These and many other declarations affirm the verity of God’s existence, attributes, and power, but in the case of the supposed Devil we have no such information.”

He says we have “no such information.” I will simply say, The Devil is not “such” a being, therefore we do not expect to find such information concerning him—as we do of the almighty, omnipotent, and all-wise Creator. The Bible tells us what God did, and what he is doing; and, as Mr. Roberts justly concludes from this, there must be a personal deity called God. As previously shown, the Bible tells us also of the Devil as a being who was once “in the truth,” and “abode not in it,” who was “cast out of heaven,” “fell” from heaven “like lightning,” and who is now “going about” seeking to “devour” men. Why should we not admit this as proof of the Devil’s existence on the ground that we admit the other as proof of the existence of God? If we explain away what the Bible says of the Devil as only a myth of paganism, or a simple diffusion of the principle of evil through the world, who could deny the Spiritualist his claim that God is simply the principles of goodness and power diffused through all space, and that, therefore, everything is God?* If, as I admit, proof of the existence of a personal, true God is found in what the Bible says God did, why not admit that there is also a personal Devil from what the Bible says of him and of what he did and does?

(To be continued.)

Notes

  1. *In the Banner of Light, Feb. 3, 1866, a Spiritualist journal of Boston, we read: “The noble forest trees, sun, moon, and stars, all things, are gods to you; for they minister unto the needs of your soul.” In the same journal, December, 1865, we again read: “We understand God to be life, simply life; that is everywhere, no more in one place than in another.” In one of their books called, “Healing of the Nations,” page 297, they say: “If God is one, all must be fractional parts of him, and he alone be all.” In another of their works, “Reply to Dwight,” published by N. P. Tallmadge, page 81, we read: “I believe in one God and that God exists in one person, that the universe is filled with an immense ocean of life or spirit, which is the body of God.” After learning that the above is taught by Spiritualists, it need not astonish us to read in the same Banner of Light, “God’s face is seen in the violet, and men may well worship this tiny flower.” ↩