REASONS WANTED

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 16, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 29.

Read the full edition

REASONS WANTED.

The Rantoul (Ill.) Weekly Press, noticing the fact that the Illinois legislature has passed a bill closing barber-shops on Sunday, says: “The measure will no doubt arouse the enmity of the opponents of Sunday legislation, who will maintain it infringes upon their constitutional rights by compelling them to observe, as a religious day, one not so considered by their church. A rest day is necessary, and as a majority of the people consider Sunday the proper day, the legislature probably has authority to compel a cessation of business on that day.”
There are several principles involved in this statement for which, very obviously, a reason is demanded. It speaks of compelling people to observe as a religious day one which they do not consider of that character. That is impossible. It is beyond the power of man to make anything religious. Only a power which is above man and has a right to control the consciences of men, can do that. A man, to be sure, may be compelled to act, outwardly, as if the day was a religious day, but that is not religiously observing the day. Religious observance is a matter of the heart, and that man cannot determine, and cannot compel. That is trespassing upon the realm of the impossible.
A day of rest, it is said, is necessary. A day of rest in what sense? As a religious day, or as a sanitary measure? If it means as a religious day, then we ask, Who has the right to determine what religious necessities are? And if simply as a sanitary measure, again the question arises, What right has the government to control individual action in that respect, any more than to prescribe how many hours one shall sleep, how often he shall take a bath, and what kinds of food he shall eat? It can be taken only in one of these two senses, and in whichever one that may be, the government is wholly outside of its sphere in putting forth its arm to interfere in the matter.
“As a majority of the people think Sunday is the right day, the legislature probably has authority to compel” all the rest of the people to think so too, and to abstain from business accordingly. In putting forth this claim this writer surrenders every principle of religious liberty, turns his back upon all that has been achieved in behalf of equal rights to the present hour, and makes out every one who has struggled to throw off the oppression of tyranny, a fanatic, and every martyr who has laid down his life for his conscience, a fool. The tyrannical principle to which he bows down, is that when a majority agree on any one point of religious faith and practice, the government may rightly enforce the same upon the remainder of the people. If, then, the writer should go to a heathen country, where the majority worship idols, the government may rightly compel him to take part in such worship, and he has no ground for remonstrance. And if they should happen to believe in human sacrifices, they might rightfully compel him to share in the horrid rites. Such is the conclusion to which his logic derives him, and there is no evading it. But this very result should be enough to convince him of the illogical and dangerous ground he takes. The truth is that neither the majority, nor the government, nor any other human agency whatever, has anything to do in the control of any man’s conscience.
But in the case of Sunday, there is no obstacle whatever thrown in the way of any one who wishes to keep that day in any religious way he chooses; and if the majority are of that persuasion, and have nothing to interfere in the least with such action on their part, why do they not keep the day, and let that suffice? What more do they want? What conceivable reason is there, containing a particle of justice or consistency, in heaven, earth, or hell, why they should seek to compel every one else to do just as they do? For men who have adopted certain lines, either of faith or practice, to attempt to compel all other men, as soon as they have the power, to conform to the same lines, when they do not wish to do so, and especially if it imposes inconvenience and loss upon the dissenters, is tyranny in its most odious form. It is only to gratify the bloated spirit of self-conceit and of their own importance, which leads them to wish thus to lord it over other men. The fact that they outnumber those who differ with them, confers upon them no right to take control of the consciences of the minority. Neither has the government any right in the premises. A man is to render unto God the things that are God’s. It is a matter between himself and God alone. Give to Cæsar the things that are Cæsar’s, no one will find any fault with that; but hands off, ye meddlesome conscience mongers, from those things that belong only to God. U. S.