AdventAI

THE FISH AND THE TEMPLE TAX.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 27., July 2, 1895

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

The city of Capernaum was situated upon the shore of the sea of Galilee. The home of Peter, with whom our Lord occasionally abode, was in this place. Few cities were so highly favored as Capernaum by the manifestations of the miraculous power of Christ. Among the wonders enacted there by the Saviour, there are few, if any, more striking and more full of instruction than the miracle by which the Master made a fish of the sea of Galilee pay for himself and Peter the temple tax, which every Jew was expected to meet. The history of the event cannot be better presented than by reproducing the narrative as found in Matthew, by whom alone the account of the transaction has been preserved. Here it is: “And when they were come to Capernaum, they that received tribute money came to Peter, and said, Doth not your master pay tribute? He saith, Yes. And when he was come into the house, Jesus prevented him, saying, What thinkest thou, Simon? of whom do the kings of the earth take custom or tribute? of their own children, or of strangers? Peter saith unto him, Of strangers. Jesus saith unto him, Then are the children free. Notwithstanding, lest we should offend them, go thou to the sea, and cast an hook, and take up the fish that first cometh up; and when thou hast opened his mouth, thou shalt find a piece of money; that take, and give unto them for me and thee.” Matt. 17:24-27.

Peter being owner of the house in which Christ was domiciled, it was very natural that the tax gatherers should inquire of him whether the Saviour held himself subject to that tax. It was very natural, also, that Peter, himself a Jew, should answer their query in the affirmative, since he, no doubt, was anxious to impress them favorably with the teachings and character of Christ. Possibly, however, Peter’s reply was not, in the strictest sense, true to the facts. Such a conclusion is suggested by the remark of Christ. “Of whom,” said he, “do the kings of the earth take custom or tribute? of their own children, or of strangers?” To this Peter replied, “Of strangers,” when Christ rejoined, “Then are the children free.” The point of what Christ said seems to be this: If the kings of the earth do not require tribute of their own families, but simply of those outside of their families; i. e., their subjects, I am under no obligation to pay the temple tax, inasmuch as I am the Son of God and therefore free, becausep. 420 I am the Son of the great King who imposed the same. After this striking assertion of his own divinity, the Saviour instructed Peter, who was subject to the tax in question, to go to the sea and cast in his hook, informing him at the same time that he would find in the mouth of the first fish which he should take, a piece of money of sufficient value to pay the tax for both Peter and himself. Matthew does not record the final accomplishment of the miracle in question, but there can be no doubt that Peter carried out the injunction of Christ, found the piece of money, and paid the temple tax as directed; since, otherwise, he would have disobeyed the positive command of the Saviour, and since, otherwise, all the directions given by Christ to Peter would have been but idle talk. In view, therefore, of the certainty that the miracle under consideration was actually enacted, it will be profitable at this time to consider the lessons to be drawn therefrom.

The first to which attention is called is that conveyed by the words, “And when he was come into the house, Jesus prevented him, saying, What thinkest thou, Simon? of whom do the kings of the earth take custom or tribute? of their own children, or of strangers?” The word “prevented,” as used in this connection, is liable to be misunderstood by the reader. Formerly, or when our King James Version was translated, it was the equivalent of the modern term, “anticipated.” In the Revised Version, it is translated, “spake first to him.” From this we understand that Jesus did not wait for Peter to tell him what had transpired outside of the house; but anticipated him by asking a question which showed that he knew all about the conversation, which had taken place between Peter and the gatherers of the temple tax. Such a knowledge as this on the part of our Lord, under such circumstances, must have been very surprising to Peter, and proved that Christ in his divine nature was not dependent upon the natural ear for his knowledge of what those around him were conversing about.

The second deduction to be drawn from the miracle of the fish and the tribute money, relates to the wisdom and power of Christ in producing results by a word. Mark it, the Saviour did not even go to the sea himself, but told Peter to do so, predicting the exact results which would follow. Consider these results from whatever standpoint you please, the consequences are the same.

The fish which Peter took and in the mouth of which he found the shekel, either picked up that shekel somewhere in the sea, or else Christ must have created the shekel or in some way caused it to be placed in the fish’s mouth just at the right time to fulfill his prediction to the apostle. Adopt the first hypothesis, and Christ must have been divine; otherwise he could not have possessed wisdom to enable him to know beforehand that there was a certain fish in the sea of Galilee which had obtained and carried in its mouth a shekel, and that this identical fish would, at the proper time, be at the exact spot where Peter dropped in his hook and also be the first fish to bite at that hook. Adopt the second conclusion; i. e., that Christ either created the shekel for the purpose in question, or caused it to be transported and deposited in the fish’s mouth just at the right time to fulfill his prophecy, and you acknowledge that he exerted a power which proved him to be no less a personage than the divine Son of God. This is so since no mere human being could produce such results in such a way.

The third lesson inculcated by the miracle passing in review is that of perfect surrender of the individual will and understanding to the will and wisdom of Christ. Peter was a man of like habits of thought with ourselves. It would have been very natural for him to reason with himself on this wise: What the Master commands me to do, I will not attempt; for, should I do so, I would but make myself the butt of ridicule for others. The thing which he declares will take place, is not only improbable but also impossible, and no one but a simpleton would go to the sea and throw in his hook with the expectation of taking a fish having a shekel in his mouth. These, I say, would have been the thoughts which would naturally pass through the mind of Peter when Christ instructed him as he did. How fortunate that he did not listen to these suggestions; but, on the contrary, with implicit faith in the ability of Christ to fulfill all that he said, performed without hesitation his part in the capture of the fish and the payment of the tax; thus insuring the enactment of a miracle which teaches in the most forcible manner possible the beautiful lesson that it is safe to obey Christ, even when in so doing one would seem to believe in the impossible.

The fourth and last lesson of the parable to be considered at this time is the light which it throws upon the practice of Christ in the matter of avoiding unnecessary prejudice and so relating one’s self even to a fallen Church and an unjust State as to impress them favorably by going as far as one can in doing everything that they require, so long as such action on his part does not involve the commission of actual sin. Christ was under no obligation to pay the temple tax; but in order to reach the Jewish priests with the great and important truths of his gospel, he worked a wonderful miracle by which to produce the shekel that enabled Peter to pay the temple tax for Christ and himself. Should it be replied that the temple tax was an ecclesiastical tax, I answer, Very true; but the principle involved is just the same. An unjust civil tax is no worse than an unjust ecclesiastical tax, and if it was proper to go out of his way as far as Christ did to mollify the feelings of a hostile priesthood, it is safe to conclude that he would have gone just as far out of his way to reach and save the officers of the civil law who sought to do him wrong. Indeed, when the Saviour illustrated his exemption from the temple tax by the figure drawn from the kings of the earth, he tacitly admitted that the principle involved was the same, whether the tax was a civil or an ecclesiastical one.