THOSE who have on their hands the task of upholding the first day of the week as the Sabbath of the Bible, have the hardest job to perform ever undertaken by man. They would be deserving of the most profound sympathy and pity were it not for the fact that no man is obliged to attempt the impossible; and the further fact that when one sees that he is in error, it is his duty to abandon it. Their efforts imply a degree of willfulness which is entitled to no sympathetic consideration whatever.
But it may be said that they do not think their position to be error. Possibly that may be so, yet we apprehend there is great truth in the recent statement in the Chicago Inter Ocean, that “Sunday is not the Sabbath, and the ministers know that it is not.” And, in fact, we rarely see a so-called argument put forth in behalf of Sunday observance which ought not to have convinced the writer (as it probably did) that there is no support whatever in the Scriptures for Sunday-keeping.
A correspondent of the Texas Baptist recently addressed to that paper the following question: “Was the Sabbath [which is] recognized by the laws of the United States, established by the Roman Catholics, as asserted by the Seventh-day Adventists?” To this that paper answered, “No; the first day of the week was kept holy to the Lord by Christians during the apostolic age, several centuries before the Roman Catholic Church had an existence.”
A great misapprehension exists on this point, and it is clearly voiced in the foregoing quotation. It is assumed that nothing can be attributed to the Roman Catholic Church except such acts and institutions as have been adopted since that church became fully organized as such, and, as an ecclesiastical hierarchy, had mounted to the throne of power. Thus it is claimed that the observance of the Sunday antedates the Roman Catholic Church by several centuries; whereas, the truth is that the Roman Catholic Church, in its principles and spirit, antedates the Sunday observance, as in any respect a Christian institution, over one hundred years. What we mean by its principles and spirit, is what Paul means when discussing the papacy in 2 Thess. 2:1-8, he attributes its development to the “mystery of iniquity,” which he said had already begun to work in his day. That is, the spirit and principles and policy, from which the Roman Catholic Church afterward became established as a logical necessity, began to intrude itself into the Christian church in the very days of the apostles themselves; and from that point the Roman Catholic Church really dates. But this does not prove the Roman Catholic Church to be an apostolic church; for it was the mystery of iniquity then; and it is the mystery of iniquity still. But Sunday had no standing in the Christian church at that time. No; the papacy was working before the Sunday came into the church; and it was the working of that spirit that brought it in; and that is what we mean when we say that the Sunday sabbath is an institution of the papacy.p. 426
It is natural to men to bring in as many old views into new systems as possible. The heathen began to embrace Christianity rapidly, and tried to ingraft upon it many of their old heathen notions. With them Sunday had long been “the wild solar holiday” of their old pagan times; and they took kindly to any regard paid to it as a Christian institution. There is not one syllable of truth in the assertion that it was regarded as a sacred day by the apostles; for not till the beginning of the third century was there any idea of a cessation from labor on that day; and not till the fourth century was there any law to regulate its observance in any particular.
The Baptist says that Constantine’s Sunday law was not a Roman Catholic enactment, but was issued by a despotic emperor as corrupt and cruel as Henry VIII. Very true; for Constantine was then a heathen emperor, and made his Sunday law in behalf of that institution as a heathen festival. The spirit of popery had, however, by that time so fostered a regard for Sunday in the Christian church that Sylvester, “by occupation, pope,” saw that the opportune moment had arrived, and seized the law of Constantine to enforce Sunday on the so-called Christian church. Constantine having provided the boiler with a fresh supply of fuel and water, Sylvester, pope, cunningly turned the switch that transferred the machine to the Christian track. The papacy, though not yet raised to its supremacy, had now become a powerful hierarchy; and the whole transaction of making Sunday a Christian institution was prosecuted by the spirit of that system of apostasy which the papacy then represented, and which in its principles, policy, and incipient stages, could be traced back to the days of the apostles themselves, but which, a little later developed into the full-fledged papal power. From that time on the advance was rapid; and in less than half a century, that is, in 364 A. D., the Council of Laodicea anathematized the keeping of the seventh day, which had been observed by great multitudes, perhaps a majority, of the church up to that time.
We come now to the Baptist’s alleged reasons for the change from the seventh to the first day of the week. It admits that the ten commandments “have not been changed,” but “are all equally binding upon all men in all time.” So far good, but now hear this: “Not the commandment, but the day upon which it is to be observed, has been changed by divine authority.” But how can the day be changed, and yet the commandment, which depends upon the day, and points out a definite day and the manner of its observance, not be changed? This is a mystery that surpasses the oracles of ancient paganism. There may be men who think they believe such assertions as this; but if it is true that “faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God,” they cannot seriously believe it; for we do not “hear” anything in the word of God concerning it. It is simply a makeshift, to which they resort to help themselves out of a difficult dilemma. And it is of no use to ask them where the “divine authority” is, to which they so coolly appeal, and when, how, why, and where, it was given; for this very testimony has been called for a thousand times, but never yet has been produced; and it never will be, for it does not exist.
Texas Baptist.—“The first-day Sabbath is observed in commemoration of the finished work of human redemption.”
Is any one willing to take that view of the matter and consider redemption finished, and stop where we are? We are happy to think that there is more to come, and that we are to be made immortal and glorified and have an eternal kingdom.
T. B.—“The latter transaction [redemption] was of infinitely greater importance to fallen man than the former [creation].”
How wise we mortals be! How able we are to comprehend both creation and redemption! and size them up! and tell just which of the two is the greater and the more important! O yes; these little matters, the pompous we, of 1895, can put in our vest pockets and examine and decide upon at our leisure. And when we decide that one is the greater, which we wish to have so because it will furnish us a pretext for a conclusion which we want to draw, then we take the commandment out of the decalogue and put another in its place, based upon our profound conclusions! It has always seemed to us an impenetrable mystery how a person could claim that the commandment has not been repealed, and is not to be changed in its wording, and then proceed to disregard what the commandment enjoins, and read in, and practice, another institution, which turns the unchanged and unchangeable wording of that commandment into a lie.
Then look at this for another argument: “When Jesus said that the Sabbath was made for man, and that he was Lord of the Sabbath, he implied that he not only had authority to change the day, but that he would make it subserve the greatest good to all men.”
Implied power, indeed! But we are not told that that power was designed for any such purpose, nor that it was ever used to that end. But what is to subserve the greatest good? The answer must be, The day. Which day? the original or the substitute? Before it is changed, or after?
One more point. The T. B. says: “We are not told, in so many words, that Christ changed the day for Sabbath-keeping, but it seems to be irresistibly implied.”
Can any one tell us what an irresistible implication is? We have heard of irresistible arguments, but an irresistible implication, what is that? An implication is something understood or implied, but not expressed. A fact never expressed, but yet irresistible! What next? As compared with the Sabbath, we are “told in so many words,” in regard to that, when it was made, why it was made, for whom it was made, how it was to be observed, and how long to continue. Let us have something like this in regard to Sunday, or a cessation of these imitations of arguments.
We need not notice the references made by the Baptist to the resurrection, to Pentecost, to Acts 20:7; 2 Cor. 16:2; Rev. 1:10; for all these are made the basis of assumptions nearly as hollow as those already noticed.
The article closes with the assertion that ever since the resurrection the first day has been observed, but for which no shadow of evidence is produced, and then adds: “Remember it, to keep it holy.” We cannot keep a thing holy that has never been made holy. Just tell us when the first day has been made holy, and we will try to keep it so—when it was ever made a Sabbath to take the place of the original institution, and where we are commanded to keep it, and we will join in its observance. U. S.