AdventAI

PAPAL SOVEREIGNTY.

By Wm. Penniman

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 26., June 25, 1895

BY WM. PENNIMAN.

(Woodburn, Ill.)

The Portland Press of July 2, 1894, reported a sermon by Dr. Blanchard on the grandeur, the error, and the danger of the dogma of papal sovereignty. His text was Matt. 21:21: “Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.” We only quote briefly from what the doctor says, as follows: “The American principle is that Church and State shall be forever separate. Jesus seems to be in sympathy with that principle. An ecclesiastical power, however, would make the Church superior to, and dominant over, the State. . . . The doctrine exists, although many Catholics do not know of its existence. Cardinal Manning is good authority. He says on page 97 of the third volume of his sermons on ecclesiastical subjects, in speaking for the pope: ‘I claim to be the supreme judge on earth and the director of the consciences of men; of the peasant that tills the field, and of the prince that sits on the throne; of the household that lives in the shade of privacy, and of the legislature that makes laws for kingdoms. I am the sole, last, supreme judge on earth of what is right and wrong.’” The doctor then says: “If any man denies that this doctrine exists, let him inform himself. If any man—layman, editor, priest, or bishop—denies it, the speaker would suspect his scholarship.”

Again: the Press represents the speaker as dwelling upon the grandeur of the doctrine, not only in picturing the office of the pope, but also in especially eulogizing Gregory VII. and Leo XIII., picturing the office as representing God and magnifying their sovereignty over all the world. He said that if the doctrines were true, he, too, would bow down before the pope as supreme ruler of men. There is no evidence that Jesus appointed Peter to be head of the church. History shows the successive steps by which the dogma arose. Besides the error, there is danger from this doctrine of papal sovereignty.

We are glad to see this Protestant D.D. as outspoken as he is on this subject, and wish that many more were as much opposed to the union of Church and State as he. But we think he handles the question too much with gloves, in calling it an error, when in truth it is a blasphemous sin for the pope to assume the power which he claims. We agree with the doctor, that there is danger in this doctrine, which is not only erroneous but blasphemous. Vicar-general Preston, in a sermon in New York, Jan. 1, 1888, said: “Every word that Leo speaks from his high chair is the voice of the Holy Ghost, and must be obeyed. To every Catholic heart comes no thought but obedience. It is said that politics is not within the province of the church, and that the church has only jurisdiction in matters of faith. ‘I will receive my faith from the pontiff, but I will not receive my politics from him.’ This assertion is disloyal and untruthful. You must not think as you choose; you must think as Catholics. The man who says, ‘I will take my faith from Peter, but I will not take my politics from Peter,’ is not a true Catholic. The church teaches that the supreme pontiff must be obeyed, because he is the vicar of the Lord. Christ speaks through him.”

We have given good Catholic authority from Cardinal Manning, whom all Catholics as well as many Protestants respect, and also from Vicar-general Preston; and it will be well for Catholics who are ignorant of what they say to inform themselves, and especially of what Vicar Preston says, that they must not think as they choose, but think as Catholics. (Italics mine.) Woe to the Catholic world in permitting the pope to think for it. Woe to the Protestant, who, by respecting some of the papal institutions, acknowledges his power. It is no wonder that Dr. Blanchard is charmed with the grandeur of the “supreme ruler of men,” when all the world is now wondering after the scarlet-colored beast. How plain it is that this beast is the same of which we read in Rev. 13:18, and that he wears, or has worn on his miter the words, Vicarius Filii Dei, which means the “vicar” or “vice-gerent” of the Son of God.

Again: it is the same power of which the prophet Daniel speaks: “He shall speak great words against the Most High.” Dan. 7:25. Also the same power spoken of as the “man of sin” (2 Thess. 2:3, 4): “Let no man deceive you by any means; for that day shall not come, except there come a falling away first, and that man of sin be revealed, the son of perdition; who opposeth and exalteth himself above all that is called God, or that is worshiped; so that he as God sitteth in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God.”

What Cardinal Manning has said proves the fulfillment of this scripture in the pope’s claim to be the supreme judge on earth and the director of the consciences of men. It is further proved by his styling himself, “Lord God the pope.” It will be well for those who think there is no danger in the doctrine of papal supremacy, to scan the past, and let the ashes of between fifty and one hundred million martyrs testify.