Inasmuch as a query has been raised as to the propriety of asking the governor of Tennessee to pardon our brethren imprisoned some weeks since in Dayton, a few words of explanation may not be amiss.
It was my privilege to be in Nashville at the time the pardons were issued, and to have some part in securing them. I had a letter of introduction from a gentleman in Dayton to Colonel Baker, a member of the House. I had several conversations with the colonel, and in one of them he suggested that we ask the governor to pardon the imprisoned men. I immediately told him that I did not think the governor would do so, because they would not agree to keep the law in the future. Colonel Baker insisted, however, that he could secure the pardons, and talked with the governor about it, who promised to pardon the men if the trial judge would recommend it. Colonel Baker asked me to write to Judge Parks, asking for such a recommendation. I had become quite well acquainted with the judge at Dayton, and so wrote him a letter explaining the situation to him, and asking him if he would kindly recommend the pardon. He did so, sending the recommendation to me. I then gave it to Colonel Baker, who took it to the governor.
Both Judge Parks, who recommended the pardons, and Governor Turney, who issued them, understood the attitude of our people toward the Sunday law, and there was no promise on the part of our brethren either expressed or implied, that they would obey the law in the future. They had plainly said in open court that they could not obey the law, and had given their reasons. They had sent a memorial to the legislature, setting forth the facts of their imprisonment and their attitude toward the law, and declaring that they could not obey it; and I placed a copy of this memorial in the governor’s hands the day the pardons were granted, and before they were issued. But even aside from that, Governor Turney must have understood that Seventh-day Adventists would not obey the Sunday law, as he was upon the Supreme Bench when the Parker case was decided, and also when the King case was before the court, so that he certainly acted intelligently in what he did.
He doubtless saw the injustice that the law was working, and while as judge he was in duty bound to uphold the law, as executive it was entirely his prerogative to remit its unrighteous penalty in the cases of our brethren. This he did without any assurance from the prisoners that they would obey the law in the future, because of his sense of the injustice that was being done them. For this we honor Governor Turney. In consideration of the circumstances, there is but one explanation which I can suggest, and that is that it was so ordered in the providence of God as a confession on the part of the State of Tennessee, by her chief executive, to the injustice of the law. It was entirely unexpected by Adventists, and was wholly unsought by them except the small part which I took in writing to Judge Parks for his recommendation.
C. P. Bollman.
Observations.—While willingly giving place to the above communication from the editor of the American Sentinel, without intending to censure the action referred to or its critics, it is difficult to forbear adding a few observations. All should realize that it is often far easier to sit by the fire at home and tell how a thing ought to be done, than to do just that way in the actual emergency. We are traveling over a new road, through a strange experience, and errors of judgment may appear; but let us remember there are two ways in which we may err: On one side to be too regardless of principle; on the other to be so strenuous in maintaining what we regard as principle as to sacrifice consistency, or, as the saying goes, standing so erect that we lean backward. A little experience often teaches people things upon which a good deal of theory never could enlighten them. Therefore, while others are getting the experience, let us not be too ready to criticise, lest in straining out a gnat of error we swallow a camel of inconsistency. To do just right always, harmonizes with both principle and consistency. Worldly policy would lead us to sacrifice both; and rigidly ignoring all circumstances will often do the same. “Be ye therefore wise as serpents, and harmless as doves.”