ACCORDING TO THEIR WORKS.
By Uriah Smith
In the account of the final judgment, John says that “the books were opened; . . . and the dead were judged out of those things which were written in the books, according to their works.” Rev. 20:12. The judgment here includes the retribution due to those who are judged. But there is a difference in the works recorded in the books. There are different degrees of guilt attaching to different individuals. There must, therefore, be a difference in degrees of punishment, if that is meted out according to their works. “Then,” says the believer in the immortality of the wicked and the eternal duration of their conscious misery, “the doctrine of the final destruction of the wicked cannot be true; for there can be no degrees of punishment in the condition of total extinction of being. And on the other hand some of those who believe the latter doctrine are about ready to deny a difference in degrees of punishment, which seems to be so clearly set forth in the Scriptures.” We shall undertake to show that there are degrees in the punishment of the wicked, and that the doctrine that the wages of sin is death, is also true, and that there is no conflict between these views. The Bible seems so clearly to recognize degrees of punishment for the wicked, that it is generally accepted without question; that is, that some are more guilty than others, and that the more guilty will be punished with more severity than the less guilty, according to their deeds. The statement so often made in the Scriptures, that every man shall be rewarded “according to his works,” recognizes this principle, in a general way; for it is evident to all that the works of some are far more heinous than the works of others, which are also bad; and the instinct of justice implanted in every heart at once says that the sentence against these more wicked acts should be framed accordingly, as is done even in courts of justice here upon the earth. Again: Paul shows by his own experience that there are degrees in human guilt, and that this fact will be taken into account in dealing with the offender. Speaking of himself, in 1 Tim. 1:13, he says: “Who was before a blasphemer, and a persecutor, and injurious; but I obtained mercy, because I did it ignorantly in unbelief.” Here the apostle pleads, in extenuation of his actions, the fact of his ignorance. This made him less guilty, and made possible a more lenient manner of dealing with him. Had he done these things with his eyes open, and to gratify a conscious spirit of diabolical hatred against the gospel of Christ, could he then have received mercy? Had he persisted in his injurious course, would he not have soon put himself beyond the reach of God’s grace? James also uses language which conveys the same idea (3:1): “My brethren, be not many masters, knowing that we shall receive the greater condemnation. For in many things we offend all.” Here he shows that though we all offend in many things, and are blameworthy on this account, we may take a course to subject ourselves to greater condemnation, or become more guilty, than if we had refrained from such a course. In Heb. 10:28, 29 the apostle Paul uses expressions which throw great light on this question. He says: “He that despised Moses’s law died without mercy under two or three witnesses; of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot the Son of God, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, wherewith he was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace.” Here a sorer penalty is recognized for the greater sin. But perhaps the most direct statement of any on this question is found in Luke 12:47, 48: “And that servant, which knew his lord’s will, and prepared not himself, neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes. But he that knew not, and did commit things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes. For unto whomsoever much is given, of him shall be much required.” And this, as shown by the preceding verses, was spoken to show how God will deal with us in our final account. The fact of degrees of punishment being thus established, the believer in eternal suffering, as already stated, is disposed to use it against the view that the destiny of the wicked is cessation of conscious being in death; for how, it is asked, can there be any degrees in that condition? So far as the condition itself, abstractly considered, is concerned, there can be no degrees; for one cannot be more dead than another, nor more unconscious than another in death, where consciousness is completely extinct in both. But there is something more to be taken into consideration. The wages of sin is not simply “to be dead,” but it is “death;” and death includes all that leads to death, embracing, of course, the process of dying with all the conditions, emotions, and feelings attendant thereon; and in that process there are tribulation and anguish. The apostle sets forth these very conditions, as included in the penalty for sin. Mark well his words: “Who [God] will render to every man according to his deeds; . . . indignation and wrath, tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that doeth evil.” Rom. 2:6–9. Degrees of punishment must, of course, be confined to that stage of the infliction during which consciousness continues; for there can be no difference after that. Now we ask the believer in eternal suffering how he will have degrees of punishment in his scheme, since the punishment of all is to be eternal? He will doubtless say that the degrees will be secured in the intensity of the suffering; that some will suffer severer pain than others, according to their guilt. Then, it may be replied that, on the hypothesis of final unconsciousness as the wages of sin, there is a place for the same distinction. That is, in the process of dying, some may suffer much more intensely and keenly than others, according to their guilt. But right here there is another important element in favor of this view; namely, the element of duration; for while the suffering of some may be more intense than that of others, it may be also much longer continued, according to the degrees of their guilt; and so there would be, on this ground, a double means of adjusting the penalty to the degrees of guilt and the awards of judgment. On the other hand, with the idea of eternal conscious suffering, there can be no degrees of punishment; for, remember, this is held to be absolutely without end; it is infinite; and we can find no degrees in infinity. What matters it if at any particular time one is suffering less than another, if the former is to come at length to the same degree of suffering as the other? and that whatever degree the most guilty may have reached, the others are destined in due time, to reach the same; and this without any end? No; this can never be. The justice of God and the harmony of the Scriptures can be fully vindicated only on the ground of a correct view of God’s dealings with his creatures, which is that those only who choose life will have that glorious boon at last in eternal possession, while those who reject God’s gracious offer, will reap the result of their course finally in the second death, and become as though they had not been. Obadiah 16. There is genuine satisfaction in finding and cherishing a truth which vindicates the character of God, and enables us to exclaim with patriarch and prophet, “Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?” and, “Just and true are thy ways, thou King of saints.” Gen. 18:25; Rev. 15:3. U. S.