ANOTHER. ARREST FOR SUNDAY LABOR.
By S. H. LANE
As noticed in last week's REVIEW, brother J. F. Rothrock, of West Salem, Ill., was arrested Monday, May 20, for keeping open his store on Sunday, May 19. Brother Rothrock is a member of the State Conference committee of the Seventh-day Adventist Conference of Illinois. He has been running a store in the village during the last few months. He was arrested for the violation of a village ordinance, which only went into effect two days before he was arrested. The trial was set for the next Thursday afternoon. He employed counsel. Two lawyers were employed by the town board. The ordinance is a strong one in relation to “Sabbath desecration,” as it terms it. As the hour of the trial approached, it was seen that the town-hall, where suits are generally tried, would not hold the people, so the opera-hall was secured, which was packed full. Our people are well known in the village, as they have a meeting-house in it, and meet there every Sabbath. Brother Rothrock’s brother is the sheriff of the county. The leading hotel of the town is run by a relative of his, while another brother, who owns a farm, lives in the village or on its outskirts. Brother Rothrock waived a jury trial, so the case was tried before the justice. The men, or at least some of them, who had purchased goods on Sunday, were sworn. They testified that they had purchased goods, but when asked if there was any disturbance in or around the store, all, without an exception, declared that all was perfectly civil. A gentleman who is a member of one of the churches, and lives but ten or fifteen feet from the store, swore that, although the store was run every Sunday, he had not been disturbed. Indeed, there was not a man among all that were sworn that testified that there had been any disturbance. The argument of the lawyers for the prosecution was that labor that might be civil on Monday or on any day of the week, would be uncivil on Sunday. One took the position that those who keep the seventh day had diseased consciences. He would not argue that Sunday was the Sabbath of the Creator. We were advised to correct our consciences. It was stated by the opposing lawyers that brother Rothrock was one of the best citizens and a Christian, but that if he were allowed to break a village ordinance, what could be expected of men who were not Christians? The town board, with one exception, testified under oath that they thought that the running of a store on Sunday was uncivil. The one said that that matter depended, he thought, on a man’s religious views. Then several of our brethren were placed on the stand, and asked if they thought running a store on Sunday was uncivil. When they testified that they did not, they were questioned if they thought running the store on Saturday would be uncivil. They answered, No. The answer astonished the lawyers; they seemed nonplused and were soon taking counsel with each other. When the witnesses finished their testimony, our lawyer made a short address in reference to the exemption clause in Illinois Sunday law, and then Elder Scoles and the writer were given an opportunity to address the crowd. I followed the lawyer, dwelling on the distinction between civil and religious rights. Elder J. W. Scoles followed, speaking on the rights of conscience as protected by the word of God, the Constitution of the United States and of the State of Illinois. The people listened to our remarks with rapt attention. It did indeed seem strange to preach to a large crowd in a court room. When the scene ended, some were filled with prejudice as at the first, but many came forward and seemed so friendly that one could not but feel that an excellent impression had been made, and on a class that would not have come to the church or even a tent to hear us preach. When I took the train at night to go to Chicago, two of the opposing lawyers were on the train. One came to me and said, “I want to congratulate you and Mr. Scoles on your speeches. Your positions were sound. Had not the law been against you, you would have carried your cases.” “If you,” they both said, “will come to our place and preach, we will come and hear you. We never tried a case like this before, when preachers plead, and a church-member, who is an excellent citizen and a Christian, was under arrest.” One thing more I want to speak of, and that is this: When our brethren were placed on the stand and questioned, every position that they took was sound with relation to religious liberty principles. The Sentinel has not been read in vain. The case was decided against us, and brother Rothrock was fined $10 and costs. He appealed to the Circuit Court, where the case will be tried not under a town ordinance but under the law of Illinois. S. H. LANE.