AdventAI

As our readers are aware, brother Geo. I. Butler has been having a good measure of success in his tent-meetings in Bartow, Fla., and as may readily be inferred, he has also met with the most determined opposition on the part of some, including the clergy. The comparison of views has got into print, and the following is the reply of brother Butler to one of the attacks made upon him, which will explain itself. While keenly dissecting the positions urged in opposition to the truth, it is presented in a spirit worthy of emulation by other laborers who have like opposition to meet. As such we commend it to their consideration:—

“SABBATH QUESTION—REPLY TO MESSRS. NASH AND TATUM.

“Ed. News: From your issue of May 4 it would seem that my expression of opinion that the arguments of Mr. Nash or any others in behalf of Sunday sacredness were anything but ‘convincing,’ had stirred up these estimable gentlemen exceedingly. Indeed, the way Mr. Nash indulges in hard names and strong adjectives, almost suggests a parallel to that polite pirate captain, ‘the mildest mannered man that ever scuttled a ship or cut a throat.’ We all know him to be naturally a kind-hearted, courteous, Christian gentleman, who would ordinarily use mild, pleasant words to a brother minister of any church. But because I fail to see the strength of Sunday arguments he and others use, I am ‘a little pope, sure of my own infallibility,’ dealing in ‘unsustained assumptions,’ and ‘virtually declare thousands of great and good men . . . fools and knaves,’ etc., etc. I am charitable enough to believe such language is not natural to Mr. Nash’s usual kindness of heart, but comes from drinking the spirit of bitterness so prevalent in his new-found book against Seventh-day Adventists, which have furnished the principal portion of his ammunition in the recent Sunday argument. The bitterness of an apostate is proverbial, and Mr. Nash has simply been like ‘poor dog Tray,’ in bad company. I hardly feel like holding him responsible for these bitter invectives. But I greatly fear, if he continues to oppose the truth of the Bible, this spirit will continue so to develop as greatly to injure his usefulness.

“But really am I the only one who is so egotistical and blind that I cannot see the force of the Sunday argument? Mr. V. P. Simmons, in the same column with the article of Mr. Nash’s, says: ‘I have long since given up trying to defend the first-day theory from any Scriptural legality.’ And he is a Sunday-keeper.

“The Chicago Inter Ocean, one of the great dailies of our country, in its issue of April 23, 1895, says, editorially: ‘Once for all this clerical juggling with words should cease. Sunday is not the Sabbath of the Bible, and every preacher knows it is not. . . . There is not a passage of Scripture, not one, in which commandment is given for change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first. . . . We know of no divine command for the observance of Sunday; we make bold to say that there is no direct divine command for its usage.’

“I also give the following extract from a Catholic priest, employed by that church to lecture in various parts of the North in behalf of its doctrines:—

“Jan. 11, 1892.

“Dear Friend: I have repeatedly offered $1000 to any one who can prove to me from the Bible alone that I am bound to keep Sunday holy. There is no such law in the Bible. It is a law of the holy Catholic Church alone. The Bible says, ‘Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath day.’ The Catholic Church says, ‘No; by my divine power I abolish the Sabbath day and command you to keep holy the first day of the week;’ and lo! the entire civilized world bows down in reverent obedience to the command of the holy Catholic Church. Yours respectfully, T. Enright, Css. R Lock Box 75, Kansas City, Mo.”

“Brother Nash in his discourse at the courthouse distinctly stated that he did not claim there was any command in the Bible to observe the first day of the week. He only claimed to find in it certain inferences which he thought implied it had taken the place of the original Sabbath. And these he felt it necessary to strengthen by appealing to the Christian Fathers, Barnabas, Clement, et al., with which to supplement the authority of his Bible in behalf of Sunday-keeping, thereby really confessing that the Scriptures were not sufficient. The degree of authority of such authors as these two, with their peculiar additions to natural history, such as that the hyena changes its sex each year, ‘at one time male and at another female,’ and the famous Phoenix of Clement, which lives just 500 years, and flies from Arabia to Heliopolis, in Egypt, to die, I will leave brother Nash to inform us. Of course he and the ‘combined consensus of Christian scholarship of the world’ may need and use such; but I prefer the blessed Bible.

“As to the ‘unsustained’ and false assumptions which he and friend Tatum attribute to me, for the benefit of the readers of the News who have not heard me at the tent, I will give a few specimens. ‘And he [God] rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it; because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.’ Gen. 2: 3. This was in the garden of Eden before sin entered, more than 2000 years before there was a Jew, where God made the Sabbath ‘for man’ (i. e., for the whole race). Mark 2: 27, 28. ‘Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy.’ ‘The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.’ ‘For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.’ Ex. 20: 8–11. This Sabbath Christ kept while on the earth, as all must admit; for he declares: ‘I have kept my Father’s commandments.’ John 15: 10. None claim he ever kept Sunday. Hence no man follows Christ’s example who keeps Sunday. He declares that he came not to destroy the law. ‘Till heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle [i. e., one letter or point of a letter] shall in no wise pass away from the law, till all things be accomplished.’ Matt. 5: 17–20, R. V. The law, therefore, stands just exactly as it did when spoken amid the thunders of Sinai, and still reads, ‘The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.’ Brother Nash admitted that the apostles still continued to keep the seventh-day Sabbath after Christ’s resurrection. The prophet Isaiah declares that the Sabbath will continue to be kept after the new heavens and the new earth are instituted, and that ‘all flesh’ shall come to worship God upon it. Isa. 66: 22, 23.

“These, dear reader, are a few of the ‘unsustained’ and ‘false assumptions’ which I have been presenting in the tent at Bartow. I leave with these Christian gentlemen the responsibility of settling with God such characterizations of the plain Bible arguments I have presented in the tent at Bartow.

“Let the reader notice that Mr. Nash alone is responsible for drawing the conclusions that observers of Sunday are ‘fools and knaves.’ I have never intimated such a thought. I know full well that multitudes of Sunday-observers are just as honest in holding their views as I am in mine. But that doesn’t prove that their arguments for so believing are ‘convincing,’ any more than those which multitudes of them hold in favor of sprinkling for baptism are so. The vast majority of the ‘Christian scholarship of the world’ so hold; yet Mr. Nash does not agree with it. He doubtless would not admit for a moment that any argument they present for sprinkling babes or men was anything but ‘weak and futile.’ His quoting the opinions of great majorities as an argument, amounts to nothing. The vast majority of the world are heathens to-day, and have been for thousands of years. Every true reform has commenced with the few who were called cranks and fools, and were derided as bad as the poor Adventists. So it was with Christ himself who was branded to death by popular professors of religion. In Paul’s time true Christians were considered the ‘filth and offscouring of all things.’ Luther and his fellow-reformers were taunted with these kinds of arguments with which Mr. Nash deals, by Dr. Eck, who accused Luther of pretending ‘to know more than the sovereign pontiff, the councils, the doctors, and the universities.’ Wesley was mobbed, hated, and despised as much as we are, and the great Baptist Church was then derided as bad as the poor Adventists now. A very poor argument for any doctrine is popular opinion. The great Protestant rock is the Bible, and the Bible alone, and Seventh-day Adventists propose to cling to it and relegate all the ‘Christian Fathers’ to the Sunday-keepers with which to splice out their Bibles.

“As for Mr. Tatum, I have no quarrel with him about the length of time he listened at the tent, whether inside or outside. I am not aware that I ever saw him there at all. I was told by a truthful man that he saw him there once, and that he stayed about ten minutes and left, and I never heard of his being there more than that, but did hear from others that he had not beenp. 346 there before. However, I shall not dispute his statements. He greatly exaggerates the length of time I used in replying to Mr. Nash. But I did reply to every argument of any importance he presented. And some of the most estimable and respectable citizens of Bartow or vicinity declared that I fully answered every one of them from plain Bible testimony.

“GEO. I. BUTLER.”