BY ELDER EUGENE LELAND.
(Millington, Mich.)
It is becoming quite popular with a certain class to treat all passages of Scripture which mention “the law,” as referring to only one law, ignoring entirely the distinction usually made between moral and ceremonial laws. This position is taken in order to avoid the claims of the fourth commandment of the decalogue, which requires the observance of the seventh day as the Sabbath. The argument runs about like this: The New Testament speaks of “the law” being abolished. Both moral and ceremonial laws are included in the expression “the law.” Therefore the moral law is abolished, and with it the seventh-day Sabbath.
We admit that in a few instances “the law,” as the term is used in the New Testament, includes both moral and ceremonial laws; and this for the simple reason that both laws were given to Israel at the same time, and that both were written together in the same book, which was called the “book of the law.” But in the great majority of instances where “the law” is mentioned in the New Testament, the term applies to the ten commandments alone, thus showing that the Scriptures do indeed recognize two distinct laws, whether men are willing to make the distinction or not.
We wish to notice a few passages of Scripture in which “the law” is applied to the ten commandments alone. In the third chapter of Romans the expression occurs nine times, and in every instance except one it refers to the ten commandments alone; and in the one exception the term refers to “the law of faith,” something entirely distinct from either the moral or the ceremonial law. Every other occurrence of the term in this chapter has reference either to the moral law alone or to the ten commandments in connection with the ceremonial law. But this last cannot be the case, for “the law” here mentioned is established by faith, and it is absurd to say that the ceremonial law or any part of it is established by faith. Therefore “the law” of Romans 3 is the ten commandments alone.
It will not do to claim that “the law” of verse 31 has reference to some other law than the one referred to in the other verses of this chapter; for it would be manifestly absurd to think that the apostle would make frequent reference to “the law” in an argument, draw his conclusion from the argument, and then in a caution against drawing some other conclusion, say that he has reference to some other law. No; verse 31 is simply a caution against drawing some other conclusion from his argument than the one which he has drawn himself. The conclusion which he has drawn from his argument is that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law. Verse 28. Then, fearing that some will draw from this statement, as many have done, that the deeds of the law are not to be done at all, because a man is not justified by them, he throws out the caution of verse 31: “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law.” What law is it that is established by faith?—Why, “the law” of verse 28, by which one is not justified. This is so evident that no candid person will deny it.
Now if the law of verse 31 does not refer to the ten commandments, but does have reference to some higher law, it follows that “the law” of verse 28 and of the other verses of this chapter has reference also to the higher law and not to the ten commandments at all, nor to the ceremonial law. Why, then, are these verses quoted to prove the abolition of the ten commandments? Either “the law” of this chapter refers to the ten commandments, or it does not. If it does refer to them, they are established by faith. If it does not refer to them but to some higher law, please do not quote this chapter to prove the abolition of a law which is not mentioned in it.
It will not do to argue that “the law” here mentioned has reference to some higher law,—a law of love, for instance; for in Romans 13 the apostle quotes several of the ten commandments, and closes his argument with the conclusion, “Therefore love is the fulfilling of the law,” showing plainly that the ten-commandment law is the law of love, and that it is the highest law of the universe.
Another instance where the ten commandments alone are alluded to as “the law,” is found in Rom. 5:20. We quote the text in full: “Moreover the law entered, that the offense might abound. But where sin abounded, grace did much more abound.” The entrance of “the law” here mentioned has undoubted reference to the giving of the law on Mount Sinai; that “the law” of this passage does not include the ceremonial law, will appear as we proceed.
“The law” which “entered that the offense might abound,” could have been no other law than the one which was transgressed by that offense. An offense could not be made to abound by the entrance of any other law. What was “the offense” which was made to abound by the entrance of “the law”?—It was Adam’s transgression. This will appear without comment by reading Rom. 5:12-20. Now if it can be shown that Adam’s “offense” was a transgression of the ceremonial law, it will appear at once how the entrance of the ceremonial law would make offense abound, and that the expression “the law” includes both moral and ceremonial laws. But this never can be shown, because the requirements of the ceremonial law were not enacted until after Adam’s transgression had occurred. Had Adam never sinned, such a thing as circumcision and sacrificial offerings would never have been required. Circumcision was not required until the days of Abraham, two thousand years after Adam’s offense had been committed. But the language of the text is: “The law entered.” It does not say that the law was enacted,—the law was made,—that the offense might abound. “The law entered.” It was in existence all the while; but by constant transgression its requirements had been lost sight of, and in consequence the enormity of sin did not appear. In order that it might appear,—“abound,”—“the law entered.”
Now it is a fact that every one of the principles of the ten commandments was in existence at the time when Adam’s “offense” was committed; and it can be clearly shown that his “offense” was a direct violation of several of them. And therefore the entrance of the ten commandments would indeed cause Adam’s “offense” to “abound.” But this could not be done by the entrance of the ceremonial law, because Adam’s “offense” was in no sense a violation of that law.
But again: If Adam’s “offense” was made to “abound” by the entrance of the ceremonial law, he stood condemned by a law which was enacted after his offense was committed; and, therefore, those who claim that “the law” here mentioned includes the ceremonial law, are guilty of charging God with enacting an ex post-facto law. But even the Constitution of the United States forbids the making of such laws as that. When one tries to avoid the claims of God’s law upon him, his blindness will lead him to charge God with deeds that a human being would not be guilty of performing.
But the absurdity of this position can be shown in another way. The ceremonial law, requiring sacrifices and offerings, was a law of faith. “By faith Abel offered unto God a more excellent sacrifice than Cain,” etc. Heb. 11:4. This is the first account we have of sacrificial offerings, and here it is said to have been performed by faith. It was an act of faith.
Of circumcision we read: “And he received the sign of circumcision, a seal of the righteousness of the faith which he had yet being uncircumcised.” Rom. 4:11. Here it is plain to be seen that circumcision was an act of faith; and therefore the law requiring circumcision and sacrificial offerings was a law of faith. But we read in Gal. 3:12, “The law is not of faith; but, The man that doeth them shall live in them.”
From these considerations it is plain that the Scriptures recognize two distinct laws, one of which is a ceremonial law, performed by the individual to show his faith in the fact that the requirements of the moral law would be fulfilled in him by an indwelling Saviour.