AdventAI

THE TRIAL OF WILLIAM PENN.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 21., May 21, 1895

(Concluded.)

Last week we had reached the point, in Penn’s trial before the Recorder and the Lord Mayor of the city of London, where the Recorder attempted to dodge the request of Penn to give him a definition of common law, Penn assuming that if a law was so hard to be understood as the Recorder maintained, it could not be a very “common” law; and asserting that common law was common rights according to Coke. The conversation then goes on:—

Recorder.—“Sir, you are a very troublesome fellow, and it is not for the honor of the court to allow you to go on. My lord [addressing the Lord Mayor], if you do not take some course with this persistent fellow, to stop his mouth, we shall not be able to do anything to-night.”

Lord Mayor.—“Take him away! Take him away! Put him into the bale-dock.” And in the midst of a vigorous appeal to the jury, he was forcibly removed to the extreme end of the court, where he could neither see nor be seen.

The Recorder then proceeded: “You, gentlemen of the jury, have heard what the indictment is. It is for preaching to the people, and drawing a tumultuous company after them, and Mr. Penn was speaking. If they will not be undisturbed, you see, they will go on. There are three or four witnesses who have proved this, that Mr. Penn did preach there, that Mr. Mead did allow of it. After this we have heard by substantial witnesses what is said against them. Now we are on matter of fact, which you are to keep and observe, as what hath been fully sworn at your peril.”

Here, Penn, from the bale-dock, interrupted in his loudest tones, “I appeal to the jury, who are my judges, and to this great assembly, whether the proceedings of the court are not most arbitrary and void of all law, in offering to give the jury their charge in the absence of the prisoners. I say it is directly opposed and destructive to the right of every English prisoner, as declared by Coke, in the 2nd Institute 29, in the chapter on Magna Charta.”

Rec. (with an affectation of humor).—“Why, you are present. You do hear, do you not?”

Penn.—“No thanks to the court that commanded me into the bale-dock. And you of the jury, take notice that I have not been heard, neither can you legally depart the court before I have been fully heard, having at least ten or twelve material points to offer in order to invalidate the indictment.”

Rec. (furiously).—“Pull that fellow down, pull him down; take him to the hole; to hear him talk doth not become the honor of the court.” The prisoners were then “haled away” to the hole in Newgate, the most squalid of all the squalid dens in England.

Then commenced the troubles of the jury; for the Recorder ordered them to agree in the verdict, according to their version as to the facts sworn. They immediately retired for consultation, but instead of returning at once with a verdict against Penn, as the judge intended and desired, thirty minutes, sixty minutes, an hour and a half, expired, before they reported. Then eight of the jurors entered and reported that they could not agree. The Recorder demanded the other four to come in, and immediately poured out upon them a flood of vituperation and abuse.

The jury withdrew the second time, and after two hours returned with a verdict, “Guilty of speaking in Grace Church street.” An attempt was made to induce them to change the verdict to make it read, “unlawful speaking,” but they manfully refused. “We have given our verdict,” they said, “we can give no other.” They were sent back a third time, whereupon they sent in a verdict, “Guilty of speaking to an assembly in Grace Church street.”

In a storm of passion the Lord Mayor pronounced their foreman an ignorant, canting knave, and the Recorder exclaimed: “You shall not be dismissed till you bring in a verdict which the court will accept. You shall be locked up without meat, drink, fire, or tobacco. You shall not think thus to abuse the court. We will have a verdict, by the help of God, or you shall starve for it.”

Penn.—“The jury, who are my judges, ought not to be thus menaced. Their verdict should be free, not forced.”

Rec.—“Stop that fellow’s mouth, or put him out of the court.”

Lord Mayor (addressing the jury).—“You have heard that he preached, that he gathered a company of tumultuous people, and they not only disobeyed the martial power, but the civil also.”

Penn.—“That is a mistake, we did not make the tumult, but they that interrupted us. The jury cannot be so ignorant as to think that we met there to disturb the peace, because it is well known that we are a peaceable people, never offering violence to any man, and were kept by force of arms out of our own house.” “You are Englishmen,” he said to the jury, “mind your privileges. Give not away your rights.”

The jury was then locked up, and the prisoners carried back to Newgate. The next morning (Sunday) the court-room was again crowded, and with anxiety checkered by hope, the public awaited the reappearance of the jurors. At seven o’clock their names were called over, and the clerk once more inquired if they had agreed upon a verdict. They replied that they had. “Guilty, or not guilty?” said the clerk. “Guilty of speaking in Grace Church street.”

Lord Mayor.—“To an unlawful assembly.”

Bushnell.—“No, my lord. We give no other verdict than we gave last night.”

Lord Mayor.—“You are a factious fellow; I will take a course with you.”

Bushnell.—“I have done according to my conscience.”

Lord Mayor.—“That conscience of yours would cut my throat.”

Bushnell.—“No, my lord, it never shall.”

Lord Mayor.—“Then I’ll cut yours as soon as I can.”

Rec. (jestingly).—“He has inspired the jury. He has the spirit of divination. Methinks he begins to affect me. I will have a positive verdict, or else you shall starve.”

Penn.—“I desire to ask the Recorder a question: Do you allow the verdict given of William Mead?”

Rec.—“It cannot be a verdict, because you are indicted for conspiracy; and one being found not guilty and not the other, is no verdict.”

Penn.—“If ‘not guilty’ be no verdict, then you make of the jury and of the great Magna Charta, a mere nose of wax.”

Mead.—“How? Is ‘not guilty’ not a verdict?”

Rec.—“It is no verdict.”

Penn.—“I affirm that the consent of the jury is a verdict in law, and if William Mead be not guilty, it follows that I am clear, since you indict us for conspiracy, and I could not possibly conspire alone.”

The unfortunate jurors were again compelled to retire, but they persisted in the verdict already rendered. The Recorder gave vent to still greater wrath, and declared, “Your verdict is nothing. You play upon the court. I say you shall go and bring in another verdict, or you shall starve, and I shall have you carted about the city, as in Edward the Third’s time.”

Foreman.—“We have given in our verdict, in which we are all agreed. If we give in another, it will be by force, to save our lives.”

Lord Mayor.—“Take them up to their room.”

Officers.—“My lord, they will not go.”

Violence was then resorted to, and the jury were compelled to withdraw, and were locked up without food or water. Some weaker ones, under this harsh treatment, were disposed to waver, and would have given way, but for the courageous resolution of Bushnell and others like him, who understood the importance of the question at issue. So when on Monday morning the court once more summoned the jurors, there was not, though they had fasted two days and nights, a traitor or a coward among them. Hunger and fatigue, and a not unnatural anxiety, had rendered them wan and worn; but they were determined to do justice to their fellow-men, arraigned, as they well knew, on a false charge.

Clerk.—“Gentlemen, are you agreed upon a verdict?”

Jury.—“Yes.”

Clerk.—“Who shall speak for you?”

Jury.—“Our foreman.”

Clerk.—“Look upon the prisoners. What say you? Is William Penn guilty of the matter whereof he stands indicted in manner and form, or not guilty?”

Foreman.—“You have our verdict in writing.”

Clerk.—“I’ll read it.”

Rec.—“No, it is no verdict; the court will not accept it.”

Foreman.—“If you will not accept it, I desire to have it back again.”

The Court.—“The paper was no verdict, and no advantage shall be taken of you for it.”

Clerk.—“How say you? Is William Penn guilty or not guilty?”

Foreman (resolutely).—“Not guilty!”

Rec.—“I am sorry, gentlemen, you have followed your own judgment and opinions, rather than the good advice which was given you. God keep my life out of your hands. But for this, the court fines you forty marks a man, and imprisonment in Newgate till the fines are paid.”

Penn.—“Being freed by the jury I demand to be set at liberty.”

Lord Mayor.—“No, you are in for your fines.”

Penn.—“Fines! what fines?”

Lord Mayor.—“For contempt of court.”

Penn.—“I ask if it be in accordance with the fundamental laws of England that any Englishman should be fined except by the judgment of his peers; since it especially contradicts the 14th and 29th chapters of the Great Charter of England, which says, ‘No freeman ought to be amerced except by the oath of good and lawful men of the vincinage.’”

Rec.—“Take him away; put him out of the court.”p. 330

Penn.—“I can never urge the fundamental laws of England but you cry out, ‘Take him away! Take him away! put him out of the court!’ No wonder, since the Spanish Inquisition sits so near the Recorder’s heart. God, who is just, will judge you all for these things.”

As the prisoners and jurors refused to pay the fine so arbitrarily imposed upon them, they were removed to Newgate. The jurors, at Penn’s instigation, immediately brought suit against the Lord Mayor and Recorder for having imprisoned them in defiance of law and justice. It was argued the 9th of November, before the twelve judges, who universally decided in favor of the appellants. They were immediately released, and Penn went forth triumphant, having struck an effectual blow in vindication of individual liberty.

The reader will find it easy to draw some parallels between the events of this trial and some things which are cropping out in our own day.

U. S.