In the Question Chair

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 14, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 20.

Read the full edition

In the Question Chair.

[DESIGNED for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

506.—RESURRECTION OF MOSES.

How does the Bible reconcile the fact that Moses, who had died, appeared on the Mount of Transfiguration, and this before Christ had been raised from the dead; and yet Christ be called the first-fruits of them that slept? R. U. H.
Answer.—People were raised in point of time before Christ was raised. But with reference to them we notice that one class was not raised to immortal life, and, with reference to the other, that of Moses, we learn that his resurrection was not a public one; either of which facts makes a sufficient distinction between their resurrection and that of Christ. The great point that determines the relation of Christ's resurrection to that of all the others, is the fact that his resurrection was the vital event on which all the others depended. Had Christ's resurrection not been determined upon, and been a present fact in the mind of God, then no others would ever have been raised. He was, therefore, the first, in the sense that his was the pivotal resurrection upon which all the others depended. In the same sense he is said to be the “first-born from the dead,” the “first begotten of the dead,” the “first-born of every creature,” etc.; and this, it may be added, is one of the definitions of the word translated “first” in these passages.

507.—OUR RELATION TO CHRIST.

In Luke 9: 49, 50 we read: “Master, we saw one casting out devils in thy name; and we forbade him, because he followeth not with us. And Jesus said unto him, Forbid him not; for he that is not against us is for us.” This scripture is often used by different denominations to prove that they are all right and acceptable to the Lord. Please give us a few comments upon the subject. R. W.
Ans.—This scripture has no reference whatever to denominational differences, nor was it designed to uphold the division of Christians into sects. God does not accept people as churches, but as individuals. To follow Christ is to do his will in all things, and whoever does that, walking up to all the light he has, is a follower of Christ wherever he may be. There are many such in all denominations. But such are always ready to receive light, and are always reaching out to know more of God's will and ways and word; and they readily accept any new truth that is brought to them. The passage teaches a lesson of tolerance. We are not to repudiate and denounce a man because he does not see everything in the same light that we do. He may not have had all the light and opportunities that we have had; but his heart may be in a better condition than ours. It is not the amount of light that a person has, but the way in which he uses it, that decides his standing before the Lord. But let no one use this scripture to bolster himself up in error when the light is set before him, as if the Lord would approve such a course.

508.—EXPLANATION WANTED.

In question 500 of the Question Chair it is explained how those who die under the third message come up out of great tribulation, because they are raised in time to pass through the seventh plague, and so, for a time, are right in the midst of the tribulation caused by the accumulated plagues, as embodied in the seventh plague. Yet in “Thoughts on Daniel and the Revelation” it is explained that these are exceptions to the general rule. A. C. E.
Ans.—We are glad some are looking so closely into these matters that they immediately discover any apparent discrepancy. The seeming difference in the two statements is owing to the different points of view from which the subject is examined. According to Revelation 7, those who die under the third message must be raised before Christ comes. The only point at which their resurrection can consistently be placed is at the voice of God, at the beginning of the seventh plague. They, therefore, pass, in the quiet of the grave, the time while six of the plagues are being poured out. Viewed, therefore, from the standpoint of the first six plagues, they do not pass through what the other members of the 144,000 experience, and with regard to them, so far, they are exceptions to the general rule. But their relation to the seventh plague is different; for, being raised at the beginning of that plague, they live through that, like the rest of the 144,000, and the time when this company come out of great tribulation, is when they come out of the last plague, having passed through all the others; that is, they are not out of that period of tribulation until the last plague is past. But the raised ones come out of that, too, and at the same time. So that from this point of view they are not exceptions to the others, but themselves also come out of great tribulation, though they have not passed through all that had preceded it. Further thought upon the subject suggests these two ways of regarding the question. We are coming to think that the latter view is the preferable one.

509.—THE COMMANDMENT TO RESTORE AND BUILD JERUSALEM.

Please give proof that the date of the going forth of the commandment to restore and build Jerusalem, B. C. 457, as held by our people, is correct. The dates as given in the margin of our Bibles are not always reliable. R. T. N.
Ans.—This date does not rest on the chronology as given in the margin of the Bible, which is not always wrong, but sometimes correct, as in this instance. Such writers of history and chronology as Doctors Hale and Prideaux, quote the “Canon of Ptolemy,” that the seventh of Artaxerxes, in which the decree went forth (Ezra 7), was B. C. 457. (See this subject discussed at length in the work published at this Office, called, “The Sanctuary and its Cleansing.” Price $1.)

510.—THE THIEVES ON THE CROSS.

In the record of the crucifixion of Christ, two of the evangelists say that both the thieves which were crucified with Christ reviled him; while by another it is stated that one reproved the other, and asked Christ to remember him when he should come into his kingdom. How can both be correct? R. U. H.
Ans.—The statements can both be true by allowing them to have been made at different times while Christ was upon the cross. For instance, at the beginning of that scene, both thieves might have been of the same spirit, and both have reiterated the reproaches of the Pharisees and reviled him; while afterward one might have been turned to the Saviour, and been led by faith to seek an interest in him and his future glory. No passages of Scripture can be taken as contradictions, unless the circumstances are such that the fulfillment of one utterly precludes by conflicting circumstances the fulfillment of the other. If any supposition, either of time or place, can be brought in, which would harmonize all the statements, it is lawful to base conclusions on such suppositions, and thus avoid any conflict which would otherwise exist. U. S.