We have come to a time in our country, when, to a certain class at least of its citizens, the record of past persecutions of Christians for conscience’ sake is a pertinent and important study. A case of this kind was that of William Penn, the founder of Pennsylvania, for engaging in preaching the gospel, in his day, in England. In the record of this case it will be found that enmity, spite, bigotry, and intolerance, were the same back there as they are manifesting themselves to-day. In the Chicago Law Times we find an account of his trial for preaching the gospel. The facts of this account we rewrite and condense to the following statements:—
Penn was born on Green Tower Hill in the city of London on Oct. 14, 1644. His father, Admiral Penn, married a Dutch lady whom he met on one of his voyages to the low countries, and whom he ever after called “the Dutch wife.” England was at the time rent with civil strife, Parliament against king, and king against Parliament. Contending factions marching through the country spread terror among the inhabitants of the land. The battle of Marston Moor had been fought, Charles I. had been virtually dethroned, and London was but a huge encampment. William Penn was then a child, and, under these circumstances, it was thought best that the Dutch wife and her son should retire into the country. They went to Wanstead, near Chigwell, a place celebrated for its historical associations, and the visits and movements of queens and the nobility, and renowned for its stately palaces, magnificent churches, and influential schools.
In such a region Penn spent the first eleven years of his life. His first knowledge of the rudiments of learning, and his initiation into the classics, marked this period. He soon became acquainted with the great questions which divided the people. He learned of the cruelties and oppressions of the established church, and imbibed those principles of independence which he took with him to Oxford. These principles soon got him into difficulty there, which led him to leave the university and at length to become a Quaker. His exasperated father turned him out-of-doors, but became reconciled to him when he himself became involved in difficulty, and found it impossible to turn William from his chosen way. He afterward studied law, opened his heart to the Holy Spirit and the influence of Magna Charta, and became strongly confirmed in the principles of righteousness and liberty which he had accepted.
At the instigation of the bishop of London he was accused of heresy and thrown into the Tower, where he remained several months. Here he wrote his celebrated treatise, “No Cross, no Crown,” and tasted the real sweets of martyrdom. A servant came to him one day and told him that the bishop of London had declared that he should either recant or die in prison. “Thou mayest tell my father,” replied Penn, “that my prison shall be my grave before I budge a jot; for I owe obedience of my conscience to no mortal man.”
Toleration and liberty of conscience were entirely unknown in England at that time. Quakers were subjected to the whipping-post, the stocks, peltings by infuriated mobs, and the imposition of heavy fines. Different statutes were brought to bear upon them, and where no specific law could be found, it was easy to require the oath of allegiance, which it was well known they would not take, and the refusal of which subjected them to six months’ imprisonment. Hoodlums and religious brutes marched in bodies with drum and fiddle to the places of their worship to break them up. Women had their hoods torn off, and the children were whipped. More than fifteen hundred were thrown into prison, and three hundred and fifty died in jail within a little over ten years after 1660. Altogether, according to Penn’s calculation, more than five thousand died for the sake of religion.
Penn early formed the project of acquiring an interest in the New World, where he and his people might live in peace, and worship God as they saw fit. This, his youthful dream, he lived to see in a measure realized when he was permitted to tread the soil of the New World, and lay the foundation of a great commonwealth, which links his name forever with that which is good and great. Few Americans know what an impetus he gave to religious freedom in his struggles through the reigns of Charles II. and James II., which dragged like a long night of tyranny and oppression over England. And few also fully realize what he did for the protection of human rights by his open defiance of unjust judges and cruel persecutors who strove to destroy him and his friends under the form of law. He led all men by his boldness and daring, and defied all his oppressors. He broke down caste, and opened to light of day the iniquity which characterized trials by courts that were organized solely to convict.
Among the instances of such a life, the narration of which would require a volume, his trial for preaching the gospel is deemed of the greatest importance. It was in the year 1670 that the infamous Conventicle Act was renewed, which prevented all dissenters from worshiping as they thought proper. Penn and his followers had received much opposition up to this time; but he was not aware till he repaired to the Friends’ meeting-house, in Grace Church street, to hold a meeting, that armed force was to be used to prevent their assembling for their quiet worship.513
He found on this occasion his meeting-house closed and guarded by soldiers. He then made up his mind to preach to the crowd in the street. A friend of his, William Meade, a London linen draper, was with him. Soon after the discourse had begun, a warrant from the Lord Mayor of London was produced for the arrest of both Penn and Meade, who were immediately dragged off to Newgate. Then was enacted what forms a curious chapter in the history of English jurisprudence. The prisoners were arraigned at the Old Bailey, not for a breach of the Conventicle Act, as is sometimes supposed, but, as the indictment ran, “for preaching to an unlawful, seditious, and riotous assembly.” At the preliminary examination Penn and Meade both appeared with their hats on. These were promptly knocked off their heads, but the officers were told to put them on again. The questions and answers which followed are thus recorded:—
Recorder.—“Do you know where you are?”
Penn.—“Yes.”
Rec.—“Do you know it is the King’s Court?”
Penn.—“I know it to be a court, and I suppose it to be the King’s Court.”
Rec.—“Do you know there is respect due to the court?”
Penn.—“Yes.”
Rec.—“Why do you not pay it, then?”
Penn.—“I do so.”
Rec.—“Why do you not put off your hats, then?”
Penn.—“I do not believe that to be any respect.”
Rec.—“Well, the court sets forty marks upon your heads as a fine for your contempt of the court.”
Penn.—“I desire it may be observed that we came into court with our hats off (that is, taken off), and if they have been put on since, it was by order from the Bench, and therefore not I, but the Bench should be fined.”
A formal indictment was of course found against Penn and Meade, and on Sept. 1, 1670, they were put on trial again at the Old Bailey before the Recorder and the Lord Mayor of London. It was one of the most remarkable trials on record. Penn planted himself squarely upon the constitution, and declared that the Conventicle Act was contrary to all the principles of Magna Charta, and was therefore void. He went back to the Saxon period, and claimed that four fundamental rights descended to free Englishmen from that time. These were: First, Security of property; secondly, Security of person; thirdly, A voice in the making of all the laws relating to property and person; and, fourthly, A share, by means of the jury, in the actual administration of the civil law. These fundamental rights, which had been attacked in the person of Penn, were vindicated by his courageous action. The court seized every opportunity to confuse and browbeat him, yet he defended himself with great spirit and ability. Penn calmly requested the Recorder to inform him by what law he was prosecuted, and on what law the indictment was founded. The Recorder in a rage replied as follows: “You must not think that I am able to sum up so many years, and ever so many adjudged cases, which we call common law, to satisfy your curiosity.”
Penn.—“This answer, I am sure, is very short of my question; for, if it be common, it should not be so very hard to produce.”
Rec. (angrily)—“Sir, will you plead your indictment?”
Penn.—“Shall I plead to an indictment that has no foundation in law? If it contains that law you say I have broken, how should you decline to produce it, since it will be impossible for the jury to determine, or agree how to bring in, their verdict, who have not the law produced by which they should measure the truth of the indictment?”
Rec. (in great passion)—“You are a saucy fellow; speak to the indictment.”
Penn.—“I say it is my place to speak to matters of law; I am arraigned a prisoner; my liberty, which is next to my life itself, is now concerned. You are many against me, and it is hard if I must not make the best of my case. I say again, Unless you show me and the people the law which you ground your indictment upon, I shall take it for granted your proceedings are merely arbitrary.”
Rec.—“Waiving this critical point, the question is whether you are guilty of this indictment or not.”
Penn.—“The question is not whether I am guilty of this indictment or not, but whether this indictment itself is legal. It is too general and imperfect an answer to say this is common law unless we know both where and what it is; ‘for where no law is, there is no transgression,’ and a law which is not in being, so far from being common law, is no law at all.”
Rec.—“You are an impudent fellow. Will you teach the court what law is? It is lex non scripta. That which men have studied thirty or forty years to know, would you have me tell you in a moment?”
Penn.—“Certainly, if the common law be so hard to be understood, it is far from being very common; but if the Lord Coke in his Institutes be of any weight, he tells us that ‘common law is common right,’ and common right is the great charter privileges confirmed by various enactments.”