AdventAI

THE LAYING ON OF HANDS.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 18., April 30, 1895

(Republished by request.)

A CORRESPONDENT earnestly requests us to pen a few lines on this subject, in view of the fact that the Mormons, or Latter-day Saints, are pressing their views in various places, and causing a measure of confusion in the minds of some, on this question. He sends us three tracts in which the views of this people on this point are set forth, that we may the better understand their arguments. According to these documents, they hold that three steps are necessary to a person’s initiation into the church: First, Baptism; secondly, The laying on of the hands of the elders upon his head; and, thirdly, The gift of the Holy Ghost received by that means; that the laying on of hands is consequently a church ordinance, and those who do not practice it are not obeying the teachings of Christ.

From this view we are compelled to dissent entirely. We believe that Seventh-day Adventists and many others are practicing in this respect all that the teaching of the New Testament warrants us to do. That we have correctly stated their position, a paragraph from a tract entitled, “Laying on of Hands,” page 1, will prove. Whoever reads the Mormon argument on this point will be pretty sure to learn that Samaria received the word of God through the preaching of Philip the evangelist, and that Peter and John were sent down from Jerusalem to look after the matter. The account is found in Acts 8: 14–17. It states how they came down and prayed that they might receive the Holy Ghost, and how they laid their hands on them, and they received the Holy Ghost. After quoting this account, a paragraph immediately follows, which we now present:—

“Comment upon these texts could not make them plainer; for the first and most palpable thought that impresses the mind while reading them, is that the apostles laid their hands upon those who had been baptized that they might receive the Holy Ghost; and they did, through obedience to this ordinance, receive the Spirit; not before baptism, but after; not without the laying on of hands, but with. Will any one take the responsibility of saying that those who were baptized would have received the Holy Ghost otherwise than by the laying on of hands; or that they received it before baptism? Was not the laying on of hands a means, and the receiving of the Holy Spirit the result?”

In the three tracts we have received, this account stands in the forefront of the argument on this question, and is made to bear a large share of its weight. Their next quotation is invariably Acts 19: 1–6, which records how Paul found certain disciples at Ephesus who had been baptized unto John’s baptism, and preached unto them Jesus. And, “when they heard this,” says the record, “they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. And when Paul had laid his hands upon them, the Holy Ghost came on them; and they spake with tongues, and prophesied.” The query at once arises why the interesting account of Acts 10 is so studiously passed by in silence; and the only reason appears to be that the facts there recorded inevitably lead to a different conclusion from the one our Mormon friends wish to establish. That chapter gives a statement of the experience of Cornelius, his sending for Peter, and Peter’s journey down to Cæsarea, and his preaching to Cornelius and his kinsmen and friends whom he had called together on the occasion. Peter’s discourse is recorded in verses 34–43. The record then continues:—

“While Peter yet spake these words, the Holy Ghost fell on all them which heard the word. And they of the circumcision which believed were astonished, as many as came with Peter, because that on the Gentiles also was poured out the gift of the Holy Ghost. For they heard them speak with tongues, and magnify God. Then answered Peter, Can any man forbid water, that these should not be baptized which have received the Holy Ghost as well as we? And he commanded them to be baptized in the name of the Lord. Then prayed they him to tarry certain days.”

Now here is the record that a company of Gentiles by accepting the truth received the gift of the Holy Ghost, and that, too, before they were baptized, and of course without having hands laid upon them. And so far as the record goes, hands were never laid upon them. And yet that was recognized by the disciples as the work of God.

Only one of the writers whose tracts we have under notice (Elder Isaac Sheen) makes any reference to this circumstance at all, and he endeavors to skip over it with the following brief allusion:—

“To convince the believing Jews that the Gentiles might be saved, the Lord poured out the Holy Ghost upon Cornelius and his friends before they were baptized, but the strong prejudices of the Jews against the Gentiles made it necessary. Their case was an exception for an extraordinary purpose.”

But this case is not to be so easily disposed of. If there was any commandment, or instruction, or uniform practice to the contrary, there would be more excuse for trying so to construe it. But as it is, there is no excuse whatever; for Peter has more to say concerning it in chapter 11. Some of the Jews took exception to Peter’s course in going to preach to the Gentiles, and he therefore rehearses to them his experience substantially as recorded in chapter 10. When he comes to his discourse before Cornelius and his friends, he says (chapter 11: 15, 16): “And as I began to speak, the Holy Ghost fell on them, as on us at the beginning. [That is, on the day of Pentecost.] Then remembered I the word of the Lord, how that he said, John indeed baptized you with water; but ye shall be baptized with the Holy Ghost.” This was a prophecy made to them by Christ just before he was taken from them to heaven. Acts 1: 5. Peter repeated it on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2: 38, 39), and declared that the promise was to them and their children, and to all that were afar off, even as many as the Lord should call. And when the Holy Ghost came upon Cornelius and his friends, Peter recognized it at once as a fulfillment of the prophecy. In the light of this fact, then, what was the intent of the prophecy? It was simply this; that the Holy Ghost should be given to believers, as well before baptism as after, as well without the laying on of hands as with; for in either case it would be equally a fulfillment of the prophecy, the order of the events and the laying on of hands being merely matters of circumstance or indifference.

To say that this “was an exception for an extraordinary purpose,” is to speak without due consideration of the subject; for it involves a grave absurdity. Mr. Sheen says that the prejudice of the Jews against the Gentiles was suchp. 282 that this was “necessary;” that is, that these Gentiles should receive the Holy Ghost before baptism. But hold! Peter’s prejudice had already been broken down by his vision of the sheet let down from heaven (Acts 10: 9–16); he had been told by the Spirit (verses 19, 20) to go down to Cæsarea with the messengers of Cornelius, nothing doubting; he had heard their statement (verses 30–33), and had become fully convinced that they were accepted of God; for he said (verses 34, 35), “Of a truth I perceive that God is no respecter of persons; but in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted with him.”

Such was the state of Peter’s mind, and his feelings toward them when he commenced his discourse to them. How utterly groundless the thought that he needed anything more to break down his prejudice! But if some further evidence was needed by Peter, could not the Holy Spirit, under whose immediate guidance and instruction Peter then was—could not that Spirit have instructed him to baptize them, and lay hands on them, that they, too, might receive the Holy Spirit?—Most assuredly; and this would have been the course so naturally to be expected, that anything different would wear the complexion of a blunder. Which would have been the more easy and natural—for the Holy Spirit to give such a chosen instrument as the apostle Peter a little further instruction, and have everything come in in order? or to fall upon that whole company before they were baptized, and were ready for it, and set them to speaking with tongues and magnifying God prematurely? And let any one explain, if he can, on the ground of Mr. Sheen, the course of the Holy Spirit on that occasion, which, instead of further instructing Peter, fell upon that company in a manner to break down an order which he claims the Lord had established, and the apostles were carrying out in the church.

Such reasoning will never answer. Every circumstance of this case shows that no such order as, first, the laying on of hands; and then, secondly, the reception of the Holy Ghost, had been established in the church.

To come to other texts, we find sixteen instances in which the laying on of hands is spoken of in the New Testament. And we find that this act was performed in connection with three different classes of transactions: First, In setting apart men to some special work in connection with the church and the gospel ministry; secondly, For the recovery of the sick; and thirdly, For the imparting of special gifts of the Holy Spirit by those who were themselves already endowed with such gifts. But these are all simply historical or prophetical statements, narrating what certain ones did on certain occasions, or what they would do; but none of them containing any command, precept, recommendation, or instruction for others to follow, nor laying any obligation directly upon any one in respect to them. Nor do we find, except in the first particular, even uniformity of action. All of which would go plainly to show that, with the exception of setting apart persons to the ministry, or service of the church, there is no precise rule to be invariably followed. Let us look at the subject more particularly under these three heads:—

1. Setting men apart for the service of the church, or the ministry. In Acts 6 we have the account of what is called the appointment of the seven deacons. The men were chosen and set before the apostles; and the apostles prayed and laid their hands on them. This was not to impart to them the Holy Ghost, for they were already “full of the Holy Ghost and wisdom” (verse 3), but simply to set them apart to their office. In Acts 13: 2, 3 we read this concerning Barnabas and Saul: “As they ministered to the Lord, and fasted, the Holy Ghost said, Separate me Barnabas and Saul for the work whereunto I have called them. And when they had fasted and prayed, and laid their hands on them, they sent them away.” This laying on of hands was not to impart the Holy Ghost; for Paul (verse 9) was converted ten years before this, and it would be preposterous to suppose he had not received the Holy Spirit before this. This act was simply to set them apart to their special work. But Seventh-day Adventists and other denominations follow the examples of the New Testament in this matter.

2. Healing the sick. Christ laid his hands on many sick persons, and they recovered. (See Mark 6: 5; Luke 4: 40; 13: 13.) But his practice was not uniform in this respect. He sometimes healed without laying on of hands. He spoke to the son of the widow of Nain (Luke 7: 11), and raised him from the dead; but no laying on of hands. The woman who touched the hem of his garment was healed; but no laying on of hands. So of the centurion’s servant (Luke 7: 2–10), and the demoniac of Gadara. Luke 8: 26–35; and many others. Neither did the apostles always lay hands on the sick to heal them. (See the case of Peter and Eneas, and Peter and Dorcas. Acts 9: 34, 40, 41.) And in James (5: 14), where more particular instruction is given in reference to the sick, nothing is said about the laying on of hands, but only of prayer and anointing with oil.

But, it will be asked, did not Christ say positively, “They shall lay hands on the sick, and they shall recover”? and is not this a command?—No; not a command, but a promise and a prophecy. We read in the same verse (Mark 16: 18), “They shall take up serpents.” We do not take that as a command, and consider ourselves under obligation to go around hunting up serpents, in order to take them up, or to keep a stock on hand for the purpose. The passage is simply a prophecy that these signs should follow believers, and when circumstances were such as to require it, they should be fulfilled. If they should chance to come in contact with a deadly serpent, as Paul did at Melita (Acts 28: 1–6), it should not harm them. In some cases they would be moved to lay hands on the sick for their recovery, as Paul did on the father of Publius (Acts 28: 8), but sometimes would perform the miracle without the laying on of hands, as Paul healed the impotent man at Lystra (Acts 14: 8–10), and as the shadow of Peter healed the sick in Jerusalem (Acts 5: 15), and handkerchiefs and aprons from Paul dispelled diseases and cast out evil spirits. Acts 19: 11, 12.

Thus we see that no uniform rule can be drawn from the practice of either Christ or his apostles in this respect. Therefore Seventh-day Adventists adopt no such rule. But they do frequently lay hands on the sick, according to the New Testament examples, and anoint with oil, after the instruction of James; and the cases of recovery through these means are frequent and marked. But it cannot be expected that recovery will be certain in every case; for it was not so even in the days of Paul himself; inasmuch as he left Trophimus, on one occasion, at Miletum sick (2 Tim. 4: 20), and inasmuch as the special message now going forth pronounces a special blessing upon those who die in the Lord during the time of its proclamation. Rev. 14: 13.

3. To impart the especial gift of the Holy Spirit. The case of the Samaritans, of which so much is made (Acts 8: 14–20), is a case in point; for there was one Simon, who, when he “saw that through laying on of the apostles’ hands the Holy Ghost was given,” he offered them money, saying, Give me also this power, that on whomsoever I lay hands, he may receive the Holy Ghost. But Peter said unto him, Thy money perish with thee, because thou hast thought that the gift of God may be purchased with money.” Here it is called “the gift of God;” and how this gift operated is told in other scriptures. The company at Cæsarea (Acts 10: 46) on receiving this gift, spoke with tongues; the disciples at Ephesus who received the gift by the laying on of Paul’s hands (Acts 19: 1–6), began immediately to speak with tongues and to prophesy. But are such gifts of the Spirit common to all the church?—By no means; for we are expressly told, in 1 Corinthians 12, that there are diversities of gifts by the same Spirit, among which are enumerated the gift of tongues and the gift of prophecy, these not being possessed by all indiscriminately, but divided “to every man severally,” as the Spirit wills. Verse 11. The gift possessed by Timothy was beyond question a special gift. 1 Tim. 4: 14: “Neglect not the gift that is in thee, which was given thee by prophecy, with the laying on of the hands of the presbytery.” Of what is here called the presbytery, or “body of elders,” Paul was doubtless a member; for he says to Timothy again (2 Tim. 1: 6): “Wherefore I put thee in remembrance, that thou stir up the gift of God, which is in thee by the putting on of my hands.” This was accompanied with the gift of prophecy, which is one of the special gifts. In connection with the words quoted, Paul exhorts Timothy to give attendance to reading, exhortation, and doctrine, and not to be ashamed of the testimony of our Lord. His gift was therefore, doubtless, a special gift to the ministry, as mentioned by Paul in Rom. 12: 6, 7: “Having then gifts differing according to the grace that is given to us, whether prophecy, let us prophesy according to the proportion of faith; or ministry, let us wait on our ministering.”

But in the bestowment of these special gifts, the circumstances are not uniform. Sometimes it is accompanied with the laying on of hands, sometimes not. On the day of Pentecost, when the disciples were baptized with the Holy Ghost, according to the promise of Christ, there was no laying on of hands; and afterward, when the place was shaken by the impulse of the Holy Ghost coming upon them, there was no laying on of hands (Acts 4: 31); and at Cæsarea, the Holy Ghost was given without the laying on of hands. Acts 10: 44, 46. It would look to us like a fearful thing to become so inflated with spiritual pride as boldly to invade the realm of the special gifts of the Holy Spirit, and claim to be endowed with gifts which we do not possess. To do so would be to make a solemn mockery of sacred things. While we are to covet earnestly the best gifts, and be ready to acknowledge and appreciate them wherever they appear, God forbid that we should act with the presumption above stated.p. 285

There is one more text to be noticed; namely, Heb. 6: 2: “Of the doctrine of baptisms, and of laying on of hands.” But this paper has already reached such a length that it will be impracticable to say much here concerning it. Nor will this be necessary, so far as the object of this article is concerned. The text speaks of “the doctrine . . . of laying on of hands,” but does not tell us what that doctrine is. Our friends say that the doctrine referred to is that every one who comes into the church must have hands laid upon him, and through that imposition of hands receive the Holy Ghost. But we have seen that there is no such doctrine in the New Testament, hence nothing of that kind can be referred to; while, as we have found, there is enough else to which it can refer. And that is all we need to say here in explanation of the text. We have no evidence that hands were ever laid upon the three thousand converted on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2: 41), nor upon the five thousand members of the church mentioned in Acts 4: 4. U. S.