Elder J. W. Kelchner sends to the Iowa Workers’ Bulletin the following letter from some ministers in the place where he was laboring, together with his reply. We would call particular attention to the latter as being worthy of imitation under similar circumstances:—
“Sheldon, Ia., 10 a. m., April 4, 1895.
“Mr. J. W. Kelchner,
“S. D. Adventist Minister,
“Sheldon, Ia.
“SIR: You are hereby challenged to discuss publicly in Sheldon the following propositions: 1. The law of which the weekly Sabbath was a part is abolished; 2. The seventh day of the week should be observed as a Sabbath by Christians; 3. The first day of the week is the Lord’s day, and should be observed as such by Christians; 4. Mrs. E. G. White is a true prophetess of God, and her so-called ‘testimonies’ and revelations are, in fact, revelations from God.p. 286 “The first and third of the foregoing propositions to be affirmed by John M. Van Kirk on behalf of the Church of Christ, and denied by J. W. Kelchner on behalf of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. The second and fourth propositions to be affirmed by J. W. Kelchner and denied by John M. Van Kirk. Said debate to begin within forty-eight hours from date hereof, and to be conducted according to such rules and regulations as may mutually be agreed upon. An immediate reply in writing to this communication, is asked for, as we desire to know before noon to-day, if possible, as to whether you accept or reject the proposal for debate. If you are favorable to debate, we shall be pleased to meet you at once at some designated place, to complete the necessary arrangements as to time, place, etc.”
“W. F. McCORMICK, Pastor,
“JOHN M. VAN KIRK.”
“Sheldon, Ia., 2 p. m., April 4, 1895.
“Messrs. McCormick and Van Kirk,
“Ministers of the Christian Church,
“Sheldon, Ia.
“DEAR FRIENDS: Your communication of this date received and duly noted. I am engaged in delivering a course of Bible lectures, which I do not care to interrupt at this juncture. My purpose in coming to Sheldon was to preach the gospel, and not to enter into public controversy. You are at perfect liberty to discuss these questions as you deem proper and right. I reserve the right to do the same. I do not believe that any good could come to the cause of Christ through a discussion such as you propose. I am perfectly willing, as you ought to be, after we have presented these various questions to the people in our respective places of meeting, to leave the decision as to which is right or wrong to the judgment of the people. I will preach upon the topics referred to in your communication, to my audience in a few days, and will be pleased to give you due notice of the time when I shall do so.”
“Very respectfully yours,
“J. W. KELCHNER.”