BY L. H. HANSEN.
(Indianapolis, Ind.)
In the law of Indiana is a statute which declares it to “be unlawful for any person or persons to engage in playing any game of base-ball where any fee is charged . . . on the first day of the week commonly called Sunday.” An agreement has been entered into recently by the managers of the Indianapolis Base-ball Association and the officers of the street railway company, whereby there is to be Sunday base-ball playing. This called forth quite a bit of discussion on the question. The newspapers have had editorials and columns of matter from the public on the subject, some in favor of it and some against it. Some reasons for Sunday base-ball are, that it will give the working classes a chance to see the game; that it is healthful exercise; and that visitors would have a place of amusement to attend while in the city. Objections are that it will demoralize the community; it will be a violation of the law; it will be a desecration of the Sabbath, and it will draw from the attendance at church. One able article of considerable length was printed, giving the origin and a brief history of Sunday laws and a comparison of the reasons for the observance of the first and seventh days as Sabbath.
Last Sunday, March 31, the ministers of the city preached on the subject, by request of the Good Citizens’ League, an organization formed for the purpose of purifying politics. We give some brief extracts from the sermons of the leading ministers. Some of the sermons were printed in full, while only the main points of others were noticed. It is to be observed that almost every one makes reference to the law. It is quite probable that this law was enacted through the influence brought to bear by these very ministers or others who are seeking to have laws framed to which they can appeal.
J. A. Milburn, Presbyterian minister, indorsed base-ball as a game, and thought that a half holiday on Saturday should be given to it. He said further: “I think it is a delightful game, and I believe that every citizen in Indianapolis would be improved if he would indulge himself occasionally in this game; but there is a statute in this State which prohibits ball playing for pay or any kind of reward upon the Sabbath day. And now if we are going to keep the saloons closed after eleven o’clock at night, and if we are going to put thieves in prison because they disobey the laws, then I say we should not discriminate against wrong-doers, and, therefore, must make the managers of our base-ball association stand square up to the letter of the law.”
R. Roberts, Methodist, said that he would rather see all the stores open, and every factory running on Sunday, than to see them closed, and know that those who worked there were “contributing to the success of Sunday base-ball; contributing toward the quickening in the community of a spirit of resistance against the divine law which has said, ‘Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy;’ contributing to the encouragement of the violation of the statutory law which says that Sunday base-ball players shall not desecrate God’s own day of rest. It is no day or time to experiment with this evil. Sunday base-ball playing will necessarily breed in the minds of all who attend the games a contempt for the holy Sabbath day; it will cut down the attendance on church services and the exercises in the Sunday-schools. . . . Why should there be tolerated in this city an evil which is an open violation of the established law of the State and the written law of God? Let every one who believes that it will be to the detriment of the community to permit the playing of Sunday base-ball, from this time on use his or her most vigorous effort to prevent this evil thing.”
Another Methodist pastor, Dr. Sargent, said: “We are asking that men should be compelled to observe the Sabbath laws of our State, not in order to convert them to our theological views, but to preserve public morals and the welfare of the State. . . . If the time for a conflict has come, if the insolence of anti-Sabbath conspirators is forcing the crisis upon us, then let all good citizens who love our good city and State, stand up and defend our wholesome laws. We are not asking men to adopt our religious views, we are asking them to protect society.”
At the First Presbyterian church, Pastor M. L. Haines said: “I want to express my sympathy with the movement inaugurated in our city to prevent, if possible, the threatened violation of State law by the playing of professional base-ball on Sunday.” He believed that those who had gone into the agreement for Sunday base-ball had not considered the matter well, how that their example in violating the law would breed in the minds of many the disregard of all law.
Another minister said: “That is a step backward, and leads to Sunday theaters and shows of every sort. Our laws are not over strict in respect to Sunday peace and quiet. . . . If this project for Sunday games is pushed into our faces, let all good citizens join in asserting the value and dignity of the laws as we have them.”
Another M. E. pastor, Dr. Henry Buchtel, said: “Laws for a civil Sunday are necessary to the safety and good order of society. Sunday mails, Sunday newspapers, and Sunday trains—except in so far as such trains are fairly under the head of works of necessity and mercy—are all a menace to our civil institutions. How much more are Sunday saloons and Sunday theaters and all laborious Sunday sports a menace to the very life of the Republic! . . . When the 2087th section of the Revised Statutes of 1894 specifically names base-ball as absolutely prohibited on the first day of the week, commonly called Sunday, who are these gentlemen that are free to set that statute aside at their pleasure? . . . But even if the proposition were not so high in favor of a decent Sunday, yet the law must stand. No man can call himself a true friend of the government who would defy the law.”
It can easily be seen how the plea that disregard for law will undermine society will affect the cases of others who will not obey the laws ‘for conscience’ sake, and who are, in fact, already being accused of these very things.
Among the ministers of the city was one, however, who gave some very good reasons for not discussing the subject from his pulpit, as he had been requested. This was a Presbyterian minister, G. L. Mackintosh. He said that he believed that the churches should take no part in politics. He believed that it would be better for the churches to keep clear of all political questions, as history shows when the church has become involved in political questions, it has been to her detriment. He said that there are several different conditions of people in Indianapolis, representing different opinions. Some believed Saturday was the Sabbath, and some believed that Sunday as a day of rest does not make it necessary for everybody to attend church. Many of this country’s population come here from other countries, and they have been taught to believe that this is a land of freedom. He did not think it was the church’s place to make persons holding opposite views conform with those of the churches.