THE ignominious record made by the last Congress is not relieved at all by the fact that its principal and almost only production, the income-tax law, has been virtually set aside by the United States Supreme Court, and is sure to be abrogated by the next Congress. It is perhaps well enough to let that Congress and its unsavory record lie where they are buried, deep under the reproaches of a justly indignant people.
In reference to the law, however, much may be said pro and con. The public exchequer is in such straits that it would almost seem to justify some desperate means for redeeming the nation's credit at home and abroad, and replenishing its coffers. It is urged that the burden of taxation falls with disproportionate weight upon the poorer classes. Import duties raise the prices of commodities which the poor as well as the rich must purchase. An income-tax levies only on what the rich receive over and above that which those in merely comfortable circumstances receive. It takes the burden from the poor and places it upon those able to bear it.
On the other hand, it is held that after a man has paid taxes upon income-producing property, he has a right to the income free from any claim of the government. Upon this ground the Court decided that the tax on real estate rentals were unconstitutional. Upon the same grounds others might also claim exemption. It is evidently illegal for the government to issue and sell its own obligations, and then turn around and levy a tax upon the interest it pays to the bondholders. Altogether the act is of a questionable legal status. It will not long survive to perpetuate the memory of the fifty-third Congress.
T.