AdventAI

“MAN DIETH.”

By W. C. Gage

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 15., April 9, 1895

BY ELDER W. C. GAGE.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

So says the Scripture; but modern theology says, No; the man does not die; only the body dies, but the man lives forever. Which is correct? If we accept even the theological definition of man, and then closely watch the phenomena connected with death, we discover irreconcilable difficulties. Thus the man is described as that which feels, thinks, reasons, etc. Physiology recognizes the fact that all these operations are dependent on the material organism; that the quality and integrity of the brain structure governs the vigor and activity of the intellectual process; that the suspension of the brain function suspends the “soul action,” and its impairment weakens it in a relative degree.

From these indisputable facts, and incidental phenomena connected with them, the believer in the Scriptural doctrine of man’s natural mortality draws a strong confirmatory argument. Believing that life in man is wholly dependent on his physical organization,—that mechanism described by the psalmist as “fearfully and wonderfully made,”—he sees in the dissolution of the body the cessation of that life, and the exact fulfillment of the Scripture declaration, “Man dieth.”

To those who witness the frequent repetition of this scene, the argument appeals most forcibly; and it is therefore a matter of little wonder that the physician, whose presence at the death-bed so often compels him to observe the psychological aspects of the situation, so frequently becomes a skeptic as to the popular belief in the doctrine of the soul.

These thoughts are suggested by the perusal of an article in the Chautauquan for March, entitled, “The World’s Debt to Medicine.” The author, John S. Billings, M. D., after summing up the many valuable and important discoveries which medical science has given to the world, apparently goes out of his way to make the following statement, although it might indeed be classed among the debts we owe to medicine if its legitimate deductions were only accepted as a safeguard against the delusion of man’s inherent immortality. He says:—

“The physician does not so separate the consideration of the psychical part of man from that of his physical organization, as is commonly done by the theologian or the jurist. The more he studies his subject, the more he is convinced that with every mental or spiritual manifestation there is some co-ordinate change in bodily structure; that body and mind exert a powerful influence upon each other; that disorder of the one may produce disorder of the other; and that both must be taken into consideration in dealing with ignorance, folly,p. 228 vice, and crime. This view has gradually become prevalent among educated men, the modern jurisprudence of insanity is based upon it; and it is beginning to be accepted by criminologists and social reformers.”

If it be indeed true that “with every mental or spiritual manifestation there is some co-ordinate change in bodily structure,”—and it is certainly true,—the further statement that mind and body must “both be taken into consideration in dealing with ignorance, folly, vice, and crime,” may simply be broadened to its legitimate scope, and thus embrace all the relations of each to the other, both in life and its cessation. At the occurrence of the latter event, science, therefore, as well as the Bible, teaches that “man dieth.”

But further than this, science cannot go. On the verge of the grave it stands helpless, and with no power to answer the question, “If a man die, shall he live again?” Revelation alone gives the solution of this problem. Such help as science can give is only by analogy; and that points in the same direction as the Scriptural answer. Thus the coming of the Lifegiver is made the source of immortality, and future life an object to be sought in and through him alone.