WHAT THEY WANT

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 9, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 15.

Read the full edition

WHAT THEY WANT.

In a sermon lately preached by Dr. Talmage in the Academy of Music, New York City, upon the subject of divorce, the doctor made the following statement:—
“What we want is that the Congress of the United States change the national Constitution so that a law can be passed which will be uniform all over the country, and what shall be right in one State shall be right in other States, and what is wrong in one State shall be wrong in other States.”
We have nothing to say in favor of the easy way that divorces are obtained in this country; it is undoubtedly a shame and a blot upon our civilization. Still this is hardly a sufficient reason why an amendment to the United States Constitution should be made, especially empowering the United States Congress to make the laws regulating marriage and divorce for the entire nation.
If such a scheme should be carried out, there is no certainty that divorces would be much more difficult to obtain than they are now. The same influences would be brought to bear upon Congress that have affected the State and Territorial legislatures, and so, whether the States or the United States, shall make the divorce laws, divorces will continue to be obtained with comparative ease.
But aside from the particular point in discussion, there is danger in the plan proposed by Dr. Talmage. It involves the question, What legislative body is to make the laws for the several States,—the legislatures of the States? or the Congress of the United States? The laws defining and punishing murder and many other crimes, vary as much in the several States as do the laws in regard to divorce. So if absolute uniformity in regard to one law is necessary, why not in regard to all? Thus, should this plan be adopted, the Constitution would receive a great number of amendments, covering every phase of legislation upon which it might be thought that uniformity of law should prevail. Or by one general amendment Congress might be empowered to make all the laws for the different States of the Union in the interests of uniformity, and the legislatures of the States and even the States themselves be dispensed with! This would be the logical result of a universal divorce law, which could have but one effect; to depreciate the authority of the States, taking away their rights to make their own laws by increasing the authority and power of the general government,—two things which every lover of his country and its institutions would consider to be a calamity.
The fact is, this desire to ignore the States and call upon Congress for everything, bodes no good to the country. The Constitution has set the bounds of congressional authority, and Congress has been given all the power that can safely be given to it. The acquisition of too much power leads to tyranny. A division of power by a comparison of measures gives better freedom and prevents extremes in legislation.
The question of Sunday observance has been for several years discussed in precisely the same way that divorce is now being treated. The laws of the States in regard to Sunday are not uniform; some have no Sunday law; others have exemption clauses, which will not allow observers of the Sabbath to be prosecuted for Sunday work; and in the States where there is a Sunday law, and no exemptions, there is a great diversity in the punishments prescribed. Hence, the ardent Sunday devotee longs for an amendment to the Constitution so that Congress may pass a Sunday law of universal application, with a uniformity of punishment. Thus in many ways are efforts constantly being made to minimize the powers of the States and to increase the authority of the general government, even to the destruction of religious liberty and the tearing down of the most precious liberties of the States and of the people.
M. E. KELLOGG.