Is it Any Day? or is it a Particular Day? Which? Some Questions for the Thoughtful and Candid.
BY ELDER J. W. RAYMOND.
(Wheeler, N. Y.)
1. While God’s word and the only weekly Sabbath commandment of Heaven says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath,” we hear again and again that “the commandment simply demands one day of the seven,” and that “it makes no difference which day we keep as the Sabbath, only that we keep some day.” If this is so, is not the man who keeps Saturday as verily keeping the Sabbath as he who keeps Sunday? If not, why not?
2. If this is so, how can a first-day observer claim that he is keeping the Sabbath any more than can he who keeps Saturday?
3. If the fourth commandment does not require the observance of a particular day but simply of one day in seven, what about a civil law that compels an observer of the seventh day to keep the definite first day in obedience to a commandment that does not require the observance of any particular day?
4. If the fourth commandment only requires a seventh day, and not the seventh day, and God himself is not particular, why did he say “the seventh day”? and why is it necessary to make such an effort to prove that we ought to keep a particular day—Sunday?
5. How can it be that God is not particular as to what day we keep, and yet very particular that we keep Sunday?
6. Is Sunday the only seventh part of time there is?
7. Would it be true of a row of seven apples that any one is an apple, unless every one was?
8. Can it be true, then, that the Sabbath is simply any day of the seven, unless every day is the Sabbath?
9. If every day is not the Sabbath, and one keeps one of the days that is not the Sabbath, does he keep the Sabbath? Can the Sabbath be kept on a day that is not the Sabbath? If so, how?
10. If we do not keep the day that is the Sabbath, are we not Sabbath-breakers?
11. Did Christ, the Creator (see Eph. 3:9; Heb. 1:1, 2; John 1:10), rest from the work of creation before he created, or was it the day after? Gen. 2:1, 2.
12. If, then, he rested from creation on the day after its completion, did he rest on the first day, or on the seventh?
13. Did he, after the work of creation was completed, “bless and sanctify” the seventh day of the week? or was it simply a seventh part of time, without any reference to a particular day of the seven? (See Gen. 2:2, 3; Ex. 20:8–11; Luke 23:56 and 24:1.
14. Could the Creator rest on, then bless and sanctify, any day of the seven, without resting on a particular day? If so, how?
15. Could a person kill any member of a family of seven, and not kill a particular person?
16. Which is the seventh day of seven, the first or the last?
17. Does not Luke 23:56 and 24:1 locate the Sabbath of the commandment on the day before the first day of the week?
18. Is not, then, the seventh day of the week the Sabbath day of the commandment?
19. Which day of the week do you keep, the first or the seventh?
20. Who made the Sabbath, God or man?
21. Did man have any part in making it? If not, then does human action have anything to do in locating and determining the day of the Sabbath?
22. If everybody should keep Tuesday, would that make Tuesday the Sabbath of the Bible? If not, how could the Sabbath be kept by keeping Tuesday?
23. Even if everybody were to keep the first day of the week, how would that make that day the seventh day of the commandment, when God locates the Sabbath day of the commandment on the day before the first day? (See Luke 23:56; 24:1.) Is the day after the Sabbath the Sabbath day?
24. Did not the Creator sanctify the very day on which he rested from his work of creation? Gen. 2:2, 3.
25. Why did he “bless and sanctify” the seventh day? Was it not because he rested on that day? (See Ex. 20:8–11.) Will this reason apply to any other day of the seven? Did he not work on every other?
26. Is not, then, a particular day of the seven the Sabbath? and is it not the last day of the seven?p. 211
27. Are we not commanded of God to refrain from labor on that very day which the Creator once “blessed and sanctified”? And does not God’s commandment say, “In it thou shalt not do any work”? Do we keep this command, then, when we work on that day and make it the busiest day of all the seven?
28. Is it not actual disobedience to do our work on the seventh day, when God says, “In it thou shalt not do any work”? and can we make amends for this disobedience by ceasing from work on some other day? To illustrate: Would the child who was told to do a certain thing on a certain day stand approved if he were to set that day aside and then do that thing on some other day of his own choosing?
29. But if it be claimed that we cannot keep the true and definite seventh day because time has been lost, and so it is impossible to know which is the true seventh day, how could such a one claim we ought to keep the first day by keeping Sunday?
30. How could the seventh day be lost and the first day not lost? or, how could one know which is the true first day without knowing which is the true seventh day too?
31. But as the special reason for Sunday-keeping is in reference to Christ’s resurrection on that day, if this is a valid position, does it prove that Sunday is the true first day of the week?
32. But can one honestly put forth such a claim and practice, and then claim that the seventh day is lost, and cannot be kept? If so, how?
33. If the seventh day is lost, what has become of the first?
34. If it was as convenient and popular to keep the seventh day as it is the first, would there be any difficulty in finding it? Let the heart be examined.
35. Do the Scriptures ever apply the name “Sabbath” to the first day of the week? If so, where? Please look for it.
36. Has God ever said of the first day of the week, “In it thou shalt not do any work”? Has Christ ever said so? Have the apostles? Can any one give the reference?
37. And as there is no transgression where there is no law (Rom. 4:15; 1 John 3:4), what sin is committed by working on the first day of the week? and where does obedience come in in keeping that day?
38. Could one possibly keep a seventh part of time by keeping any day of the week, without uniformly keeping the same day? And would not that be a definite day? Is Saturday a more definite day than Sunday?
39. If one were keeping a day simply as a seventh part of time, could he change to another day, and still be continuing right on keeping a seventh part of time? Think, and then tell how.
40. How, then, could there ever have been a change from the seventh day of the week to the first, without a violation of the seventh-part-of-time theory? Yes, how?
41. And if the fourth commandment does not require the observance of the seventh day of the week, but simply a seventh part of time, then did not the people of God violate that law if they changed to first-day observance at the resurrection of Christ, as some tell us? Stop and think.
42. If it is a seventh part of time that the commandment requires to be kept, why any change from the seventh day to the first? Is not one day as verily a seventh part of time as another?
43. But if you keep the first day of the week in commemoration of the resurrection of Christ, are you not keeping a definite day? And could you keep some other day and still be keeping the day of his resurrection? And now where is the seventh-part-of-time theory?
44. Did not the followers of our Lord keep the Sabbath day of the commandment by resting on the day before the first day of the week? (See Luke 23:56; 24:1.)
45. Do we not, then, break the Sabbath of that commandment when we work on that day?
46. Is it not wrong to follow and uphold a course that makes the commandments of God of none effect? (See Mark 7:1–13.)
47. Are you ready for the judgment? Carefully examine James 2:8–12.