APOSTOLICAL SUCCESSION

33%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 2, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 14.

Read the full edition

APOSTOLICAL SUCCESSION.

THE Cork (Ireland) Constitution of Oct. 27, 1894, contained a bit of correspondence, setting forth in its true light that figment of the imagination known as “Apostolical Succession,” that is, that every minister, to be qualified to exercise his office, must have received his consecration in a direct line from the apostles themselves. The folly of such a claim is set forth below; for whoever will try to trace it, will find some breaks which can by no possibility be bridged over, and find the so-called line sometimes running through the foulest slums that ever offended the nostrils of decency. A writer signing himself “Common Sense,” addresses himself as follows “to the editor of the Cork Constitution:”—
“SIR: The controversy on the above subject will not do much to convince the majority of intelligent Protestants that it is worth your while to open your columns to it at all. As well open them to one on the question of the moon being made of green cheese. Lord Macaulay’s review of Gladstone on Church and State, fifty-five years ago, settled the matter for that majority in both islands. ‘The foundations of the theory,’ said Macaulay, ‘which ought to be buttresses of adamant, are made out of the flimsy materials which are fit only for perorations.’ Again he says, ‘We are at a loss to conceive how any clergyman can feel confident that his orders have come down correctly. Whether he be really a rightly-ordained successor of the apostles or not depends on an immense number of contingencies like these; viz., whether under King Ethelwolf, a stupid priest might not, while baptizing scores of Danish prisoners who had just made their escape between the font and the gallows, omit, inadvertently, to perform the rite on one of those graceless proselytes; whether in the seventh century an impostor who had never received consecration, might not have passed himself off as a bishop upon a rude tribe of Scots; whether a lad of twelve did really, by a ceremony huddled over when he was too drunk to know what he was about, convey the Episcopal character to a boy of ten. . . . We read in history of sees of the highest dignity openly sold, transferred backward and forward by popular tumult, bestowed sometimes by a profligate woman on her paramour, by a warlike baron on a stripling, his kinsman. We read of bishops of ten years old, of bishops of five years old, of many popes who were mere boys, and who rivalled the frantic dissoluteness of a Caligula. In our own island it was the complaint of Alfred that not a single priest south of the Thames could read either Latin or English.’—Macaulay’s Essays, Vol. II., p. 72.