AdventAI

THE TENNESSEE TRIALS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 13., March 26, 1895

As promised last week, we quote further from the Dayton (Tenn.) Republican concerning the imprisonment of our brethren in Rhea county jail, as there mentioned. Judge Parks in pronouncing sentence upon the accused, made some very significant remarks from which we quote:—

“While our sympathies are with the defendants, and while they perhaps have good grounds for their faith, yet this is a temporal, not a spiritual court, and we cannot pass upon questions of belief. The only questions we have to deal with are, ‘What is the law?’ and, ‘Has the law been violated?’”

A large portion of his remarks seem to be an attempt to excuse himself for the sentence he was obliged to render. After stating that as an officer of the law, he could do no less than to enforce the law while it stands on the statute-book, he says:—

“If I were to express my private feelings, however, I might say that there is nothing I regard with more concern or solicitude than an encroachment of legislative enactment upon the personal rights of the individual in matters of conscience. That there is a limit in these matters beyond which legislation cannot rightfully go will be conceded by every man. Where is that limit?”

He refers to the doubts which many, even Sunday-keepers, entertain as to the constitutionality of these laws, and how others attempt to harmonize them with the fact that every man is guaranteed the right to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience; and that is because Sunday observance has had the support of so large a proportion of Christians of all classes, that these laws never have been considered as prescribing any particular belief. On this point he says:—

“Sunday is and for a long time has been recognized by nearly all Christian denominations as the Sabbath, and it is for this reason, no doubt, that the laws which protect that day have always been acquiesced in as constitutional. They have never been regarded as laws which prescribe any particular belief, but as laws which protect the unanimous belief of nearly all Christian denominations. But here we have a respectable element of Christian believers who are honest, inoffensive, law-abiding citizens in all matters not conflicting with their sense of duty, who believe they are under divine command to observe the seventh day as the Sabbath. As a matter of abstract individual right, can they be required to observe another day also?”

Concerning the position maintained by our brethren, he makes the following interesting remarks:—

“Their position is not that of the person who claims that as a matter of personal liberty, he has the right, if he chooses, to run an open saloon on Sunday, or to do any like act. That is not a matter of conscience, this is. They claim that it is not only their right, but their duty under divine command, to observe the seventh day. Calling them ‘cranks’ does not settle the question. If there were only one of them, he would be entitled, not only to his belief, but to the exercise of that belief, so long as in so doing he does not interfere with any natural right of his neighbor. A man cannot kill another, and excuse himself by claiming that he believed he was carrying out God’s will in so doing, because this would deprive his victim of a natural right; viz., the enjoyment of life. Do the defendants, in keeping the seventh day, and working on the first, thereby interfere with any natural right of their neighbors? Or is it an artificial right, created by statute? Has any power but the divine will the right to establish any one day as sabbath? If the day has been set by divine edict, but two or more persons honestly differ as to what day was appointed, can the dispute be settled by legislative enactment? These are grave questions upon which no opinion is now ventured.”

He asks some questions which are very easily answered; and although he ventures no opinion, it can hardly be doubted what his personal opinion is.