Religious Intolerance in Tennessee.—An Adventist Academy Closed.
In 1892 Elder G. W. Colcord, a Seventh-day Adventist minister and teacher, established an academy at Graysville, Rhea Co., Tenn., in which he invested all the means at his command, amounting to about $5000. Several of his brethren likewise put money into the enterprise, not as a speculative investment, but in order to build up an educational institution to fit young persons of both sexes for lives of usefulness. The school prospered, and soon a flourishing colony of Adventists grew up around it. When the institution was closed, March 1, 1895, it had an enrollment of over one hundred pupils. The occasion of the closing of the school was the arrest of Elder G. W. Colcord, the principal, Prof. I. C. Colcord, one of the teachers, and M. C. Sturdevant, manager of the boys’ dormitory. These, together with Wm. Burchard, Henry Burchard, Dwight Plumb, W. J. Kerr, E. S. Abbott, Wm. Wolf, N. B. England, E. M. Plumb, A. F. Harrison, and B. L. Dieffenbacher, were indicted last November by the grand jury of Rhea county for violation of the Sunday law. These men are all members of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. The ten first named were the only ones arrested, as the others happened to be away on business when the arrests were made.
Mr. England’s case was continued. The nine others arrested stood trial, and were all convicted. Elder Colcord and M. C. Sturdevant on four indictments each; Wm. Burchard and E. S. Abbott on two indictments each; the others on one each. They were tried March 5 and 6, and were committed to prison, March 8, for terms ranging from twenty to eighty days, with the exception of Wm. Wolf, whose costs were secured by his father, Dr. S. Wolf. Wm. Wolf himself, together with the other defendants, refused to pay the costs, as to do so would only be to confess the justice of the conviction and to invite further prosecution. The principal defense in each case was the God-given right to work six days; and not only so, but the defendants insisted that the fourth commandment requires not only the observance of the seventh day, “the Sabbath of the Lord,” but that other days of the week be habitually devoted to worldly pursuits. The fourth commandment, they maintain, establishes a difference between the seventh day and the other days of the week, and that habitually to treat another day as the Sabbath, is to set up a counterfeit of the Lord’s Sabbath. The defendants pleaded that not only was it a religious duty to work on Sunday, but that under Article I., of the Bill of Rights of Tennessee, they had a constitutional right to work on that day. The article in question provides “that no human authority can, in any case whatever, control or interfere with the rights of conscience; and that no preference shall ever be given by law to any religious establishment or mode of worship.” Not one of them denied doing secular work on Sunday, but all denied that this work was a nuisance, as charged in the indictments.
The following defense by Wm. Burchard will serve as a sample of the defenses in each case, though no two were exactly alike:—
“I am indicted for violating the Sabbath. I plead not guilty. I have been keeping the seventh day for about four and one-half years. I learned that the Bible says that the seventh day of the week is the Sabbath. I obey the laws of the land when they do not conflict with the law of God, but when they do, I obey God. The Bible says, ‘Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates; for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.’ The State says the first day of the week is the Sabbath, but I choose to believe and to obey the God of heaven. I read in Acts 5:29 that when forbidden of the rulers to preach the gospel, ‘Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men;’ and again in Acts 4:19: ‘Peter and John answered and said unto them, Whether it be right in the sight of God to hearken unto you more than unto God, judge ye. For we cannot but speak the things which we have seen and heard.’ This is a case against me for my belief. I read in Rom. 10:17: ‘Faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.’ I believe the Bible, and my faith is that the seventh day is the Sabbath; so it is a case about my belief in the Bible.”
“I was born and raised in Rhea county, Tenn., and have never been before a court before. Moreover, the supreme court of the State has decided that a single act of Sunday work does not constitute a nuisance, and they have proved only one offense against me.”
Judge Parks, in charging the jury in this case, said:—
“Gentlemen of the jury, the defendant, Wm. Burchard, is charged in the indictment with carrying on the common avocations of life on Sunday, the same not being an act of real necessity or charity. To this charge he pleads ‘not guilty,’ and you are sworn to try the issue. It is a violation of the law of the State unnecessarily to perform labor on Sunday in such a way as to disturb the worship of others, or in such a way as to affect the morals of the community. The carrying on of ordinary business or any kind of secular labor on Sunday, if so conducted as to attract public attention, is indictable under the laws of the State. It is not necessary to show that any person was disturbed by such act; it is sufficient if the act was done in such a public manner as to be open to the observation of the public.p. 205
“A single act of work on Sunday is not a nuisance in the eyes of the law, unless that act be done in some peculiarly flagrant manner. One act is indictable, if it is done in this manner, if it will tend to corrupt the public morals. The question for you to determine is, whether the work performed by the defendant in this instance is of such a nature or character as to have come under this head.
“You are the exclusive judges of the evidence and credibility of the witnesses. . . . Take the case and render such verdict as you think is warranted by the law and under your oaths.”
In two or three of the cases in which but one act was proved, the juries hesitated somewhat, and one of them returned for further instruction. In this case his honor said:—
“One offense is not necessarily of itself a nuisance in the eyes of the law, but if it were done in an open and public way, that is, where the public might see it, and if it were of such a nature and character as to be a flagrant violation of the Sabbath, it would be an offense under the law. In that case a verdict of guilty should be given. I also charged you that the defendant, if he did an act of secular work on Sunday, or if he had it done on Sunday, should be found guilty. Now it is for you to decide from the evidence before you, whether or not the defendant, if he did an act of secular work on Sunday, or if he had it done, whether or not it was done in an open and public way, and whether, if it were done, it amounted to a flagrant violation of the Sabbath as established by law.”
Of course, under this instruction, the jury could scarcely do otherwise than convict, which was done in every case, notwithstanding the constitutional guaranty of liberty, and the divine warrant which they showed in court for keeping the seventh day and working upon the other six days.
The defendants employed no counsel, but at the conclusion of the trials, three attorneys, one of them the ex-attorney-general of the district, asked their permission to make a motion in arrest of judgment. This was done, and ably argued by counsel. It was, however, overruled by the judge, who imposed a fine of $2.50 in each case, together with costs, amounting altogether to about $20 in each case. His honor promptly remitted the fine, and expressed a regret that he could not likewise remit the costs, but said that that was beyond his power, and that if the costs were not paid, the defendants would be committed to jail, which was accordingly done.
Besides the cases against the Adventists, there was one other indictment for Sunday labor; but when the case was called, the prosecuting witness refused to prosecute, and the indictment was quashed. The defendant in this case was not an Adventist, and the finding of the indictment was probably a mistake. Hundreds of the employees of the Dayton Coal and Iron Company work in the town of Dayton and in Rhea county every Sunday, and are not prosecuted.
Peculiar interest attaches to the cases of the Seventh-day Adventists, because this persecution directly affects Graysville Academy, which is closed indefinitely because of the imprisonment of the principal and the teacher second in charge. It works a special hardship upon some of the students who were almost ready to graduate, and who are now compelled to return to their homes at considerable expense, without finishing their course at school. Most of the students are scattered to various States, and others are awaiting the receipt of money from home, to enable them to leave.
Several of the imprisoned men have families of small children, and all but one are married men. One has five children and another seven, all too young to earn their living, yet the fathers are taken away and imprisoned for no other crime than that of doing honest labor for the support of their families.
This Adventist community is composed of quiet, law-abiding people, many of whom, so far from injuring any one, were laboring for the good of their fellow-men and for the salvation of souls. None of the work done was of a nature to disturb the peace or quiet of the neighborhood. It seems that the enemies of the Adventists are determined to persecute them, for additional indictments have been found by the grand jury, and it is probable that some who are now suffering imprisonment will again have to appear before the court at the next term, and that others who had not previously been indicted will also be arrested and required to answer for their God-given and constitutional right to the free exercise of their religious faith.
No blame attaches in these cases to the officers of the law. Judge James G. Parks and Attorney-General Fletcher unreservedly express themselves as regretting that they are compelled to be parties to what is evidently religious persecution. In pronouncing judgment upon the convicted Adventists, Judge Parks, as reported in the Dayton (Tenn.) Republican of March 9, said:—
“In these cases the defendants have been adjudged guilty, after a fair and impartial trial by jury, of violating that day which is recognized by the law of our State as the Sabbath, and it now becomes my duty, painful though it be, to pronounce judgment upon them.
“While our sympathies are with the defendants, and while they perhaps have good grounds for their faith, yet this is a temporal, not a spiritual court, and we cannot pass upon questions of belief. The only questions we have to deal with are, ‘What is the law?’ and, ‘Has the law been violated?’ The law is plain, and it is not only our sworn duty to enforce it, but to encourage respect for all law in general. As individuals we may each have our own opinions as to the justice of a law, yet as public officials intrusted with its enforcement, our duty is unequivocal. A co-ordinate branch of the government is intrusted by the people with the law-making power, and when this power is exercised within constitutional limits, the judiciary can do nothing but enforce the law thus enacted. The supreme court of this State, whose decisions must be taken as final by the lower courts, has passed upon this question, and we cannot rightfully reverse its decisions.
“If I were to express my private feelings, however, I might say that there is nothing I regard with more concern or solicitude than an encroachment of legislative enactment upon the personal rights of the individual in matters of conscience. That there is a limit in these matters beyond which legislation cannot rightfully go, will be conceded by every man. Where is that limit? This is a question which even the enlightened civilization of the nineteenth century, it seems, cannot answer. Human laws are of necessity imperfect. One class of individuals will claim that their rights are encroached upon in this way; another, in that way, and so on. This arises from diversity and shades of opinion. These questions, it seems, cannot be settled to suit everybody. As to the cases at the bar, the large majority of the people honestly and conscientiously believe that secular labor on Sunday is a desecration of the true Sabbath and that this tends to corrupt public morals. That this belief pervades the people at large is fully evidenced by the several laws we have prohibiting various things as tending to desecrate that day. These laws would not exist but for public sentiment in their favor.
“The masses for hundreds of years have thought, and they still think, that public morality requires the observance of the day which has been recognized practically by all Christian denominations as the sabbath. As to the constitutionality of these laws it is true that grave doubts are entertained by many who adhere to Sunday as the sabbath. While every man is guaranteed the right to worship as his conscience dictates, and while no law respecting the establishment of religion can be passed, yet this has always been interpreted to mean that no particular creed or form of religion shall be prescribed, and that Church and State shall remain divorced.
“All our laws recognize Christianity in general as the basis of our civilization, and laws for its protection have always been regarded as in keeping not only with the Constitution but with public policy. Sunday is and for a long time has been recognized by nearly all Christian denominations as the sabbath; and it is for this reason, no doubt, that the laws which protect that day have always been acquiesced in as constitutional. They have never been regarded as laws which prescribe any particular belief, but as laws which protect the unanimous belief of nearly all Christian denominations. But here we have a respectable element of Christian believers who are honest, inoffensive, law-abiding citizens in all matters not conflicting with their sense of duty, who believe they are under divine command to observe the seventh day as the Sabbath. As a matter of abstract individual right, can they be required to observe another day also?
“Their position is not that of the person who claims that as a matter of personal liberty, he has the right, if he chooses, to run an open saloon on Sunday, or to do any like act. That is not a matter of conscience, this is. They claim that it is not only their right but their duty under divine command to observe the seventh day. Calling them ‘cranks’ does not settle the question. If there were only one of them, he would be entitled not only to his belief but to the exercise of that belief, so long as in so doing he does not interfere with any natural right of his neighbor. A man cannot kill another and excuse himself by claiming that he believed he was carrying out God’s will in so doing, because this would deprive his victim of a natural right; viz., the enjoyment of life. Do the defendants in keeping the seventh day and working on the first, thereby interfere with any natural right of their neighbors? or is it an artificial right created by statute? Has any power but the divine will the right to establish any one day as Sabbath? If the day has been set by divine edict, but two or more persons honestly differ as to what day was appointed, can the dispute be settled by legislative enactment? These are grave questions upon which no opinion is now ventured, but they go as to the justice of the law, and not as to what the law is. There can be no dispute as to what the law is, and our duty is plain, and we must follow it. If the law is wrong, the remedy is not to be found in the courts. The consensus of Christian sentiment favors Sunday observance, and while the law commands its observance, the courts will enforce the law.”
It is but just to say that the feeling among the better element in the community is decidedly against the prosecutions. Graysville is suffering in a business way from the persecution, because the town has been built up largely by the establishment of the academy; and since it was known that the indictments were found last November, real estate has depreciated 50 per cent. But the fact remains, nevertheless, that where laws are enacted which make such prosecutions possible, there are always irresponsible persons who care nothing for the results either to the Adventists or to the community at large, and will drag the seventh-day observers before the courts. Wives may be deprived of their husbands, and children of their fathers; schools may be broken up, and disappointment and loss inflicted upon the students; but what is that to men who have no sense of justice or of right, and who are controlled only by feelings of bigotry and intolerance? The bar of the county is almost a unit in opposition to the prosecution. The judge’s language in passing judgment upon the cases cannot be mistaken. It is an arraignment of the law as unjust. The three papers published in Dayton are likewise unanimous in condemning the persecution of the Adventists as unrighteous from a standpoint of justice, and as unpolitic from a business standpoint. These facts all go to illustrate the truth of the words of Thomas Jefferson, that where a bad law is on the statute-books, ‘a single bigot’ may set the machinery of the law in motion, and ‘better men be his victims.’
In view of the facts thus briefly stated, the question arises: What are the people of Tennessee, and of other States, and of the United States, going to do about the existence of statutes which make such things possible? Is the American sense of justice dead? Is it indeed true of this country that “judgment is turned away backward, and justice standeth afar off; for truth is fallen in the street, and equity cannot enter. Yea, truth faileth; and he that departeth from evil maketh himself a prey.”
The Adventists do not, as some have thoughtlessly asserted, court persecution. They have in several States exhausted every legal remedy in seeking relief from oppressive laws. They have twice appealed to the supreme court of Tennessee, and once to the United States Circuit Court. They refuse to pay fines, as before stated, because to do so would be to acknowledge that they are indebted to the State. They maintain that they have violated no proper law, that their punishment is unjust, and that taking their property to pay fines is nothing short of robbery. They do not resist the officers, but they will not become parties to the injustice by voluntarily paying fines; but as Elder Holmes, the Baptist, when commanded to remove his coat 200 years ago that he might be whipped, said: “I will not so much as unbutton a single button,” so the Adventists say, “We will not pay a single penny. We will suffer imprisonment, if we must, and the loss of property if it is taken from us, but we havep. 206 defrauded no man, and we will not voluntarily pay money for the free exercise of our God-given rights.”
It is true that as compared with the great mass, the Adventists are but a handful; as has been sneeringly said by one of their enemies, they amount to but “one seventh of one per cent of the population of the country;” but is it not true, as stated by Judge Parks, that “if there were only one of them, he would be entitled not only to his belief but to the exercise of that belief, so long as in doing so he does not interfere with any natural right of his neighbor”? What answer will the American press and people return to this question?