ROME'S RELATION TO GUATEMALA AND THE UNITED STATES.
By M. E. K.
The republic of Guatemala has, to some extent, broken the fetters of religious tyranny, and granted a fair measure of liberty to her people. This is releasing them from the yoke of the priests, and of course it is not pleasing to the Roman Church. Guatemala now has no representative in Rome, as Nicaragua and other Central and South American States have. Mgr. Satolli not long since took it upon himself to instruct the Guatemalan government as to her best interests in this matter, and his letters are now given to the public. This is said to be the first time that Satolli has allowed his zeal for his church to lead him to a discussion in affairs of a civil nature. In urging the Guatemalan government to renew her official relations with the papacy, he made certain statements which are of interest to the people of this country. Thus he says:— “In the first place, allow me to suggest that to re-establish diplomatic relations between the Holy See and your government, a ‘concordat’ would not be necessary, but that they could be re-established and maintained without it. Besides, it is well to reflect that the holy father enjoys always, in fact and by international right, the prerogatives of sovereignty. In the second place, the separation between the Church and the State (sanctioned by the Constitution) excluded the action of one power over another in civil matters in regard to the church, and in religious matters in respect to the State, but does not exclude official relations between the one power and the other, unless by separation is meant the inevitable hostility or open wrong of the civil power toward the church and its ministry.” A “concordat” is the term that is usually applied to the treaties between civil sovereigns and the papacy. Satolli thinks such a regularly drawn treaty is not needed to establish “diplomatic relations” between a country and the pope. He even says that the fact that the constitution of a country excludes the church from the control of the civil power, and the civil power from the control of the church, does not thereby imply that official relations may not still be maintained, “unless by separation is meant the inevitable hostility or open wrong of the civil power toward the church and its ministry.” This is really saying that a nation, although it has in its constitution an article debarring the State from any connection with religion, can enter into diplomatic relations with the Roman See, because the pope enjoys the “prerogatives of sovereignty” (is a sovereign), and because such separation would not mean hostility to the church. Of course this was written primarily in reference to the relations of Guatemala with the See of Rome; but that it was written with a view of the application of the same principles to the United States, is evident for two reasons: (1) Guatemala now occupies a relation to Rome similar to that of the United States; and (2) Satolli does not hesitate to refer to the relations of the United States to Rome to illustrate his idea. Hence he makes the following statements:— “The condition of the Catholic Church in the United States, in whose Constitution was inserted the article of separation of the State from any religious sect, cannot escape our consideration. If up to date no official relations exist between the government and the Holy See, it is because the majority of the population is anti-Catholic. In the meantime the church here is attaining possibly greater development and liberty than in other countries.” Remember that Satolli has been trying to prove that there is nothing in the way of diplomatic relations between the Papal See and Guatemala, and now he tries to show that the United States government sustains a similar relation to the papacy! If this should be accomplished, and the Catholic religion through its representative head shall be joined in diplomatic relations with the government of this nation, then of course the other great religious bodies here will clamor for the same relation! They may not have a “sovereign” for a head, but they have religion; and as the separation of religion and the State cannot mean “hostility toward the church,” they will claim their share of patronage and power; so that we may not only have a Catholic legate to this government, but a Methodist, an Episcopalian, a Presbyterian, etc. The church cards are now being shuffled for a new deal, and the United States is the object of the game. While these selfish and un-Christian schemes for church aggrandizement are in progress, the truth in regard to the relations of Christianity to governments is being taught. True Christianity does not seek the aid of the civil power; the desire of a church for the aid of that power is of itself an evidence of departure from Christ.