AdventAI

THE OBJECTOR BURIED.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 12., March 19, 1895

Under the caption, “The Ten Commandments,” a writer in the Restitution premises that some one has “taken out six props from under the Sabbath,” and he proposes to “remove the seventh and let the delusion fall.” This is thought to be done in the following ingenious and original manner: Calling attention to the fact that when the Lord proclaimed the ten commandments to Israel, he declared himself to be the God who had brought them out of bondage in Egypt; he supposes that the Lord takes the ten commandments and reads them to different persons, Adam, Noah, and Abraham; but they all protest that the ten commandments do not apply to them, because they never were in Egyptian bondage! Then he has the Lord read them to Moses, and Moses exclaims, “Why, yes; these laws belong to the children of Israel.” Not satisfied to stop at Moses, he makes a tremendous spring forward in time, and has the Lord read the same law to Christ. But he makes Jesus say, “Lord, I never was in Egyptian bondage.” And so he is exempted from allegiance to the ten commandments. The conclusion is then reached that these laws were neither binding before Moses nor since Christ!

But right here it may be remarked that he does not make his examination thorough enough; for, in his great anxiety to get quickly from Moses to Christ, he has not taken into account a large number of very good people who lived between the time of Christ and the time of Moses. There were Samuel, David, Elijah, Isaiah, and many others. Let us try this very wonderful argument on them. Were they ever in Egypt?—Not one of them. Then they were never delivered from Egyptian bondage. Why, then, should they keep the Sabbath, since they can bring the same excuse for not keeping it that has been manufactured for Adam, Noah, and Abraham? for if those only who have been in Egyptian bondage are required to observe the Sabbath, the obligation to keep it would have expired by degrees, as that generation, that was actually delivered from Egypt, was removed by death. In this case Sabbath-keeping would have been a thing of the past in the early years of Israel’s occupation of the promised land.

Should an objection to this conclusion be raised on the ground that the Israelites after Moses’s time were descendants of those who came out of Egypt, and were therefore under obligations to keep the Sabbath, it should be remarked that they never were actually in Egypt, and that actual residence and bondage in Egypt is claimed to be the only and sole reason for keeping the Sabbath. Moreover, this writer excepted Christ from keeping the Sabbath on this ground, and on no other. And if Christ, who, as an actual descendant of those who came out of Egypt, was thus relieved from Sabbath-keeping, why not Joseph and Mary, and so on back until their ancestors who actually came out of Egypt are reached? This would remove the Sabbath from a long period, during which time no one questions its obligation.

One more position in the same article will be noticed: The writer, in his anxiety to prove that the Sabbath need not now be observed, tries to show a great difference between the Old and the New Testament, in the following manner: He goes to Ex. 20:5, where the Lord declares himself to be a “jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me,” and then says, “Do you believe that to be the case now, under the gospel?” Then he quotes from the New Testament to show that God will receive all who come to him, and that all must give an account of themselves to God. Well, does the text quoted from Exodus say that he would not receive all who came to him?—It does not. Was it not about that time that the Lord declared himself to be “the Lord, the Lord God, merciful and gracious, long-suffering, and abundant in goodness and truth, keeping mercy for thousands, forgiving iniquity and transgression and sin”? Ex. 34:6, 7. The character of God has not changed. A mistaken idea of the meaning of Ex. 20:5 has led this writer to a wrong conclusion,—that God, now merciful, was once harsh and vindictive. No such idea can rightly be gathered from that text. The Lord does not say there that he will punish children for the iniquity of their fathers. When in the days of Israel’s captivity some of those in bondage claimed that they were suffering because of their father’s sins, the Lord by his prophet emphatically repudiated that idea, and declared that “the son shall not bear the iniquity of the father.” Ezek. 18:20.

But to return to Ex. 20:5: “Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them [images], nor serve them; for I the Lord thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them” that love me?—Ah, no! That is a misquotation. It is “to the third and fourth generation of them that hate me,” that the Lord says that he will visit the iniquity of the fathers upon the children. If a son, seeing all the evil of his father’s life, pursues the same downward path, thus doing evil himself, and thereby sanctioning the evil course of his father, God holds him measurably, responsible for the evil that he thus imitates. This is as emphatically stated in the New as in the Old Testament. All the righteous blood shed upon the earth from Abel’s time down to the time of Christ was required of those who put him to death (Matt. 23:25), and in the day of final retribution God finds in great Babylon the “blood of prophets, and of saints, and of all that were slain upon the earth.” Rev. 18:24.

This should be sufficient to show that God is not a reformed tyrant, better now than he was then, and that there is no conflict between Ex. 20:5 and the statements of God’s mercy in the New Testament. God is the same. The gospel light shines clearer now than in past ages, but it was the gospel then, for men were then saved, and saved by the gospel, for that is the only way of salvation.

From these considerations the conclusion is reached that this latest attempt to take away the support of the Sabbath, will, like its six predecessors, have but very little effect upon the stability of that venerable and beneficent institution. Rather, this clumsy attempt to knock a prop from under the Sabbath has loosened a mass of Scriptural evidence underneath which this would-be objector is buried out of sight.

M. E. K.