AdventAI

IDLE WORDS.

By George I. Butler

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 10., March 5, 1895

“But I say unto you, That every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account thereof in the day of judgment. For by thy words thou shalt be justified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned.” Matt. 12:36, 37. Webster’s first definition given of “idle” is, “of no account; useless; vain,” etc. The definition would naturally include unnecessary words,—words which might as well not have been spoken; subserving no useful purpose, needless, etc. It is safe to say there is hardly a person living of whom it could be said, Every word he speaks is essential and really demanded by the occasion. Is it such words as these of which our Saviour speaks? or rather words of malice, wicked words concerning God and things excellent and sacred; words that injure others and manifest inward depravity and the spirit of Satan? Perhaps a careful consideration of the context will shed some light on this point.

Our Lord gave a short discourse containing some very important points embraced between verses 22 and 37, of Matthew 12, closing with the words quoted at the beginning of this article. This discourse was called out by the fact that when he had cast out a demon from one blind and dumb whom he completely healed, causing great amazement among the people and leading them to think that he, as the son of David, should be their deliverer and king, the Pharisees, to break his influence, showed the terrible malice of their hearts by saying, “This fellow doth not cast out devils, but by Beelzebub, the prince of devils.” It would seem from the connection that they did not say this to him in a public manner, but did it in a private way,p. 154 going about among the people using their strongest efforts to destroy his influence among them.

The Pharisees were the leading religionists among the people, looked up to with even more reverence than the leading clergy and so-called National Reformers are now among us. It was they who had charge of the synagogues and filled many of the most honorable positions among the religious classes. And we may readily suppose that in their efforts to make the people believe that Jesus was a bad man, and hence one that Beelzebub would work through, was the fact that the Saviour paid so little heed to their various traditions, especially those they had heaped up on the observance of the Sabbath, as they very often accused him of Sabbath-breaking; their traditions then being dearer to their hearts than the commandments of God, the same as we see to-day among the observers of the Sunday Sabbath. It is very probable that by their cunning sophistry in this use of their powerful influence as teachers in the synagogues, they did much to destroy the effect of Christ’s wonderful miracles upon the public mind. Hence Jesus felt it necessary to strip off this hypocritical covering and expose their wickedness.

“And Jesus knew their thoughts [from which it would seem that their words had not been spoken in his personal presence], and said unto them, Every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation; and every city or house divided against itself shall not stand; and if Satan cast out Satan, he is divided against himself; how shall then his kingdom stand?” In these few words he clearly demonstrated the utter absurdity of their statements. It was a special triumph of Satan and his angels, to obtain complete possession of individuals, thus depriving them of their freedom of will, and having full control over them to their utter ruin. Unless this power was broken, such were irretrievably lost. Would Satan, when he had once secured this object so much desired, empower Jesus to come and utterly drive out the demon and restore the poor sufferer to his normal condition of a free moral agent? Most absurd.

Having clearly demonstrated this point, he proceeded to show that his power thus to defeat Satan was a demonstration of the power and presence of the kingdom of God; for none but a stronger than Satan could thus dislodge this mighty foe, since he is much stronger than any human power. “He that is not with me is against me; and he that gathereth not with me scattereth abroad.”

He next set before them the awful nature of this wicked, malicious accusation. It is nothing less than blaspheming the Holy Spirit by attributing the work of that divine agency to God’s greatest enemy. When men thus permit Satan to actuate them, they cut themselves off from the sole means of their own salvation. The Spirit is the connecting link between fallen man and Christ. When, to gratify his malice, a person thus traduces this blessed medium, its strivings with him cease, and he is lost forever, like the man overboard who cuts the rope thrown to rescue him. This sin in its consequences is utterly ruinous. “Either make [or declare] the tree good, and his fruit good; or else make the tree corrupt, and his fruit corrupt; for the tree is known by his fruit.” There is nothing surer in nature than the fact that the fruit always shows the nature of the tree. It was impossible to counterfeit such works as Jesus did. There was no possible excuse for attributing them to a Satanic source. Their course demonstrated that they were a “generation of vipers,” the brood of the old serpent, filled with his malice against Christ. They must needs show forth this malice in their words because that spirit was the one they cherished. The words we use show the nature of the heart from which they proceed.

Then come the words upon which we are commenting: “But I say unto you, That every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account thereof in the day of judgment. For by thy words thou shalt be justified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned.” This closes the subject under consideration, and a new theme is introduced. These words, then, are his final conclusion. He is dwelling all the way through upon the wicked words of the Pharisees on this occasion, and showing to those whom they had been seeking to influence the malice, the blasphemy, and the final doom of such conduct. It will come up for final decision in the last great day of judgment, and all such will be lost.

What he said about idle words is the logical deduction, the final conclusion, of his quoted remarks. This passage cannot properly be disconnected from the theme upon which he had been dwelling. He had not said anything concerning merely trivial, unnecessary words. These, to be sure, are elsewhere condemned in the Bible, and we would by no means seek to justify them; but they were not the subject here. Neither do we recall anywhere in Holy Writ any passage where such strong language is applied to unnecessary words. The connection here seems fully to demonstrate that the kind of words which our Saviour so strongly denounced are malicious, wicked words, calculated to ruin souls, and such as are prompted by the spirit of Satan. The Diaglott renders the term, “pernicious words.” Greenfield’s Lexicon renders the term in this text, “unprofitable, useless, by implication, injurious words.” Evidently this is the true sense of the passage. With this view, the passage is consistent throughout; otherwise the meaning seems strained.

G. I. B.