DANGER IN MILK AND ITS PRODUCTS.
[THE following from the Medical World so fully exposes the many dangers to which we are exposed, that we bespeak a careful perusal.—ED.] “Editor Medical World: Milk and milk products are in very general use in all civilized countries. Milk is considered the type of a perfect food, containing, as it does, all the proximate principles necessary for the growth and sustenance of the human body. Infants are raised on it, and it is the basis of many prepared infant foods, whose strongest claims are that they are nearly identical with the standard average of mothers’ milk. Probably no one article of diet is more frequently prescribed for invalids by physicians than milk in some form. Good milk, pure milk, cannot be too highly recommended. But current events remind us not infrequently that impure milk and its products are sources of disease, and sometimes the cause of death. “It may not be unprofitable to consider some of the elements of danger. And first, as to the cow. Tuberculosis in cattle is widely prevalent. It occurs most frequently, perhaps, in thoroughbred cows, due, probably to in-and-in breeding, or too much housing and pampering. During the past year many choice herds of blooded cattle in New York have been examined by official inspectors, and condemned and slaughtered, because they were infected with tuberculosis. Even with the most careful official scrutiny, milk from tuberculous cows has been delivered to innocent customers for family use, and for the feeding of young children. Within the past month, a well-known milk company, that derives part of its supply from Orange county, in this State,—a county with a world-wide reputation for its dairy products,—discovered that milk from tuberculous herds was being delivered at one of its stations. While the high reputation of this company is a guaranty that the impure milk was detected and rejected at the earliest possible moment, there is good reason for closely scrutinizing the product supplied by less watchful and less scrupulous purveyors. “That tuberculosis in cattle may be conveyed by milk and beef to human beings, is too well established to admit of a doubt. It has been said that in some countries, and among certain sects where meat and milk are not used, there is no trace of tuberculosis among the people. I am unable to verify this, but I think it is possible if not highly probable. “A well-authenticated case of tubercular transmission occurred recently, not far from New York City. A few months since a grandchild of the late Henry Ward Beecher died from tubercular meningitis. The diagnosis was beyond doubt, but the cause, or source, of the disease was not evident. No probable cause presented itself to the attending physicians. The parents were healthy, the surroundings excellent. So carefully had the child been reared, that among other precautions, a thoroughbred and costly cow had been purchased to furnish the supply of milk for the family. Finally, the attention of the physicians was turned toward the source of the milk supply. The family cow was apparently healthy, but a veterinarian was called, and on examination it was conclusively proved that the choice cow had tuberculosis, and that, beyond doubt, she was the cause of the illness and death of the child. Not every case can be so directly traced to its source, but the lesson from this one indicates that, beyond doubt, there have been many such. “Having good, healthy cows, the next thing is to see that the stables and surroundings, persons and utensils, are always scrupulously clean. The ideal rosy-cheeked, tripping milkmaid, with white cap and apron, is found chiefly in poetry and painting. The actual milkmaid is more likely to be a son of Erin, or of the sod, who smokes his dhudeen while he pulls the taps of the waiting kine, and mingles his tobacco smoke with the lacteal fluid. Should the cow be clean and the pail clean, the usual process of straining is little more than a formality. Unfortunately, however, many stables, yards, and cows are filthy beyond description. Chunks of manure and sodden straws drop from the cows into the milk-pails, making a mild infusion of manure—a sort of lactate of feces. Straining will remove the coarser particles, but the product is not pleasant to contemplate as an article of diet for delicate stomachs. “Nor is the odor of such stables suggestive of the classical ‘sweet breath of the kine.’ It soon makes the uninitiated long for a breath of fresh air. In this aroma, so pungent and penetrating, the milk can hardly escape being affected. Now, this picture of dairy stables and surroundings is strictly within the lines of truth, although it almost causes one’s gorge to rise at the thought of it. If this be true of a proportion of country and dry-feed dairies, how infinitely worse are the swill-milk stables, where cows are stall-fed on brewers’ grains, until they become a mass of toothless, stump-tailed rottenness. Swill-milk feeding has been somewhat diminished since the notable crusades of the illustrated papers some years ago, but it is by no means totally suppressed. “On the outskirts of this city, in a landlocked basin, stands an old ramshackle cow stable, beside a nasty, stinking pond-hole, that takes the drainage from the stables and other buildings. Here, in warm weather, may be seen the cows up to their bellies in the liquid filth, fighting their natural enemies, the flies. The deadly odor from this abominable place is only too apparent a quarter of a mile away. Near the barn stand fancy-painted milk wagons, bearing the legend, ‘Pure Orange County Milk.’ How fortunate those families that can get ‘one cow’s milk’ from this choice dairy, on which to rear the infant struggling with dentition, cholera infantum, and marasmus! “That typhoid fever is conveyed in milk is only of too common occurrence. Among recent outbreaks of this kind were those at Barnegat Bay and Mont Clair, N. J. In Mont Clair more than a hundred persons had typhoid from milk that came from a single dairy, and there were many deaths. If I remember rightly, the owner of the dairy himself also fell a victim to the disease.134 Before the epidemic was recognized, in one family of my acquaintance several members appeared to suffer from a sort of ill-defined malaria. Partly of their own accord, and partly by the doctor’s advice, they refrained somewhat from the ordinary table-food, and lived chiefly upon milk diet, as better suited to their ailing condition. This proved to be particularly unfortunate, as the more milk they used from the infected dairy, the more typhoid germs they took into their systems, for the infected milk was the cause and the aggravation of their illness. Of this family five members had typhoid fever, and three died. “How susceptible milk or cream is to putrefaction or chemical changes, is shown by the cases of wholesale poisoning by ice cream, that are of no unusual occurrence. For a long time these sudden cases of illness following picnics and festivals were ascribed to intentional poisoning by evil-minded persons. Sometimes it was believed that the poison came in the vanilla or other flavoring extract used in the manufacture of the cream. Finally, however, the true nature of the changes leading to the production of the ptomaine, tyrotoxicon, was definitely determined by Professor Vaughn. This poison is possible also in butter and cheese. “That cheese may carry the germs of diphtheria has been very recently shown by the discovery by Dr. Beebe, of New York, in a consignment of cheeses from a creamery in the interior of this State. The explanation is that a farmer who supplied milk from which the cheese was made, had a case of diphtheria in his family. After mingling with the affected persons, he milked his cows, and through him the germs of the contagion were communicated to the milk, and none of the processes of cheese-making serving to eliminate them, they appeared in the ultimate product—the cheese. Butter may likewise be infected with various disease germs, either by being the product of tuberculous cows, by exposure as milk or cream, in the processes of butter-making, or even by unclean storage after it is made. “It is highly probable that many germ diseases of obscure origin have been disseminated through milk and its products. The sources and modes of conveyance of the diseases have been so remote, so subtle and unsuspected, as to escape detection; and thus, doubtless, has arisen the idea that certain communicable diseases, as scarlatina, diphtheria, typhoid, etc., have originated de novo—have resulted without a specific cause—a germ disease, without the essential producing germs. The failure has been in properly tracing such diseases to their real source. The aim of this cursory resume of this subject is not to discountenance the proper use of wholesome dairy products. If I could, I would first reach the dairyman, and urge him to be wise, careful, and discriminating, in even the smallest particular relating to milk, butter, and cheese. I would arouse the consumer to the vital importance of knowing the source of his dairy-products, how manipulated, and in what condition they are presented for consumption. “Last, but not least, it is the duty which physicians owe to their patients, to make themselves familiar with all the varying phases of this subject, and when milk is directed as an article of diet, to insist upon its coming from a pure source, properly handled, and properly prepared for infants and invalids.”—Benj. Edson, M. D.