AdventAI

THE PAPAL ENCYCLICAL AGAIN.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 7., February 12, 1895

ATTENTION was called in the last issue of the REVIEW to the papal encyclical pertaining to the Catholic Church in America, and especially to such portions as suggested Leo’s desire and intention to claim America for the Catholic Church. For many years, and especially of late, the American Catholics have been saying that the Catholic Church had all it wanted in this country; that they had equal rights under the laws, and full liberty to propagate their doctrines, make converts, and establish churches, and that that was all they desired. It was evident all the time that if they were telling the truth about this,—that they were satisfied with a condition of things here which they would not be satisfied with anywhere else, judging by their determined efforts in other countries to keep the entire control of the governments as they had done in the past. How there could be any sincerity in their claim that they had all they wanted here in simple equality and equal liberty, when in other countries such a measure of liberty and equality did not satisfy them at all, has always been a great query with Protestants. Still there is no doubt that many American Catholics believed it, and the fact that they did believe it and were liable to continue to do so, so alarmed Leo that he thought it time for this American but un-Roman idea to be eradicated from their heads; and he therefore made the statement, quoted in the last REVIEW, that the separation of the Church and the State as in this country was not the “most desirable status of the Church.”

The Catholic Mirror of Feb. 2, commenting editorially upon the encyclical, says that this was a “significant remark.” Yes, it was very significant; and what does it signify? It signifies that the position heretofore taken by the Catholics in this country—that liberty and equality with the Protestants is all they want here—is only a pretense and a sham; that the pope is afraid that if the American Catholics are not corrected by his infallible authority, they will soon actually believe themselves that liberty is all they want; and that the time has now arrived when this duplicity need no longer be practiced; but that the truth of the matter—that Catholics want a union with the State here as elsewhere, and the support of the laws of the country—may now be safely declared; that Rome here, in spite of her soft, sweet smiles and honeyed phrases, is the same as she is everywhere; and that she is aiming at nothing less than the complete subjection of this country to her authority. The pope plainly states that the “most desirable status of the Church” is not found here, and surely the most desirable state is none too good to be secured.

If these plain and unequivocal statements of the animus and desire of the Roman Church for a union with this government, contrary to our Constitution and our entire system of government, do not affect and stir to life the lingering sparks of Americanism and Protestantism in our land to a flame of indignant protest, we may conclude that the American people have fallen into a state of languid carelessness, premonitory of utter degeneration and decay, so great that there is no remedy. M. E. K.